Effects of Bionic Bone Flexibility on the Hydrodynamics of Pectoral Fins

Yonghui Cao, Tian Bao, Yingzhuo Cao, Pu Wang, Ou Yang, Yang LuJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the flexibility of pectoral fins, inspired by manta rays, impacts their hydrodynamic performance. By creating bionic fins with adjustable leading and trailing edge flexibility, the researchers found that a stiffer leading edge and a more flexible trailing edge significantly improve thrust, mimicking natural manta ray fin structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional underwater vehicles often rely on propellers, which can be noisy and less maneuverable. Manta ray-inspired vehicles, utilizing pectoral fin propulsion (MPF), offer advantages like stability, agility, and quiet operation. However, understanding how the fin's inherent flexibility contributes to efficient propulsion is crucial for designing more effective bio-inspired underwater robots. While previous studies have touched upon flexibility, a quantitative relationship between specific flexibility distributions (leading vs. trailing edge) and hydrodynamic forces remains an open question.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Theoretical Analysis: They used thin-wing theory to analyze the hydrodynamics of a 2D flexible pectoral fin, identifying chordal curvature as a key factor influencing hydrodynamic forces.
  • Bionic Design: They designed a two-stage bionic skeleton for pectoral fins, allowing for independent control of leading and trailing edge flexibility. This flexibility was characterized by varying the root-to-tip width ratio of the bionic skeleton.
  • Flexibility Measurement: A tensiometer was used to quantitatively measure the static flexibility of the designed pectoral fins. Relative flexibility was then calculated by normalizing against the least flexible design.
  • Experimental Measurement: A six-dimensional force sensor was used to measure the thrust and lift generated by the bionic pectoral fins during flapping in a controlled water environment.
  • Data Analysis: Experimental data was normalized and analyzed to correlate flexibility with hydrodynamic performance. Polynomial fitting was used to establish quantitative relationships between relative flexibility and normalized thrust/lift. The influence of phase difference between leading and trailing edge movements was also investigated.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from their custom-designed bionic pectoral fins.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leading vs. Trailing Edge Flexibility Matters: The paper clearly demonstrates that the flexibility of the leading and trailing edges of the pectoral fin have distinct and significant effects on propulsion.
  • Stiffer Leading Edge, Softer Trailing Edge: A stiffer leading edge delays vortex shedding, leading to better thrust and lift. Conversely, a more flexible trailing edge increases the "wave number" of the fin's motion, enhancing thrust. This combination is key for optimal performance.
  • Mimicking Nature Works: The findings align with the observed skeletal flexibility distribution in real manta rays, where the trailing edge is generally more flexible than the leading edge. This suggests that bio-inspiration is a valid and effective design principle.
  • Phase Difference is Crucial: The interaction between fin flexibility and the phase difference of movement between the leading and trailing edges significantly impacts performance, with an optimal phase difference around 30 degrees identified.

Key Results

  • Thrust Improvement: Reducing leading-edge flexibility and increasing trailing-edge flexibility significantly improved thrust performance. For instance, a decrease in leading-edge flexibility led to a 12% increase in normalized thrust.
  • Lift Characteristics: Leading-edge flexibility showed a monotonic increase in normalized lift, while trailing-edge flexibility had a more pronounced effect, with higher flexibility leading to lower lift but a better thrust-to-lift ratio.
  • Optimal Flexibility Range: The study suggests a "middle level" of flexibility (around 3-4 for relative flexibility) can enhance propulsion.
  • Optimal Phase Difference: An ideal phase difference for pectoral fin movement was found to be around 10-30 degrees for optimal performance.
  • Quantitative Relationships: Polynomial fitting provided quantitative relationships between relative flexibility and normalized thrust/lift, showing strong correlations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • 2D Simplification: The study primarily focused on 2D flexible pectoral fins, while real fins are 3D. The paper acknowledges that spanwise deformation was ignored.
  • Static Flexibility: The flexibility was characterized based on static measurements, and the dynamic behavior of the fin under actual flapping conditions could be more complex.
  • Limited Frequency Range: Experiments were conducted within a specific frequency range, and performance at other frequencies might differ.

The authors propose future work to:

  • Investigate the 3D hydrodynamic performance of pectoral fins.
  • Utilize Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) to study the flow field structure around the pectoral fin wake.
  • Establish a more comprehensive pectoral fin design and performance evaluation system.

Summary updated

Abstract

Compared with traditional underwater equipment powered by propeller, the manta-ray-inspired vehicle with MPF mode (Median fin/paired fin) has the advantages of stable swimming attitude, high maneuverability, and low noise, etc. As one of the sources of advancing power when the manta-ray-inspired vehicle swims, the flexible deformation of the pectoral fin is an important factor affecting the hydrodynamic performance. In this paper, a mechanical analysis of the two-dimensional flexible pectoral fin using thin wing theory shows that the main factor affecting the hydrodynamic force of the two-dimensional flexible pectoral fin is the level of curvature of the pectoral fin chordal section. By designing a two-stage bionic skeleton at the leading and rear edges of the manta-ray-inspired vehicle, the root–tip section width of the bionic skeleton is used to characterize the level of the bionic pectoral fin’s flexibility, and a tensiometer is used to quantitatively measure the level of flexibility. The root-to-tip ratio of the cross-section was varied to obtain different levels of pectoral fin flexibility, and the hydrodynamic properties of the pectoral fins during flapping were measured using a force sensor and normalized for analysis. The experimental results show that the reduction of the flexibility of the leading edge and the increase of the flexibility of the rear edge are beneficial to the improvement of the thrust performance, and the experimental results are the same as the distribution of the skeletal flexibility in real organisms. Fitting curves of the pectoral fins’ relative flexibility and the normalized thrust/lift show that the flexibility of the pectoral fins has a significant effect on its hydrodynamic force, and a stiffer leading edge and a softer rear edge can improve the hydrodynamic characteristics of the manta-ray-inspired vehicle. Phase differences interacting with flexibility can also enhance bionic pectoral fins’ dynamic properties within 10~30 degree.
BibTeX
@article{cao2022effects,
  author = {Yonghui Cao and Tian Bao and Yingzhuo Cao and Pu Wang and Ou Yang and Yang Lu and Yong Cao},
  title = {{Effects of Bionic Bone Flexibility on the Hydrodynamics of Pectoral Fins}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse10070981},
}
Figure