Effectiveness of a Participatory and Interactive Virtual Reality Intervention in Patients With Social Anxiety Disorder: Longitudinal Questionnaire Study (Preprint)

Hyun-Jin Kim, Seulki Lee, Dooyoung Jung, Ji‐Won Hur, Heon‐Jeong Lee, Sungkil Lee, Gerard Jounghyun Kim, Chung-Yean Cho, Seungmoon Choi, Seung-Moo Lee, Chul‐Hyun Cho2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study developed and evaluated a participatory and interactive virtual reality (VR) intervention for social anxiety disorder (SAD). The VR program significantly reduced various symptoms of SAD, including general anxiety, social anxiety, and internalized shame, demonstrating VR's potential as a valuable therapeutic tool.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Social anxiety disorder (SAD) is characterized by an intense fear of negative evaluation in social situations, leading to significant impairment in daily life. While cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is effective, individuals with SAD often face barriers to seeking treatment, such as stigma, cost, and limited access to specialized services. Virtual reality (VR) offers a promising alternative by providing immersive, controlled exposure therapy in a safe environment. However, existing VR interventions often lack personalization and interactivity. This paper addresses the need for a more engaging and tailored VR intervention for SAD by developing a participatory and interactive VR program and evaluating its effectiveness.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel participatory and interactive VR intervention for SAD. The program consisted of three stages: introduction, core, and finishing. The core stage involved participants engaging in social situations, such as introducing themselves to virtual characters. Crucially, the VR scenarios were designed to be participatory, allowing participants to control their actions, and interactive, with the difficulty level (easy, medium, hard) adapting based on the virtual characters' responses. This allowed for a more personalized experience. Participants' progress was assessed using a battery of validated psychological questionnaires measuring general anxiety, SAD symptoms, shame, and rumination. The study involved 32 individuals diagnosed with SAD and 34 healthy controls.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new datasets or benchmarks. Instead, it utilized established psychological scales to measure various aspects of social anxiety and general anxiety. These scales included:

  • Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI)
  • State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI)
  • Internalized Shame Scale (ISS)
  • Post-Event Rumination Scale (PERS)
  • Social Phobia Scale (SPS)
  • Social Interaction Anxiety Scale (SIAS)
  • Brief-Fear of Negative Evaluation Scale (BFNE)
  • Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale (LSAS)
  • Korean Social Avoidance and Distress Scale (KSAD)

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Participatory VR enhances engagement: The "participatory" aspect, where users control their avatar and actions, seems crucial for making the VR experience more impactful than passive observation.
  • Adaptive difficulty is key: The ability to adjust the VR scenario's difficulty based on participant response is a significant step towards personalized therapy, potentially increasing effectiveness.
  • VR addresses multiple facets of SAD: The intervention showed improvements not only in core social anxiety symptoms but also in related areas like internalized shame and negative rumination, suggesting a holistic impact.
  • VR as a bridge, not a sole solution: While VR showed significant improvements, SAD patients still exhibited higher scores than controls post-treatment, indicating that VR might be most effective as part of a broader treatment strategy.

Key Results

The study found significant improvements in the SAD group across multiple psychological scales after the VR intervention. Specifically:

  • General Anxiety: Scores on the BAI and STAI-Trait significantly improved.
  • Social Anxiety Symptoms: Measures like SPS, SIAS, BFNE, KSAD, and LSAS showed significant reductions.
  • Cognitive/Emotional Aspects: The Internalized Shame Scale (ISS) and its subscales (emptiness, self-punishment, fear of mistakes) also showed significant improvements. Negative rumination (a subscale of PERS) also decreased.
  • Comparison to Controls: Even after VR treatment, the SAD group maintained significantly higher scores on most scales compared to the healthy control group, highlighting the persistent nature of SAD symptoms.
  • Responder vs. Non-responder: There was no significant difference in outcomes between participants who responded to the VR treatment (defined by a 50% reduction in BAI scores) and those who did not, suggesting that the current definition of response might need refinement or that the intervention's impact is more nuanced.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Lack of Control Group: The study did not include a sham or waitlist control group, making it difficult to definitively attribute all observed changes solely to the VR intervention.
  • Self-Reported Measures: Reliance on self-report scales can introduce bias due to participant motivation or subjective interpretation.
  • Responder Definition: The definition of a "responder" based on a single scale (BAI) might be too simplistic and could mask subtler treatment effects or differences between subgroups.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Longitudinal Studies: Investigating the long-term persistence of VR treatment effects.
  • Treatment Combinations: Exploring the effectiveness of combining VR with other therapeutic techniques or repeated VR sessions.
  • Subgroup Analysis: Conducting more detailed comparisons between subgroups based on severity, psychological profiles, or medication status.
  • Optimizing Session Number: Determining the optimal number and timing of VR sessions for maximum therapeutic benefit.

