Effective refractive error coverage in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis of updated estimates from population-based surveys in 76 countries modelling the path towards the 2030 global target

Rupert Richard Alexander Bourne, Maria Vittoria Cicinelli, David Selby, Tabassom Sedighi, Ian Tapply, Ian McCormick, Jost B. Jonas, Mohammad Haris Abdianwall, Mukharram M. Bikbov, Tasanee Braithwaite, Matthew J. Burton, Vera Lúcia Alves Carneiro, Robert J. Casson, Ching‐Yu Cheng, Nathan Congdon, Catherine Creuzot-Garcher, Leon B. Ellwein, Mohammad Hassan Emamian, Akbar Fotouhi, Tim Fricke, David S. Friedman, João M. Furtado, Ronnie George, Noopur Gupta, Xiaotong Han, Hassan Hashemi, Mingguang He, Abba Hydara, Aiko Iwase, Gyulli M. Kazakbaeva, Rajiv Khandekar, Rohit Khanna, Fatima Kyari, Luisa Casas Luque, Srinivas Marmamula, Andreas Müller, Vinay Nangia, Kovin Naidoo, Jacqueline Ramke, Paisan Ruamviboonsuk, Solange Rios Salomão, Hugh R. Taylor, Yih Chung Tham, Fotis Topouzis, Rohit Varma, Lingam Vijaya, Ningli Wang, Ya Xing Wang, Tien Yin Wong, Hua Yan, Seth Flaxman, Stuart Keel, Serge Resnikoff, Wondu Alemayehu, Aries Arditi, Alessandro Arrigo, Alain M Bron, Ching-Yu Cheng, Reza Dana, Monte A Del Monte, jenny P deva, Mo Dirani, Laura Dreer, Joshua R Ehrlich, Arthur G Fernandes, Gus Gazzard, Billy R Hammond, Mary Elizabeth Hartnett, April D Ingram, Songhomitra Panda-Jonas, Rim Kahloun, John H Kempen, Moncef Khairallah, Judy E Kim, Van C Lansingh, Janet L Leasher, Nicolas Leveziel, Jennifer Lim, Hans Limburg, Julie-Anne Little, Alan R Morse, David C MuschThe Lancet Global Health 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive global and regional analysis of effective refractive error coverage (eREC) in adults, revealing that current progress is insufficient to meet the 2030 WHO target. It highlights significant disparities in eREC across regions, sexes, and age groups, underscoring the urgent need for accelerated and equitable interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Globally, uncorrected refractive error is a major cause of vision impairment, affecting hundreds of millions of people. While spectacles are a highly effective and cost-efficient solution, access to and quality of correction remain uneven. The World Health Organization (WHO) has set a global target of a 40 percentage-point increase in effective refractive error coverage (eREC) by 2030. However, understanding the current state of eREC, identifying regional disparities, and projecting future progress is crucial for guiding global efforts. This paper addresses this by providing updated, detailed estimates of eREC and analyzing the trajectory towards the 2030 target.

Methods

The study employed a systematic review and meta-analysis of population-based eye surveys. Key methods include:

  • Data Synthesis: Analysis of data from 237 population-based eye surveys conducted in 76 countries since 2000, encompassing over 815,000 participants.
  • eREC Calculation: eREC was calculated using a PVA-based method at a 6/12 visual acuity threshold, defined as the proportion of people needing refractive correction who received it and achieved a good quality outcome.
  • Quality Gap Measurement: The relative quality gap was calculated as (REC - eREC) / REC × 100, where REC accounts for correction regardless of outcome quality.
  • Bayesian Logistic Regression: An expert elicitation process was used to select covariates (e.g., optometrists per person, socio-demographic index, healthcare access and quality) for a Bayesian logistic regression model to estimate eREC by country, age, and sex.
  • Projection Modeling: The model was used to estimate eREC for 2023 and project future trends towards 2030, allowing for the assessment of progress towards the WHO target.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • Global Vision Database: A repository of data from population-based surveys of vision impairment and blindness.
  • RAAB (Rapid Assessment of Avoidable Blindness) surveys: A specific type of population-based survey.
  • Comprehensive eye surveys: More detailed surveys with wider age ranges and geographical sampling.

The analysis included data from 237 studies (35 comprehensive and 202 RAABs) across 76 countries, with participant-level microdata requested for studies conducted from January 1, 2000, onwards.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Global Progress is Insufficient: Despite a steady increase in eREC, the current trajectory is not on track to meet the 2030 WHO target. This highlights the need for a significant acceleration in global efforts.
  • Deep Regional Disparities: eREC varies dramatically across Global Burden of Diseases (GBD) super-regions, with high-income countries showing much higher coverage than sub-Saharan Africa. This underscores the inequity in access to vision correction.
  • Sex and Age Matter: Females consistently have lower eREC than males across all regions. Additionally, eREC declines with increasing age among adults aged 50 and older, suggesting potential barriers for older populations.
  • Quality Gap Persists: While the overall coverage is improving, the "quality gap" (difference between correction and effective correction) remains significant, particularly in regions with lower eREC. This means that even when people receive correction, it may not be of sufficient quality.
  • Myopia's Growing Impact: The increasing prevalence of myopia, especially in East Asia, is a significant factor that increases the denominator for eREC and may foreshadow future vision loss if not adequately addressed.

