Effectiveness of social distancing measures and lockdowns for reducing transmission of COVID-19 in non-healthcare, community-based settings

Caitriona Murphy, Wey Wen Lim, Cathal Mills, Jessica Y. Wong, Dongxuan Chen, Yanmy Xie, Mingwei Li, Susan Gould, Hualei Xin, Justin Cheung, Samir Bhatt, Benjamin J. Cowling, Christl A. DonnellyPhilosophical 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This systematic review synthesizes evidence on the effectiveness of nine social distancing measures (SDMs) in reducing COVID-19 transmission. It finds that more stringent measures like lockdowns and mass gathering restrictions were most effective, especially when used in combination, though disentangling individual intervention effects remains challenging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic saw unprecedented global implementation of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs), primarily social distancing measures (SDMs), to curb transmission. However, understanding the precise effectiveness of individual SDMs and their optimal combinations has been difficult due to the complex, overlapping nature of their implementation and the observational design of most studies. This paper addresses the need for a comprehensive synthesis of the existing evidence to inform future pandemic preparedness and response strategies.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic review of literature published between January 1, 2020, and December 1, 2022. They searched major databases for studies reporting on the effectiveness of nine specific SDMs: school closures, school measures, workplace closures, workplace measures, catering/fitness/personal care service measures, care home measures, restrictions on mass gatherings, physical distancing, and stay-at-home orders (lockdowns). All study designs were considered for inclusion, but simulation studies not fitted to observed data were excluded. The quality of evidence was assessed using the GRADE framework.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The review synthesized data from existing studies, which utilized various datasets including national and sub-national epidemiological data, mobility data, and government response trackers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stringency Matters: The most stringent SDMs, such as stay-at-home orders (lockdowns) and restrictions on mass gatherings, consistently showed the greatest effectiveness in reducing transmission.
  • Combinations are Key: While individual SDMs have an effect, the review strongly suggests that combinations of measures were most successful in slowing or stopping transmission.
  • Observational Data Dominates: The vast majority of studies were observational, which, while informative, introduces inherent risks of bias and makes it challenging to isolate the true effect of individual interventions.
  • Behavioral Change is Crucial: The effectiveness of any SDM policy hinges on its ability to change individual and population behaviors.
  • Mobility as a Proxy: Human mobility data, often derived from mobile phone devices, served as a valuable proxy for estimating the impact of interventions, showing expected reductions when SDMs were in place.

Key Results

The review included 338 studies, with nearly half focusing on stay-at-home orders.

  • Stay-at-home orders (lockdowns): 119 studies found substantial benefits, reducing the reproduction number (Rt), incidence, and mortality. While most studies reported significant reductions (around 50%), some found smaller effects when implemented alongside other measures.
  • School closures: 104 studies were reviewed, with over half showing strong evidence of effectiveness. Proactive school closures were generally associated with reductions in incidence and transmission.
  • Workplace measures and closures: Twelve observational studies indicated that reduced workplace mobility was significantly associated with reduced SARS-CoV-2 incidence or transmission. Thirty-seven studies on workplace closures generally observed a beneficial effect.
  • Restrictions on mass gatherings: 28 studies examined this measure, with 26 reporting substantial reductions in impact, particularly on Rt. The effectiveness increased with greater stringency (e.g., limiting gatherings to 10 people or fewer).
  • Overall: The combined effects of numerous SDMs, including school closures, workplace closures, and restricting mass gatherings, were highly successful in reducing transmission. This was also evidenced by the reduced circulation of other respiratory viruses during periods of strict NPI implementation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Observational Bias: The reliance on observational studies makes it difficult to establish causality and avoid bias.
  • Intervention Overlap: It was challenging to disentangle the effects of individual SDMs due to their widespread and simultaneous implementation.
  • Data Granularity: Many studies lacked quantitative data on the degree of behavioral change in response to SDMs.
  • Subgroup Analyses: Subgroup analyses were not frequently assessed and could be a focus for future research.

Future work should aim to identify the optimal combinations of measures, understand the drivers of policy impact (e.g., behavioral changes over time), and explore the potential for interactions with individual protective measures. Further research is also needed to assess the effectiveness of SDMs in the context of evolving pathogen dynamics and to balance their public health benefits against socioeconomic impacts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Social distancing measures (SDMs) are community-level interventions that aim to reduce person-to-person contacts in the community. SDMs were a major part of the responses first to contain, then to mitigate, the spread of SARS-CoV-2 in the community. Common SDMs included limiting the size of gatherings, closing schools and/or workplaces, implementing work-from-home arrangements, or more stringent restrictions such as lockdowns. This systematic review summarized the evidence for the effectiveness of nine SDMs. Almost all of the studies included were observational in nature, which meant that there were intrinsic risks of bias that could have been avoided were conditions randomly assigned to study participants. There were no instances where only one form of SDM had been in place in a particular setting during the study period, making it challenging to estimate the separate effect of each intervention. The more stringent SDMs such as stay-at-home orders, restrictions on mass gatherings and closures were estimated to be most effective at reducing SARS-CoV-2 transmission. Most studies included in this review suggested that combinations of SDMs successfully slowed or even stopped SARS-CoV-2 transmission in the community. However, individual effects and optimal combinations of interventions, as well as the optimal timing for particular measures, require further investigation. This article is part of the theme issue 'The effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions on the COVID-19 pandemic: the evidence'.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{murphy2023effectiveness,
  author = {Caitriona Murphy and Wey Wen Lim and Cathal Mills and Jessica Y. Wong and Dongxuan Chen and Yanmy Xie and Mingwei Li and Susan Gould and Hualei Xin and Justin Cheung and Samir Bhatt and Benjamin J. Cowling and Christl A. Donnelly},
  title = {{Effectiveness of social distancing measures and lockdowns for reducing transmission of COVID-19 in non-healthcare, community-based settings}},
  booktitle = {Philosophical},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1098/rsta.2023.0132},
}
Figure