Summary updated

Abstract

<sec> <title>BACKGROUND</title> Social anxiety disorder (SAD) is characterized by excessive fear of negative evaluation and humiliation in social interactions and situations. Virtual reality (VR) treatment is a promising intervention option for SAD. </sec> <sec> <title>OBJECTIVE</title> The purpose of this study was to create a participatory and interactive VR intervention for SAD. Treatment progress, including the severity of symptoms and the cognitive and emotional aspects of SAD, was analyzed to evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention. </sec> <sec> <title>METHODS</title> In total, 32 individuals with SAD and 34 healthy control participants were enrolled in the study through advertisements for online bulletin boards at universities. A VR intervention was designed consisting of three stages (introduction, core, and finishing) and three difficulty levels (easy, medium, and hard) that could be selected by the participants. The core stage was the exposure intervention in which participants engaged in social situations. The effectiveness of treatment was assessed through Beck Anxiety inventory (BAI), State‐Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI), Internalized Shame Scale (ISS), Post-Event Rumination Scale (PERS), Social Phobia Scale (SPS), Social Interaction Anxiety Scale (SIAS), Brief-Fear of Negative Evaluation Scale (BFNE), and Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale (LSAS). </sec> <sec> <title>RESULTS</title> In the SAD group, scores on the BAI (&lt;i&gt;F&lt;/i&gt;=4.616, &lt;i&gt;P&lt;/i&gt;=.009), STAI-Trait (&lt;i&gt;F&lt;/i&gt;=4.670, &lt;i&gt;P&lt;/i&gt;=.004), ISS (&lt;i&gt;F&lt;/i&gt;=6.924, &lt;i&gt;P&lt;/i&gt;=.001), PERS-negative (&lt;i&gt;F&lt;/i&gt;=1.008, &lt;i&gt;P&lt;/i&gt;&amp;lt;.001), SPS (&lt;i&gt;F&lt;/i&gt;=8.456, &lt;i&gt;P&lt;/i&gt;&amp;lt;.001), BFNE (&lt;i&gt;F&lt;/i&gt;=6.117, &lt;i&gt;P&lt;/i&gt;=.004), KSAD (&lt;i&gt;F&lt;/i&gt;=13.259, &lt;i&gt;P&lt;/i&gt;&amp;lt;.001), and LSAS (&lt;i&gt;F&lt;/i&gt;=4.103, &lt;i&gt;P&lt;/i&gt;=.009) significantly improved over the treatment process. Compared with the healthy control group before treatment, the SAD group showed significantly higher scores on all scales (&lt;i&gt;P&lt;/i&gt;&amp;lt;.001), and these significant differences persisted even after treatment (&lt;i&gt;P&lt;/i&gt;&amp;lt;.001). In the comparison between the VR treatment responder and nonresponder subgroups, there was no significant difference across the course of the VR session. </sec> <sec> <title>CONCLUSIONS</title> These findings indicated that a participatory and interactive VR intervention had a significant effect on alleviation of the clinical symptoms of SAD, confirming the usefulness of VR for the treatment of SAD. VR treatment is expected to be one of various beneficial therapeutic approaches in the future. </sec> <sec> <title>CLINICALTRIAL</title> Clinical Research Information Service (CRIS) KCT0003854; https://cris.nih.go.kr/cris/search/search_result_st01.jsp?seq=13508 </sec>
BibTeX
@misc{kim2020effectiveness,
  author = {Hyun-Jin Kim and Seulki Lee and Dooyoung Jung and Ji‐Won Hur and Heon‐Jeong Lee and Sungkil Lee and Gerard Jounghyun Kim and Chung-Yean Cho and Seungmoon Choi and Seung-Moo Lee and Chul‐Hyun Cho},
  title = {{Effectiveness of a Participatory and Interactive Virtual Reality Intervention in Patients With Social Anxiety Disorder: Longitudinal Questionnaire Study (Preprint)}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.2196/preprints.23024},
}
Figure