Effective cataract surgical coverage in adults aged 50 years and older: estimates from population-based surveys in 55 countries

Ian McCormick, Robert Butcher, Jennifer Evans, Islay Mactaggart, Hans Limburg, Emma Jolley, Yuddha Dhoj Sapkota, Joseph Oye, Sailesh Kumar Mishra, Andrew Bastawrous, João M. Furtado, Anagha Joshi, Baixiang Xiao, Thulasiraj Ravilla, Rupert Bourne, Alarcos Cieza, Stuart Keel, Matthew J. Burton, Jacqueline Ramke, Jafer K Ababora, Heba AlSawahli, Doris M Alvarado, Hery Harimanitra Andriamanjato, Ahmad Ashraf Amalius, Rosario Barrenechea, Juan Batlle, Ileana Brea, Anthea Burnett, Felipe A Chiriboga, Uranchimeg Davaatseren, Rainald Duerksen, Cristina Eusebio, Robert P. Finger, Pedro A Gomez-Bastar, César Gonzales, Reeta Gurung, Saad Hajar, Muhammad Zahid Jadoon, Elesh Jain, George Kabona, Khumbo Kalua, Lévi Kandeke, Ram Prasad Kandel, J Karimurio, Sucheta Kulkarni, Van Charles Lansingh, Nor Tshering Lepcha, Wanjiku Mathenge, Seyed-Farzad Mohammadi, Manfred Mörchen, Nasiru Muhammad, Paddy B Musana, Grace C Mutati, María Eugenia Nano, János Németh, Ala Paduca, Alexander Páez, Sarah Polack, Mansur Rabiu, Lutfah Rif’ati, Beatriz Natividad Rodríguez Rodríguez, Mohamad Aziz Salowi, Nicholas Sargent, Mansyur Syumarti, Ubeydulla Thoufeeq, Astrid V Villalobos, Joseph W Wachira, Min Wu, Biaxiang Xiao, Mariano Yee Melgar, Xiu Juan ZhangThe Lancet Global Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides the most comprehensive analysis to date of effective cataract surgical coverage (eCSC) across 55 countries, revealing significant disparities in both access and quality of cataract surgery. The findings highlight the urgent need for quality improvement, especially in lower-income settings, to meet global targets for reducing blindness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cataract is a leading cause of blindness worldwide, yet effective treatment—cataract surgery—is not universally accessible or of consistently high quality. While cataract surgical coverage (CSC) measures the proportion of people operated on for cataracts, effective cataract surgical coverage (eCSC) goes a step further by incorporating a measure of surgical quality (postoperative visual acuity). This distinction is crucial because simply performing surgery doesn't guarantee a good outcome. The 74th World Health Assembly set an ambitious target to increase eCSC by 30 percentage points by 2030, necessitating robust baseline data to track progress. This paper addresses the critical need for up-to-date, comprehensive eCSC estimates to inform global and national strategies for combating preventable blindness.

Methods

The researchers conducted a secondary analysis using data from 148 population-based Rapid Assessment of Avoidable Blindness (RAAB) surveys conducted between 2003 and 2021 across 55 countries. RAAB is a standardized methodology for assessing avoidable blindness. The study calculated both CSC and eCSC, with eCSC adjusted for postoperative visual acuity. They employed a modified definition of CSC and eCSC that now includes individuals with unilateral cataract and vision impairment in the other eye, as well as those with an unmet need for surgery, providing a more complete picture of met and unmet needs. Age-adjusted and sex-adjusted estimates were generated, and statistical methods were used to account for the cluster sampling design of the RAAB surveys. Meta-analysis was used to pool data and compare estimates across different regions and income levels, as well as to analyze sex-based disparities.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 148 RAAB surveys conducted between 2003 and 2021. These surveys were sourced from the RAAB repository, which contains data from population-based eye health surveys. The data included individual participant survey data and census population data for individuals aged 50 years and older. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Quality Matters as Much as Access: The significant gap between CSC and eCSC in many countries underscores that simply increasing the number of surgeries (access) is insufficient. Improving the quality of outcomes is paramount.
  • Income Gradient is Stark: eCSC is strongly correlated with a country's income level, with high-income countries showing substantially higher coverage than low-income countries. This highlights the resource-dependent nature of effective eye care.
  • Gender Inequality Persists: Men consistently have better eCSC than women, indicating persistent barriers to accessing quality cataract surgery for females.
  • Regional Variations are Significant: eCSC varies considerably by WHO region, with the African region showing the lowest coverage, emphasizing the need for targeted interventions.
  • A Moving Target: The WHO's 6/12 visual acuity threshold for a good outcome represents a higher standard than previously used, and achieving this will require significant quality improvements.

