Effects of baryons on the gravitational redshift profile of ΛCDM halos

Hongyu Zhu, Shadab Alam, Rupert A. C. Croft, Shirley Ho, Elena GiusarmaarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Gravitational redshifts are emerging as a powerful tool for testing General Relativity on cosmic scales. However, most theoretical predictions rely on dark-matter-only (DMO) simulations, neglecting the influence of baryonic processes. This study investigates how gas cooling, star formation, and feedback in massive galaxy clusters alter their gravitational potential wells and, consequently, their gravitational redshift profiles. Using the MassiveBlack-II (MBII) hydrodynamic simulation, we find that baryons significantly deepen central potentials, leading to an increase in predicted gravitational redshifts by up to 50% in group-sized halos compared to DMO models. We provide updated halo profile fits to account for these effects in future observational tests of gravity.

Introduction

In General Relativity, light escaping a massive object undergoes a gravitational redshift ($z_g$), losing energy as it climbs out of the gravitational potential well. Measuring this effect in galaxy clusters provides a direct test of the relationship between matter density and gravity. While dark matter dominates the total mass of these clusters, baryonic matter (gas and stars) undergoes non-gravitational processes like radiative cooling that allow it to concentrate in the cluster centers. This concentration can significantly alter the shape and depth of the gravitational potential, yet many current models for $z_g$ profiles are based on simplistic DMO simulations.

Methods and Simulations

To isolate the impact of baryons, we compared two versions of the same cosmic volume: the MassiveBlack-II (MBII) hydrodynamic simulation and its DMO counterpart. MBII includes sophisticated physics for gas cooling, star formation, and black hole feedback. We analyzed the 9 most massive, relaxed halos in both simulations, calculating the gravitational potential ($\Phi$) for every particle to derive the $z_g$ profile ($z_g \approx \Delta\Phi/c^2$).

Baryonic Amplification of the Redshift Signal

The primary finding is a substantial "adiabatic contraction" effect. As baryons cool and condense at the center of a halo, their added mass pulls the surrounding dark matter inward. This synergy creates a much steeper and deeper central potential "pit" than what is found in DMO models.

As shown in the figure above, the total gravitational redshift signal in the hydrodynamic simulation is markedly higher than in the DMO case, particularly within the inner $100 \text{ kpc}/h$. For massive clusters, this baryonic effect adds an extra ~8 km/s to the signal, representing a nearly 50% boost over DMO-based expectations.

Consistency Across the Halo Sample

This enhancement is not an outlier but a consistent feature across the studied sample. The inclusion of baryons leads to density profiles that are 30% to 50% more concentrated ($c_{200}$) than their DMO counterparts.

The bar chart above illustrates that for every halo in our sample (H1-H9), the characteristic overdensity $\delta_c$—a measure of how "packed" the center is—is significantly higher when baryonic physics is included. This increased concentration is the physical driver behind the amplified gravitational redshift signal.

Conclusion

Our results demonstrate that baryonic physics is a first-order effect in predicting the gravitational redshift profiles of galaxy clusters. Standard Navarro-Frenk-White (NFW) profiles, which are often used to model DMO halos, fail to capture the steepened inner potentials caused by baryons. We find that generalized NFW (gNFW) or Einasto profiles provide much better fits. By providing accurate templates that account for these baryonic effects, this work enables more robust tests of General Relativity using upcoming large-scale structure surveys.

Summary updated

Abstract

Gravitational redshifts and other relativistic effects are beginning to be studied in the context of galaxy clustering. Distortions consistent with those expected in General Relativity have been measured in galaxy cluster redshift profiles by Wojtak et al. and others and in the the cross-correlation function of galaxy populations by Alam et al. On scales below ~20 Mpc/$h$ simulations have shown that gravitational redshift dominates over other effects. However, this signal is related to the shape and depth of gravitational potentials, and therefore the matter density in galaxies and galaxy clusters that is responsible for them. We investigate the effects of baryonic physics on the gravitational redshift profiles of massive (group and cluster-sized) halos. We compare the profiles of different components in halos taken from the MassiveBlack-II cosmological hydrodynamic simulation and a dark matter-only version of the same simulation. We find that inclusion of baryons, cooling, star formation and feedback significantly alters the relevant inner density profiles. These baryonic effects lead to overall increases in both gravitational redshifts and the transverse relativistic Doppler effects by up to ~50% for group size halos. We show how modified Navarro Frenk White halo profiles can be used to parametrize these differences, and provide relevant halo profile fits.
BibTeX
@misc{zhu2019effects,
  author = {Hongyu Zhu and Shadab Alam and Rupert A. C. Croft and Shirley Ho and Elena Giusarma},
  title = {{Effects of baryons on the gravitational redshift profile of ΛCDM halos}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1901.05615},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.05615},
}

Loading related content...

Figure