Effects of an integrated safety system for swivel seat arrangements in frontal crash

Li Zhao, Ruth Gao, R. W. McCoy, Hongyu Hu, Lei He, Zhenhai GaoFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

As autonomous vehicles (AVs) move toward flexible "living room" interiors, traditional safety systems must evolve to protect occupants who aren't facing forward. This study demonstrates that integrating Automated Emergency Braking (AEB) with Pre-Pretension (PPT) seatbelts can significantly reduce injury risks across various swivel angles, though the timing of these systems must be precisely tuned to account for asymmetric seatbelt performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional vehicle safety is built around a "standard" posture: a forward-facing occupant with a steering wheel and dashboard in front of them. However, AVs promise a "third living space" where seats can swivel to face each other. This creates a massive safety gap.

When a seat is rotated (even by 15 or 30 degrees), a standard three-point seatbelt no longer restrains the body symmetrically. During the split second of emergency braking before a crash (the pre-crash phase), the occupant’s body moves out of its initial position. If the safety system doesn't account for this "out-of-position" movement, the subsequent impact could be far more lethal. The researchers sought to understand how an integrated system—combining the car's ability to brake itself with a seatbelt that tightens before the impact—affects occupant kinematics and injury risk at different seating angles.

Methods

The researchers employed high-fidelity Finite Element (FE) simulations using the THUMS (Total Human Model for Safety) Version 4.0, a sophisticated digital representation of a 50th-percentile male.

Key components of their virtual sled test included:

  • Seating Configurations: A single-seat model with a seat-mounted seatbelt (crucial for swivel seats).
  • Orientations: Nine different angles ranging from -45° to +45° in 15° increments.
  • The Integrated System: They simulated Automated Emergency Braking (AEB)—a 1G deceleration pulse—combined with Pre-Pretension (PPT), where the shoulder belt actively pulls the occupant back into the seat before the actual 20 mph frontal crash occurs.
  • Control Strategies: They tested different PPT delay times (0ms, 50ms, and 100ms) to find the optimal window for restraining the occupant.

Datasets

As a simulation-based study, the "data" consists of the validated FE models:

  • THUMS v4.0: The primary human body model used for calculating injury metrics.
  • Validation Data: The simulation results for neck movement and belt force were validated against existing volunteer test data from literature (e.g., Wen, 2019) to ensure the digital "dummy" behaved like a real human during braking.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Asymmetry Trap: A standard 3-point belt is inherently asymmetric. When the seat rotates to the right, the shoulder belt engages the occupant more firmly. When it rotates to the left, the shoulder belt tends to slip off, leading to much larger lateral head movements.
  • The "Pre-crash Envelope": The study mapped a "kinematics envelope"—essentially a 3D map of where an occupant's head travels during emergency braking. This is a vital tool for designers to ensure that "roomy" AV interiors don't have hard surfaces (like tables or screens) within that swing zone.
  • Timing is Angle-Dependent: There is no "one-size-fits-all" timing for safety systems. For example, a 0ms PPT delay was best for seats angled at -45°, while a 50ms delay performed better at +45°.
  • The Double-Edged Sword of Pre-crash: While AEB and PPT generally reduced injury metrics like HIC (Head Injury Criterion), the pre-crash movement actually increased certain injury risks (like neck injury, Nij) at specific angles (-45° and +30°). This suggests that "out-of-position" kinematics can sometimes create new vulnerabilities.

Key Results

  • Head Excursion: In lateral movement, the head traveled up to 100mm in negative seat orientations but only 70mm in positive ones, highlighting the belt's asymmetric effectiveness.
  • Injury Reduction: In most orientations, the integrated system significantly lowered:
  • HIC15 (Head Injury): Values stayed well below the threshold of 700.
  • BrIC (Brain Injury Criteria): Reduced in almost all directions except -45°.
  • Chest Deflection: Significantly reduced for orientations between -15° and +30°.
  • Optimal Strategy: The study concluded that a 50ms delay for the PPT seatbelt was the most robust "all-around" setting for the 0° to +45° range.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for further exploration:

  • Passive Model: The THUMS model used was "passive," meaning it didn't account for "bracing"—the way humans instinctively tense their muscles when they see a crash coming.
  • Simplified Interior: The simulation omitted airbags and the steering wheel. While this allowed for a "clean" look at seatbelt physics, real-world AVs may still have these components.
  • Limited Angles: The study stopped at 45°. Future research needs to look at "campfire" seating where occupants might face 90° or even 180° (rear-facing).
  • Crash Types: This study focused only on frontal crashes; side and rear impacts with swivel seats remain a major unknown.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Objective:</b> Autonomous vehicles (Avs) have paved the way for the arrangement of swivel seats in vehicles, which could pose a challenge to traditional safety systems. The integration of automated emergency braking (AEB) and pre-pretension (PPT) seatbelts improves protection for a vehicle's occupant. The objective of this study is to explore the control strategies of an integrated safety system for swiveled seating orientations. <b>Methods:</b> Occupant restraints were examined in various seating configurations using a single-seat model with a seat-mounted seatbelt. Seat orientation was set at different angles, from -45° to 45° with 15° increments. A pretension was used on the shoulder belt to represent an active belt force cooperating with AEB. A generic full frontal vehicle pulse of 20 mph was applied to the sled. The occupant's kinematics response under various integrated safety system control strategies was analyzed by extracting a head pre-crash kinematics envelope. The injury values were calculated for various seating directions with or without an integrated safety system at the collision speed of 20 mph. <b>Results:</b> In a lateral movement, the excursions of the dummy head were 100 mm and 70 mm in the global coordinate system for negative and positive seat orientations, respectively. In the axial movement, the head traveled 150 mm and 180 mm in the global coordinate system for positive and negative seating directions, respectively. The 3-point seatbelt did not restrain the occupant symmetrically. The occupant experienced greater <i>y</i>-axis excursion and smaller <i>x</i>-axis excursion in the negative seat position. Various integrated safety system control strategies led to significant differences in head movement in the <i>y</i> direction. The integrated safety system reduced the occupant's potential injury risks in different seating positions. When the AEB and PPT were activated, the absolute HIC15, brain injury criteria (BrIC), neck injury (Nij), and chest deflection were reduced in most seating directions. However, the pre-crash increased the injury risks at some seating positions. <b>Conclusion:</b> The pre-pretension seatbelt could reduce the occupant's forward movement in the rotating seat positions in a pre-crash period. The occupant's pre-crash motion envelope was generated, which could be beneficial to future restraint systems and vehicle interior design. The integrated safety system could reduce injuries in different seating orientations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2023effects,
  author = {Li Zhao and Ruth Gao and R. W. McCoy and Hongyu Hu and Lei He and Zhenhai Gao},
  title = {{Effects of an integrated safety system for swivel seat arrangements in frontal crash}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2023.1153265},
}

Loading related content...

Figure