Key Results

  • The median eCSC across 55 countries was 24.8%, with a median CSC of 40.0%.
  • eCSC estimates ranged from a low of 3.8% in Guinea Bissau (2010) to a high of 70.3% in Hungary (2015).
  • High-income countries had a median eCSC of 60.5%, while low-income countries had a median of 14.8%.
  • Men had a higher eCSC than women, with a pooled risk difference of 3.2% and a pooled risk ratio of 1.20.
  • The South-East Asia and European regions reported the highest median eCSC, while the African region had the lowest.
  • The Eastern Mediterranean region had the highest crude coverage but a lower effective coverage compared to South-East Asia and Europe.
  • Examples of improvement were noted in Bhutan (increase of 15 percentage points) and Nepal (increase of 20 percentage points) over approximately a decade.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data Availability: Estimates were unavailable for many countries, and data from only two high-income countries were included, potentially underestimating the true eCSC in these regions.
  • Comparability: The inclusion of RAAB surveys conducted over a long period (2003-2021) means estimates may not be directly comparable across all countries and regions.
  • Representativeness: Less than half of the country estimates were nationally representative, with subnational data potentially over- or underestimating national coverage.
  • Future Work: The paper calls for more population-based surveys to fill data gaps, particularly in the European, Eastern Mediterranean, and Americas regions. It also emphasizes the need to address gender inequity and prioritize underserved groups for equitable increases in eCSC. Further research into the financial protection aspects of cataract surgery access is also recommended.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{mccormick2022effective,
  author = {Ian McCormick and Robert Butcher and Jennifer Evans and Islay Mactaggart and Hans Limburg and Emma Jolley and Yuddha Dhoj Sapkota and Joseph Oye and Sailesh Kumar Mishra and Andrew Bastawrous and João M. Furtado and Anagha Joshi and Baixiang Xiao and Thulasiraj Ravilla and Rupert Bourne and Alarcos Cieza and Stuart Keel and Matthew J. Burton and Jacqueline Ramke and Jafer K Ababora and Heba AlSawahli and Doris M Alvarado and Hery Harimanitra Andriamanjato and Ahmad Ashraf Amalius and Rosario Barrenechea and Juan Batlle and Ileana Brea and Anthea Burnett and Felipe A Chiriboga and Uranchimeg Davaatseren and Rainald Duerksen and Cristina Eusebio and Robert P. Finger and Pedro A Gomez-Bastar and César Gonzales and Reeta Gurung and Saad Hajar and Muhammad Zahid Jadoon and Elesh Jain and George Kabona and Khumbo Kalua and Lévi Kandeke and Ram Prasad Kandel and J Karimurio and Sucheta Kulkarni and Van Charles Lansingh and Nor Tshering Lepcha and Wanjiku Mathenge and Sailesh Kumar Mishra and Seyed-Farzad Mohammadi and Manfred Mörchen and Nasiru Muhammad and Paddy B Musana and Grace C Mutati and María Eugenia Nano and János Németh and Ala Paduca and Alexander Páez and Sarah Polack and Mansur Rabiu and Lutfah Rif’ati and Beatriz Natividad Rodríguez Rodríguez and Mohamad Aziz Salowi and Yuddha Dhoj Sapkota and Nicholas Sargent and Mansyur Syumarti and Ubeydulla Thoufeeq and Astrid V Villalobos and Joseph W Wachira and Min Wu and Biaxiang Xiao and Mariano Yee Melgar and Xiu Juan Zhang},
  title = {{Effective cataract surgical coverage in adults aged 50 years and older: estimates from population-based surveys in 55 countries}},
  booktitle = {The Lancet Global Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1016/s2214-109x(22)00419-3},
}
Figure