Effects of Anterior Capsulotomy on Decision Making in Patients with Refractory Obsessive–Compulsive Disorder

Chencheng Zhang, Yilin Chen, Shuaiwei Tian, Tao Wang, Yile Xie, Haiyan Jin, Guozhen Lin, Hengfen Gong, Kristina Zeljic, Bomin Sun, Tianming Yang, Shikun ZhanFrontiers in Psychology 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Despite various lines of evidence implicating impaired decision-making ability in individuals with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), neuropsychological investigation has generated inconsistent findings. Although the cortico-striato-thalamo-cortical (CSTC) circuitry has been suggested, the involvement of the cortex has not yet been fully demonstrated. Moreover, it is unknown whether surgical intervention on the CSTC circuitry results in a predicted improvement of decision-making ability of OCD. Here we present a study of decision making based on the Iowa Gambling Task (IGT) to investigate decision making in a large sample of individuals with treatment-resistant OCD with and without anterior capsulotomy (AC). Task performance was evaluated in healthy subjects, individuals with OCD that had not undergone surgery, and postsurgical OCD patients with AC. The latter group was further divided into a short-term postsurgical group and a long-term postsurgical group. We found that the OCD patients without surgery performed significantly worse than the healthy controls on the IGT. There were no significant differences in decision-making between the presurgical OCD patients and those at the short-term postsurgical follow-up. Decision-making ability of the long-term postsurgical OCD patients was improved to the level comparable to that of healthy controls. All clinical symptoms (OCD, depression, and anxiety) assessed by psychiatric rating scales were significantly alleviated post-surgically, but exhibited no correlation with their IGT task performance. Our findings provide strong evidence that OCD is linked to impairments in decision-making ability; that impaired CSTC circuitry function is directly involved in the manifestation of OCD; and that AC related improvements in cognitive functions are caused by long-term plasticity in the brain circuitry.

Introduction

Approximately one-third of patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) do not respond to standard pharmacological or cognitive-behavioral therapies. For these refractory cases, neurosurgical interventions targeting the cortico-striato-thalamo-cortical (CSTC) circuitry—the brain's primary pathway for habit formation and reward processing—can offer significant relief. While surgery is known to reduce psychiatric symptoms, its impact on the profound decision-making deficits often seen in OCD has remained unclear. This study investigates whether anterior capsulotomy (AC) can repair these underlying cognitive "glitches" over time.

Methodology

The researchers employed a cross-sectional design involving 138 participants categorized into four groups:

  1. Healthy Controls (HC): 31 subjects.
  2. Pre-operative OCD (preO): 51 patients.
  3. Short-term postsurgical OCD (postST): 24 patients (approx. 4 months post-op).
  4. Long-term postsurgical OCD (postLT): 32 patients (2–5 years post-op).

Decision-making was assessed using the Iowa Gambling Task (IGT), where participants choose between "bad" decks (high immediate reward, high long-term loss) and "good" decks (low immediate reward, long-term gain). The surgical intervention was a bilateral Anterior Capsulotomy (AC), which uses radio-frequency heat to create precise lesions in the anterior limb of the internal capsule, disrupting overactive CSTC loops.

Key Results

The study found a significant disparity in cognitive recovery timelines. While clinical symptoms like anxiety and obsessions improved relatively quickly after surgery, decision-making capabilities followed a much slower trajectory.

Learning curves for the IGT across five blocks. Long-term post-op patients (postLT) eventually reach performance levels comparable to healthy controls (HC), while pre-op (preO) and short-term post-op (postST) patients lag.

As shown in the learning curves, pre-operative and short-term post-operative patients performed significantly worse than healthy controls. However, the long-term post-operative group achieved net scores comparable to healthy controls by the final blocks of the task (~9.50 vs. ~2.94 for pre-op patients).

Cognitive Strategy and Plasticity

A deeper analysis of decision-making strategies revealed that healthy controls and long-term post-op patients learned to "stay" with good decks even after experiencing a loss. In contrast, pre-op and short-term post-op patients remained inconsistent, failing to internalize the long-term reward structure.

Stay probabilities for the long-term post-operative group. High stay probabilities for 'Good Win' and 'Good Lose' scenarios indicate a stable preference for advantageous decks.

This delayed improvement supports the Plasticity Hypothesis: the brain requires years to "re-wire" and normalize decision-making processes following the surgical lesion. Interestingly, there was no correlation between the reduction in psychiatric symptoms (e.g., Y-BOCS scores dropping from 25.84 to 9.22) and IGT performance, suggesting a functional dissociation between the neural substrates for obsessions and those for decision-making.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The findings provide strong evidence that AC-related improvements in cognitive functions are driven by long-term neural plasticity. While the cross-sectional nature of the study is a limitation, the results highlight a clear path for future longitudinal research. Subsequent studies using fMRI could help pinpoint the specific cortical regions, such as the orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) or anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), that undergo reorganization during this multi-year recovery phase.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite various lines of evidence implicating impaired decision-making ability in individuals with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), neuropsychological investigation has generated inconsistent findings. Although the cortico-striato-thalamo-cortical (CSTC) circuitry has been suggested, the involvement of the cortex has not yet been fully demonstrated. Moreover, it is unknown whether surgical intervention on the CSTC circuitry results in a predicted improvement of decision-making ability of OCD. Here we present a study of decision making based on the Iowa Gambling Task (IGT) to investigate decision making in a large sample of individuals with treatment-resistant OCD with and without anterior capsulotomy (AC). Task performance was evaluated in healthy subjects, individuals with OCD that had not undergone surgery, and postsurgical OCD patients with AC. The latter group was further divided into a short-term postsurgical group and a long-term postsurgical group. We found that the OCD patients without surgery performed significantly worse than the healthy controls on the IGT. There were no significant differences in decision-making between the presurgical OCD patients and those at the short-term postsurgical follow-up. Decision-making ability of the long-term postsurgical OCD patients was improved to the level comparable to that of healthy controls. All clinical symptoms (OCD, depression, and anxiety) assessed by psychiatric rating scales were significantly alleviated post-surgically, but exhibited no correlation with their IGT task performance. Our findings provide strong evidence that OCD is linked to impairments in decision-making ability; that impaired CSTC circuitry function is directly involved in the manifestation of OCD; and that AC related improvements in cognitive functions are caused by long-term plasticity in the brain circuitry.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2017effects,
  author = {Chencheng Zhang and Yilin Chen and Shuaiwei Tian and Tao Wang and Yile Xie and Haiyan Jin and Guozhen Lin and Hengfen Gong and Kristina Zeljic and Bomin Sun and Tianming Yang and Shikun Zhan},
  title = {{Effects of Anterior Capsulotomy on Decision Making in Patients with Refractory Obsessive–Compulsive Disorder}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01814},
}
Figure