Key Results

  • Global eREC in 2023: Estimated at 65.8% (95% UI 64.7–66.8), a 6 percentage-point increase since 2010.
  • Regional Variation (2023): High-income countries at 84.0% (95% UI 83.0–85.0) vs. sub-Saharan Africa at 28.3% (26.4–30.4).
  • Sex Differences: Global eREC for males was 67.4% and for females was 64.3%.
  • Progress Since 2000: Relative increases in eREC varied significantly by region, with sub-Saharan Africa showing the largest relative increase (60.2%) and high-income countries the smallest (6.8%).
  • Undermetted Need Reduction: The percentage of those with a refractive need that was undermet reduced from 10.0% in 2000 to 5.3% in 2023.
  • Country-Level Projections: The study identified countries like Ethiopia as having the worst projected eRECs in 2030, while Russia is forecast to have the best.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Sparsity and Heterogeneity: While this study significantly expanded the data sources, some regions still have limited data, and the heterogeneity of study protocols (e.g., differing visual acuity thresholds) can affect comparability.
  • Subnational vs. National Data: Only 17% of studies were nationally representative, meaning subnational data might not always reflect the true national picture, especially in diverse countries.
  • Covariate Limitations: Due to collinearity and data sparsity, only a limited number of covariates could be included in the statistical model, potentially limiting the precision of predictions.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for high-quality, nationally representative population-based studies. Future research should also focus on measuring uncorrected visual acuity, strengthening data for younger populations, and improving geographical coverage, particularly in under-represented regions. Addressing the quality of refractive correction services and integrating vision care with other health services are also crucial next steps.

Summary updated

Abstract

For the French, Chinese and Spanish translations of the abstract see Supplementary Materials section.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bourne2025effective,
  author = {Rupert Richard Alexander Bourne and Maria Vittoria Cicinelli and David Selby and Tabassom Sedighi and Ian Tapply and Ian McCormick and Jost B. Jonas and Mohammad Haris Abdianwall and Mukharram M. Bikbov and Tasanee Braithwaite and Matthew J. Burton and Vera Lúcia Alves Carneiro and Robert J. Casson and Ching‐Yu Cheng and Nathan Congdon and Catherine Creuzot-Garcher and Leon B. Ellwein and Mohammad Hassan Emamian and Akbar Fotouhi and Tim Fricke and David S. Friedman and João M. Furtado and Ronnie George and Noopur Gupta and Xiaotong Han and Hassan Hashemi and Mingguang He and Abba Hydara and Aiko Iwase and Gyulli M. Kazakbaeva and Rajiv Khandekar and Rohit Khanna and Fatima Kyari and Luisa Casas Luque and Srinivas Marmamula and Andreas Müller and Vinay Nangia and Kovin Naidoo and Jacqueline Ramke and Paisan Ruamviboonsuk and Solange Rios Salomão and Hugh R. Taylor and Yih Chung Tham and Fotis Topouzis and Rohit Varma and Lingam Vijaya and Ningli Wang and Ya Xing Wang and Tien Yin Wong and Hua Yan and Seth Flaxman and Stuart Keel and Serge Resnikoff and Wondu Alemayehu and Aries Arditi and Alessandro Arrigo and Mukharram M Bikbov and Rupert R A Bourne and Tasanee Braithwaite and Alain M Bron and Matthew Burton and Robert J Casson and Ching-Yu Cheng and Maria Vittoria Cicinelli and Nathan G Congdon and Reza Dana and Monte A Del Monte and jenny P deva and Mo Dirani and Laura Dreer and Joshua R Ehrlich and Leon B Ellwein and Arthur G Fernandes and Seth Flaxman and Tim R Fricke and David S Friedman and João M Furtado and Gus Gazzard and Ronnie George and Billy R Hammond and Mary Elizabeth Hartnett and April D Ingram and Jost B Jonas and Songhomitra Panda-Jonas and Rim Kahloun and John H Kempen and Moncef Khairallah and Rohit C Khanna and Judy E Kim and Van C Lansingh and Janet L Leasher and Nicolas Leveziel and Jennifer Lim and Hans LIMBURG and Julie-Anne Little and Ian McCormick and Alan R Morse and David C Musch and Kovin S Naidoo and Vinay Nangia},
  title = {{Effective refractive error coverage in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis of updated estimates from population-based surveys in 76 countries modelling the path towards the 2030 global target}},
  booktitle = {The Lancet Global Health},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/s2214-109x(25)00194-9},
}
Figure