Effects of a Mixed Emissions Control Policy on the Manufacturer’s Production and Carbon Abatement Investment Decisions

Wang Fei, Dalin ZhangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how a mixed emissions control policy, combining a carbon tax with a dynamic reward-punishment mechanism, influences manufacturers' decisions on production and carbon abatement investment. It reveals that while these policies can encourage abatement, their effectiveness is highly dependent on the stringency of the government's targets and the specific economic context, suggesting a nuanced approach is needed for optimal environmental and economic outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The urgent need to curb greenhouse gas emissions has led governments worldwide to implement various environmental policies. While carbon taxes are a common tool, they can increase operating costs for manufacturers and may not always be sufficient on their own. To address this, governments are increasingly using incentive-based mechanisms like reward-punishment systems. This paper tackles the complex interplay between these policies, specifically a carbon tax and a dynamic reward-punishment system tied to abatement targets, and how they affect a manufacturer's choices regarding production levels and investments in carbon reduction technologies. The authors aim to understand how to design these policies to maximize both manufacturer profits and overall social welfare, considering consumer environmental awareness.

Methods

The study employs a game-theoretic approach, modeling the interaction between the government (as the leader) and a monopolistic manufacturer (as the follower). The manufacturer first decides on its carbon abatement investment level and then its production quantity to maximize its profit. Subsequently, the government, observing the manufacturer's behavior, sets its optimal pre-determined abatement target to maximize social welfare. This backward induction method allows for the analysis of how different policy parameters and market conditions influence the decisions of both parties. The authors derive analytical solutions for optimal decisions and then conduct numerical simulations to explore the relationships between various parameters.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and numerical simulations rather than empirical data from specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stricter Targets Aren't Always Better: A higher government-mandated abatement target doesn't automatically lead to more manufacturer abatement. It can increase costs and reduce demand, potentially harming production.
  • Consumer Power Matters: Increased consumer environmental awareness consistently benefits manufacturers' low-carbon production efforts. However, its positive environmental impact is contingent on the government's abatement target being below a certain threshold.
  • Abatement Cost is Key: Reducing the cost of carbon abatement is always beneficial for manufacturers' low-carbon production. Its environmental benefit, however, is also tied to the government's target stringency.
  • Carbon Tax vs. Reward-Punishment: While both policies can encourage abatement, the carbon tax appears to have a more direct and effective impact on reducing total carbon emissions. The reward-punishment mechanism's effectiveness is more sensitive to the overall policy stringency.
  • Nuanced Policy Design: The optimal policy mix (carbon tax rate, reward-punishment coefficient, and abatement target) is highly context-dependent. The government needs to carefully balance these elements, considering factors like the manufacturer's abatement cost, consumer preferences, and the unit carbon emissions of the product.

Key Results

The paper presents several propositions detailing the impact of various parameters:

  • Abatement Cost Coefficient (k): A higher cost coefficient negatively impacts abatement investment and production. However, if consumer preference is low, manufacturers might pass these costs on through higher prices.
  • Government Abatement Target (φ): Stricter targets (higher φ) can increase the manufacturer's cost burden and reduce market demand. Environmental benefits from stricter policies are only realized when the target exceeds a certain threshold.
  • Carbon Tax Rate (to): A higher carbon tax rate generally encourages abatement investment and production, especially under looser emission control policies. It also consistently reduces total carbon emissions.
  • Reward-Punishment Coefficient (η): Similar to the carbon tax, a higher coefficient encourages abatement investment. However, its environmental benefit is more pronounced under looser emission control policies.
  • Consumer Preference (λ): Stronger consumer preference for low-carbon products always boosts abatement investment and production. Its environmental benefit is realized when the government's target is not too stringent.

Numerical simulations (Figures 2 and 3) illustrate these relationships, showing how changes in parameters like the carbon tax rate and reward-punishment coefficient affect the optimal abatement target, investment levels, and excessive abatement.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study is based on a single-period decision environment, which could be extended to a multi-period setting to capture dynamic effects. They also suggest exploring other incentive-punishment policies, such as tiered carbon taxes or dynamic reward-punishment mechanisms based directly on carbon emissions. Future work could also incorporate multi-product scenarios and investigate the impact of different market structures beyond a monopoly.

Summary updated

Abstract

Considering the consumers' environmental awareness, a mixed emissions control policy with carbon tax and a dynamic reward-punishment mechanism for carbon abatements was introduced to explore the manufacturer's low-carbon production issues. The results showed that: (1) Under a given mixed emissions control policy, a higher government pre-determined abatement target cannot positively encourage manufacturers' carbon abatement behaviors. However, a stricter emissions control policy is environmentally beneficial only when the government pre-determined abatement target exceeds a certain threshold. (2) Reducing the carbon abatement cost and enhancing the consumers' environmental awareness would always benefit manufacturers' low-carbon production, but both approaches benefit the environment only when the government pre-determined abatement target is below a certain threshold. (3) Under a mixed emissions control policy of social welfare maximization, the reward-punishment coefficient positively correlates with the government's optimal pre-determined abatement target, and the effect of the carbon tax rate on that is closely related to the carbon emissions of the unit product. More importantly, imposing a carbon tax or raising the tax rate and adopting a reward-punishment mechanism or raising the reward-punishment coefficient can effectively encourage manufacturers' carbon abatement investment behaviors. However, they have nothing but a negative effect on manufacturers' excessive abatement levels.
BibTeX
@article{fei2022effects,
  author = {Wang Fei and Dalin Zhang},
  title = {{Effects of a Mixed Emissions Control Policy on the Manufacturer’s Production and Carbon Abatement Investment Decisions}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192013472},
}
Figure