Effects of Bandwidth on Ear Differentiation and Grain Yield Formation of Maize in Strip Intercropping

Liang Bing, Jingjing Li, Xuyang Zhao, Xinhui Lei, Guopeng Chen, Pu Tian, Yushan Wu, Taiwen Yong, Feng Yang, Xiaochun Wang, Wenyu YangPlants 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the width of the intercropped band (bandwidth) affects maize ear development and grain yield in a strip intercropping system. Researchers found that wider bandwidths negatively impact ear differentiation and reduce yield by altering dry matter allocation and increasing abortion rates. The optimal bandwidths of 1.6m and 2.0m were identified as crucial for stabilizing yield and improving resource utilization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Strip intercropping, a practice where different crops are grown in alternating strips, is gaining traction as a way to boost land productivity and resource utilization. In maize strip intercropping, particularly with legumes, wider bands (bandwidths) are often favored to improve light capture for the wider row and facilitate mechanized farming. However, there's a critical question: does increasing this bandwidth, while beneficial for some aspects, actually hinder the maize's own yield potential? Specifically, how does bandwidth influence the intricate process of ear differentiation and development, which directly dictates grain yield? This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by systematically examining the effects of varying bandwidths on maize ear development and yield formation, seeking to identify an optimal range for this crucial parameter.

Methods

The researchers employed a single-factor randomized block design to test four different bandwidths for maize strip intercropping: 1.6 m (T1), 2.0 m (T2), 2.4 m (T3), and 2.8 m (T4). For comparison, they used monoculture maize with corresponding row spacings (K1-K4) as controls. Key measurements included:

  • Light Transmittance: Using a canopy analyzer (SunScan), they measured photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) in both the wide and narrow rows to understand light availability.
  • Ear Differentiation and Development: This involved detailed observations of young ear development from the V7 stage onwards, including floret differentiation, tasseling and silking times, and the anthesis-silking interval (ASI).
  • Dry Matter Partitioning: At the silking stage, plant tissues (stems, leaves, ears) were separated and weighed to determine how resources were allocated.
  • Yield and Yield Components: At maturity, they measured grain number per ear (GPE), 1000-grain weight (TGW), and overall maize yield (M).
  • Abortion Rates: Floret abortion rate (FAR) and grain abortion rate (GAR) were calculated to quantify losses during development.

Statistical analysis was performed using ANOVA and Duncan's test to identify significant differences between treatments.

Datasets

The study utilized field data collected over two growing seasons (2022 and 2023) at the Chongzhou Modern Agricultural Research and Development Base in Sichuan Province, China. Meteorological data (monthly rainfall, effective accumulated temperature, and solar effective radiation) for the growth periods were sourced from NASA. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on experimental field trials.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Goldilocks Zone" for Bandwidth: The study strongly suggests that there's an optimal bandwidth for maize strip intercropping. Too narrow might limit light for the wider row, while too wide seems to negatively impact the maize's own ear development.
  • Dry Matter Misdirection: Wider bandwidths appear to "trick" the maize plant. It shifts dry matter allocation away from the developing ear and towards leaves, likely as a response to perceived light limitations or competition, even if overall light is available.
  • Abortion is Key: The increased allocation to leaves, coupled with other stress responses, leads to a higher rate of floret and grain abortion, directly reducing the number of viable kernels.
  • ASI's Subtle Role: While ASI was affected by intercropping, it didn't reach a threshold to significantly impact fertilization itself, suggesting other factors are more critical for yield loss in this context.
  • Intercropping Enhances Sensitivity: The study highlights that intercropping, particularly with varying bandwidths, makes maize more sensitive to factors affecting ear development and grain filling.

Key Results

  • Light Distribution: Wider bandwidths (T3, T4) significantly increased light transmittance in the wide row but drastically reduced it in the narrow row compared to monoculture.
  • Dry Matter Partitioning: As bandwidth increased, dry matter partitioning to ears decreased, while partitioning to leaves increased. This effect was significant in T3 (2.4m) and T4 (2.8m).
  • Ear Development Inhibition: Wider bandwidths (T3, T4) delayed ear differentiation. Floret abortion rate (FAR) and grain abortion rate (GAR) were significantly higher in T3 and T4 compared to their monoculture counterparts.
  • Yield Losses: Maize yield decreased significantly with increasing bandwidth. T4 (2.8m) showed yield losses of 26.9% and 31.6% compared to its monoculture control (K4) and the narrowest intercropping treatment (T1), respectively.
  • Optimal Bandwidths: Bandwidths of 1.6 m (T1) and 2.0 m (T2) were found to stabilize dry matter partitioning to the ear, ear length, and abortion rates, leading to more stable maize yields.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study was conducted in a specific region (Sichuan Province, China) and under particular environmental conditions. While they identified optimal bandwidths for this context, further research might be needed to validate these findings across different agro-climatic zones and maize varieties. Future work could also explore the genetic basis of maize's response to varying bandwidths and investigate the interaction effects with different legume species in strip intercropping systems. The study also suggests that in regions with abundant solar and thermal resources, expanding bandwidth or increasing planting density could be explored, but this needs careful consideration of the trade-offs identified in this research.

Summary updated

Abstract

In strip intercropping, increasing bandwidth enhances light energy utilization and facilitates mechanized production, yet it constrains the realization of maize yield advantages. The impact of bandwidth on the ear differentiation and development and yield formation requires further investigation. In this study, different bandwidths (T1, 1.6 m, T2, 2.0 m, T3, 2.4 m, and T4, 2.8 m) were arranged, and monoculture maize with varying row spacings (K1, 0.8 m, K2, 1.0 m, K3, 1.2 m, and K4, 1.4 m) was used as the control. The results show that increasing bandwidth inhibited the ear differentiation. The proportion of dry matter partitioning to leaves increased and to ears decreased, resulting in shorter ear length and higher floret and grain abortion rates. Maize yield losses amounted to 26.9% and 31.6% in T4 compared to K4 and T1, respectively. Moreover, the bandwidth did not affect the fertilized florets due to the smaller anthesis-silking interval created by the simultaneous effect. We concluded that the appropriate bandwidth, 1.6 m and 2.0 m, can stabilize the dry matter partitioning to the ear; stabilize ear length, floret, and grain abortion rate; and stabilize the maize yield.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bing2025effects,
  author = {Liang Bing and Jingjing Li and Xuyang Zhao and Xinhui Lei and Guopeng Chen and Pu Tian and Yushan Wu and Taiwen Yong and Feng Yang and Xiaochun Wang and Wenyu Yang},
  title = {{Effects of Bandwidth on Ear Differentiation and Grain Yield Formation of Maize in Strip Intercropping}},
  booktitle = {Plants},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/plants14071081},
}
Figure