Effective strategies for teachers to guide children’s art activities: based on a survey of children’s art activities and teacher guidance, and an analysis of their correlation

Han Zhang, Y. F. Yang, Jialin LiFrontiers in Psychology 2025 · DOI

Abstract: Providing effective strategic guidance for teachers to guide children's art activities and improving the quality and level of children's art activities is of great significance for children's mental development and subsequent development, as well as improving the quality of teacher teaching. We developed a children's art activity and teacher guidance observation table to collect art activity data from 538 children and guidance behavior data from 62 kindergarten teachers in 10 kindergartens in Chongqing, Sichuan, Hubei, Jiangxi, Jiangsu, and Shanghai. Then, we analyzed the differences in children's art activities and discussed the correlation between children's art activities and teachers' guidance. The results showed that there are significant and extremely significant differences in the art activity styles and interests of children in random activities, independent activities, and organized activities. There is a significant correlation between teacher guidance and children's art interaction styles. Based on the above results, we suggest that when instructing children's art activities, teachers should build a hierarchical and interesting learning environment to stimulate children's interest in learning art and make it fun, to continuously improve the quality and level of children's art activities.

Introduction

In early childhood education, art instruction often oscillates between rigid imitation and unguided free play. This research, published in Frontiers in Psychology, addresses the challenge of knowing when and how educators should intervene to maximize developmental outcomes. By bridging the gap between traditional "instilling knowledge" methods and child-centered frameworks like Reggio Emilia, the study quantifies how different activity types and teacher guidance behaviors correlate with children’s interest and performance.

Methodology

The researchers utilized a multi-step approach to gather and analyze data:

  1. Instrument Development: Using rootedness theory, 62 teaching cases were analyzed to extract 96 keywords, resulting in three observation forms (Art Activity Method, Interest, and Teacher Guidance) containing 41 items.
  2. Observation: Master’s-trained educators conducted non-participant observations, recording 3 hours of activity per site across 10 kindergartens in six Chinese regions.
  3. Participants: The dataset included 538 children (275 boys, 263 girls) and 62 female teachers, covering diverse art forms such as painting, handicrafts, and music.
  4. Statistical Analysis: ANOVA was used to compare activity types, while the gray relevance method analyzed the correlation between teacher guidance and children’s interaction styles.

Key Insights: The Tripartite Framework

The study categorizes art activities into three distinct modes:

  • Spontaneous Activities: Naturally triggered by immediate interest, these activities serve as an emotional release mechanism.
  • Self-Directed Activities: Child-initiated and planned, these foster deep engagement and autonomy.
  • Structured Activities: Teacher-designed with specific objectives, these are effective for building cognitive skills.

A significant finding was the role of material provision. Providing specific tools or media was more effective at driving collaboration and classroom discussion than verbal explanation alone, acting as a "scaffold" for social interaction. Furthermore, teacher guidance through "comparison" and "association" helped children transition from simple imitation to higher-order thinking.

Key Results

The statistical analysis revealed distinct strengths for each activity mode. Spontaneous activities yielded the highest scores for emotional well-being and artistic experience. In contrast, structured activities were significantly more effective for developing listening skills and critical thinking.

Table 1: Comparison of children's art activity methods across spontaneous, self-directed, and structured modes.

Self-directed activities outperformed others in fostering active questioning and high levels of focus, suggesting that autonomy is a primary driver of deep engagement.

Table 2: Comparison of children's interest and engagement indicators across different activity modes.

Key quantitative findings include:

  • Emotional vs. Cognitive: Spontaneous activities led in emotional well-being ($M=2.41$), while structured activities excelled in listening ($M=2.82$) and critical thinking ($M=2.28$).
  • Engagement: Self-directed activities saw the highest levels of focus ($M=2.17$) and active questioning ($M=2.09$).
  • Correlation: Strong correlations were found between teacher guidance and the "comparison" (0.762) and "performance" (0.751) dimensions of children's activities.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the study provides a data-driven roadmap for arts instruction, it is limited by its geographic scope and cross-sectional design. Future research should include longitudinal studies to track the long-term effects of these strategies on creativity and explore "blended" teaching models that integrate structured and unstructured play.

Ultimately, teachers should match their guidance to specific developmental goals, building hierarchical and interesting learning environments to continuously improve the quality of children's art activities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Providing effective strategic guidance for teachers to guide children's art activities and improving the quality and level of children's art activities is of great significance for children's mental development and subsequent development, as well as improving the quality of teacher teaching. We developed a children's art activity and teacher guidance observation table to collect art activity data from 538 children and guidance behavior data from 62 kindergarten teachers in 10 kindergartens in Chongqing, Sichuan, Hubei, Jiangxi, Jiangsu, and Shanghai. Then, we analyzed the differences in children's art activities and discussed the correlation between children's art activities and teachers' guidance. The results showed that there are significant and extremely significant differences in the art activity styles and interests of children in random activities, independent activities, and organized activities. There is a significant correlation between teacher guidance and children's art interaction styles. Based on the above results, we suggest that when instructing children's art activities, teachers should build a hierarchical and interesting learning environment to stimulate children's interest in learning art and make it fun, to continuously improve the quality and level of children's art activities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025effective,
  author = {Han Zhang and Y. F. Yang and Jialin Li},
  title = {{Effective strategies for teachers to guide children’s art activities: based on a survey of children’s art activities and teacher guidance, and an analysis of their correlation}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1600401},
}
Figure