Effective field theory of dark matter: a global analysis

Sebastian Liem, Gianfranco Bertone, Francesca Calore, Roberto Ruiz de Austri, Tim M. P. Tait, Roberto Trotta, Christoph WenigerJournal of High Energy Physics 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive global analysis of real and complex scalar dark matter models using an effective field theory (EFT) approach. By combining data from cosmology (Planck), direct detection (LUX), and indirect detection (Fermi-LAT), the authors constrain the parameter space of these models and explore the implications of a potential Galactic Center Excess (GCE) signal. They find that while current data disfavors low-mass real scalar dark matter, the GCE scenario can be explained by these models, though tension arises with dwarf galaxy observations for real scalars, which is alleviated in the complex scalar case.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The nature of dark matter remains one of the most significant mysteries in physics. While WIMP (Weakly Interacting Massive Particle) candidates are popular, a model-independent approach is crucial to explore a broader range of possibilities. Effective Field Theories (EFTs) provide a powerful framework for describing dark matter interactions with Standard Model particles without assuming specific UV completions. However, previous studies often focused on individual EFT operators or limited combinations. This paper addresses the need for a global analysis of all relevant dimension-6 EFT operators for scalar dark matter, simultaneously considering multiple experimental constraints to provide a more complete and coherent picture of the parameter space. The authors also investigate the potential of these EFT models to explain the observed excess of gamma rays from the Galactic Center, a tantalizing but potentially astrophysical signal.

Methods

The authors employ a Bayesian statistical framework, utilizing Bayes' theorem to infer the posterior probability distributions of the model parameters given the experimental data. They implement a joint likelihood function that combines constraints from:

  • Cosmological Relic Density: Planck data on the cosmic microwave background (CMB) is used to constrain the dark matter abundance.
  • Direct Detection: Upper limits from the LUX experiment on spin-independent scattering cross-sections are incorporated.
  • Indirect Detection: Limits from the Fermi Large Area Telescope (Fermi-LAT) on gamma-ray signals from dwarf spheroidal galaxies are used.
  • Galactic Center Excess (GCE): A likelihood is constructed to evaluate the compatibility of dark matter annihilation with the observed gamma-ray excess from the Galactic Center.

A key methodological aspect is the use of the EFTBayes package, which interfaces with FeynRules for model definition, MicrOMEGAS for relic density and detection rate calculations, and LUXCalc for LUX likelihoods. For parameter space exploration, they utilize the MultiNest nested sampling algorithm, known for its efficiency in mapping posteriors and evaluating profile likelihoods. They also explore the impact of different prior choices (Log and Dirichlet priors) on the results.

Datasets

The paper utilizes publicly available experimental data and derived likelihoods:

  • Planck CMB Data: Used for constraining the cosmological dark matter relic density.
  • LUX Experiment Data: Upper limits on spin-independent scattering cross-sections.
  • Fermi-LAT Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy Data: Limits on dark matter annihilation cross-sections from the non-observation of gamma-ray signals.
  • Fermi-LAT Galactic Center Excess Data: Used to evaluate the potential of dark matter annihilation to explain this observed excess.

The paper does not introduce new experimental datasets but rather combines existing constraints within a unified theoretical framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Relic Density as the Dominant Constraint: The cosmological relic density is found to be the most impactful constraint, requiring a precise tuning of operator coefficients to match the observed abundance.
  • Mass Dependence of Constraints: For real scalar dark matter, indirect detection limits (especially from dwarf galaxies) strongly disfavor masses below 100 GeV. Direct detection limits from LUX become less relevant for very low-mass dark matter candidates due to energy thresholds.
  • Impact of p-wave Operators: The presence of p-wave operators in complex scalar dark matter models significantly alters the constraints. These operators lead to velocity-dependent annihilation, which is less effective in the early universe for setting the relic density and also less constrained by current indirect detection searches.
  • Galactic Center Excess as a Probe: Including the GCE as a potential dark matter signal dramatically reshapes the parameter space, favoring specific mass ranges (around 40-60 GeV for real scalars) and operators.
  • Tension with Dwarf Galaxies: While the GCE can be explained by scalar dark matter EFTs, the real scalar case faces tension with the non-detection of gamma rays from dwarf galaxies. This tension is relieved in the complex scalar case due to the flexibility offered by p-wave operators.

Key Results

  • Real Scalar Dark Matter: Current data, excluding the GCE, disfavors masses below 100 GeV. Small favored regions exist around charm and bottom quark masses due to resonance effects in the early universe.
  • Complex Scalar Dark Matter: Less constrained than real scalars due to the presence of p-wave operators, which are less sensitive to current indirect detection limits.
  • GCE Interpretation:
    • For real scalars, fitting the GCE strongly favors a mass around 40-60 GeV and the R2 operator. However, this scenario is in tension with dwarf galaxy limits.
  • For complex scalars, the GCE can be explained, and the tension with dwarf galaxy limits is relieved due to the freedom from p-wave operators.
  • Model Independence: The EFT approach allows for straightforward extension to other dark matter types or additional operators, provided new experimental data becomes available.

Limitations and Future Work

  • EFT Validity: The EFT description breaks down when the energy scale of the interaction approaches the mass of the heavy mediator particles. The paper notes that for processes with large momentum transfer (e.g., at the LHC), EFT limits may not apply to models with mediator masses below the TeV scale.
  • Low-Energy Fermi-LAT Data: The current Fermi-LAT dSph likelihood has a lower energy threshold (500 MeV) that limits its sensitivity to very low-mass dark matter candidates. Extending this to lower photon energies could further constrain these models.
  • Astrophysical Uncertainties: The paper acknowledges that the GCE could be explained by astrophysical sources like millisecond pulsars, and the dark matter interpretation is an assumption made for illustrative purposes.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their framework can be readily extended to include other types of dark matter (e.g., fermionic) or additional EFT operators. They also emphasize that adding more degrees of freedom without new experimental constraints is not advisable. The development of more informative data will be crucial for further refining these analyses.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present global fits of an effective field theory description of real, and complex scalar dark matter candidates. We simultaneously take into account all possible dimension 6 operators consisting of dark matter bilinears and gauge invariant combinations of quark and gluon fields. We derive constraints on the free model parameters for both the real (five parameters) and complex (seven) scalar dark matter models obtained by combining Planck data on the cosmic microwave background, direct detection limits from LUX, and indirect detection limits from the Fermi Large Area Telescope. We find that for real scalars indirect dark matter searches disfavour a dark matter particle mass below 100 GeV. For the complex scalar dark matter particle current data have a limited impact due to the presence of operators that lead to p-wave annihilation, and also do not contribute to the spin-independent scattering cross-section. Although current data are not informative enough to strongly constrain the theory parameter space, we demonstrate the power of our formalism to reconstruct the theoretical parameters compatible with an actual dark matter detection, by assuming that the excess of gamma rays observed by the Fermi Large Area Telescope towards the Galactic centre is entirely due to dark matter annihilations. Please note that the excess can very well be due to astrophysical sources such as millisecond pulsars. We find that scalar dark matter interacting via effective field theory operators can in principle explain the Galactic centre excess, but that such interpretation is in strong tension with the non-detection of gamma rays from dwarf galaxies in the real scalar case. In the complex scalar case there is enough freedom to relieve the tension.
BibTeX
@article{liem2016effective,
  author = {Sebastian Liem and Gianfranco Bertone and Francesca Calore and Roberto Ruiz de Austri and Tim M. P. Tait and Roberto Trotta and Christoph Weniger},
  title = {{Effective field theory of dark matter: a global analysis}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep09(2016)077},
}
Figure