Effect of Voids behind Lining on the Failure Behavior of Symmetrical Double-Arch Tunnels

Xu Zhang, Zijian Ye, Bo Min, Youjun XuSymmetry 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how voids behind the lining of symmetrical double-arch tunnels affect their structural integrity. Using a combination of physical model tests and numerical simulations, the study reveals that voids significantly alter stress distribution, leading to asymmetrical failure patterns and increased damage, particularly near the void. Understanding these effects is crucial for ensuring the safety and longevity of extensive tunnel infrastructure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The safety and stability of tunnels, especially during their service life, are critical concerns in civil engineering. Double-arch tunnels, common in China, are particularly susceptible to defects like voids forming behind their linings due to construction imperfections or ground movement. These voids can lead to a loss of soil support, causing increased earth pressure, internal force redistribution, and ultimately, tunnel lining deformation, cracking, and potential failure. While research exists on single tunnels or double-arch tunnels without voids, a comprehensive understanding of how voids at different locations and sizes impact the failure behavior of symmetrical double-arch tunnels is lacking. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by systematically studying the influence of voids on the mechanical responses and failure mechanisms of these structures.

Methods

The research employs a two-pronged approach:

  • Model Tests: Two physical model tests were conducted in a large tank.
  • Model Test 1 (MT1): A baseline test simulating a symmetrical double-arch tunnel without any voids.
  • Model Test 2 (MT2): A test simulating a tunnel with a void introduced at the top of the central wall. These tests involved applying increasing overload to the model surface and monitoring earth pressure, bending moments, and lining cracks using pressure cells, strain gauges, and displacement meters. The tests were designed to simulate plane strain conditions.

  • Numerical Analysis: A series of numerical simulations were performed using the Abaqus finite element software, incorporating the extended finite element method (XFEM) for crack modeling.

  • A 2D model of the double-arch tunnel was created, with soil modeled using the Mohr-Coulomb constitutive model and the lining using a damaged mechanics model.
  • Ten numerical tests were conducted to systematically investigate the effects of:
  • Void Location: Voids were placed at the central wall, right haunch, right shoulder, vault, and left shoulder.
  • Void Size: The angle of the void at the vault was varied (15°, 25°, 30°, 35°).
  • The simulations involved applying an overload up to 6.00 MPa and analyzing crack propagation, minimum principal strain, and internal forces.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data collected from model tests and simulated data from numerical models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Void-induced Asymmetry: The presence of voids fundamentally disrupts the symmetrical stress distribution in double-arch tunnels, leading to asymmetrical failure patterns. This is a critical departure from the behavior of tunnels without voids.
  • Stress Concentration: Voids cause significant stress concentration in the surrounding soil and lining, particularly in areas adjacent to the void. This localized stress increase is a primary driver of premature cracking and failure.
  • Location Matters Most: The location of the void has a more pronounced effect on lining failure than its size, especially for cracks adjacent to the central wall.
  • Weak Points Amplified: The bottom of the central wall, already identified as a potential weak point, experiences the most severe damage when voids are present.
  • Cracking Complexity: The propagation of cracks in double-arch tunnels with voids becomes more complex, deviating from the simpler patterns observed in void-free or symmetrical cases.
  • Asymmetrical vs. Symmetrical: While both symmetrical and asymmetrical double-arch tunnels experience more severe damage with voids, the large-section tunnel in asymmetrical configurations shows more complicated cracking patterns.

Key Results

  • Earth Pressure: The introduction of a void at the top of the central wall dramatically increased earth pressure, reaching up to 1.177 MPa in the model tests, compared to a generally uniform distribution in the void-free case.
  • Bending Moments: Voids led to significant changes in bending moments. For instance, a void at the central wall caused increased positive bending moments on the sides of the void and negative moments within the void area.
  • Cracking Load: The presence of voids generally led to earlier cracking and lower cracking loads compared to the void-free scenario.
  • Minimum Principal Strain: Numerical results showed that compressive failure (indicated by minimum principal strain) primarily occurred at the inner fiber of the lining, with the highest values observed near the void. For example, a maximum value of 0.00489 was recorded in Numerical Test 6 (void at the left shoulder).
  • Void Size Effect: Increasing void size at the vault led to increased tensile stress and earlier cracking on the inside of the void, while reducing crack depth at the tunnel invert.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Limitations: The authors acknowledge that achieving perfect similarity criteria in model tests can be challenging, particularly regarding the unit weight of the model lining.
  • Experimental Shortcomings: Model tests are noted as being time-consuming, costly, and lacking flexibility, which numerical analysis can help to overcome.
  • Void Shape and Size: While the study explored different void locations and sizes, real-world voids can have irregular shapes. Future work could explore the impact of more complex void geometries.
  • Material Heterogeneity: The models assume homogeneous soil and lining materials. Future research could incorporate material variability.
  • Dynamic Effects: The current study focuses on static loading. Investigating the effect of dynamic loads (e.g., seismic activity) on tunnels with voids would be a valuable extension.
  • Long-term Performance: The study provides insights into immediate failure behavior. Long-term deformation and degradation mechanisms in the presence of voids warrant further investigation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2019effect,
  author = {Xu Zhang and Zijian Ye and Bo Min and Youjun Xu},
  title = {{Effect of Voids behind Lining on the Failure Behavior of Symmetrical Double-Arch Tunnels}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/sym11101321},
}
Figure