Effect of Using Mobile Phones on Driver’s Control Behavior Based on Naturalistic Driving Data

Lanfang Zhang, Boyu Cui, Minhao Yang, Feng Guo, Junhua WangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages naturalistic driving data to analyze how specific mobile phone usage actions (answering, dialing, talking, hanging up, viewing) impact a driver's control behavior. It reveals that different mobile phone tasks trigger distinct driver self-regulatory strategies, affecting control intensity, sensitivity, and stability, which is crucial for understanding and mitigating distracted driving risks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Distracted driving, particularly due to mobile phone use, is a major contributor to traffic accidents. While many regulations exist, there's a lack of unified understanding of how different mobile phone activities affect driving. Previous research often relied on driving simulators, which may not accurately reflect real-world behavior. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating the nuanced impact of various mobile phone operations on driver control behavior using unobtrusive, naturalistic driving data.

Methods

The researchers employed a naturalistic driving study dataset from Shanghai, China. They extracted 134 driving events involving mobile phone use and categorized these into five sub-operations: answering, dialing, talking/listening, hanging up, and viewing information. To analyze the impact on driver control, they utilized a "moving time window" approach. This involved calculating metrics for:

  • Control Activity Intensity: Measured by the median standard deviation of acceleration (longitudinal and lateral) within a 1-second window, reflecting the driver's engagement and attention allocation.
  • Control Operation Sensitivity: Assessed by the standard Euclidean distance between consecutive 1-second window vectors of acceleration standard deviations, indicating how quickly drivers respond to changes.
  • Control State Stability: Evaluated using the standard deviation of speed and lane offset over time, representing the steadiness of longitudinal and lateral vehicle control.

By analyzing these metrics during and after mobile phone use, the study aimed to quantify the effects of different distractions.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Shanghai Natural Driving Study (SH-NDS). This dataset comprises high-precision, unobtrusive data collected from vehicles equipped with advanced data acquisition systems (Doppler radar, accelerometers, GPS, and cameras) over extended periods. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather analyzes a subset of existing SH-NDS data specifically curated for mobile phone use events.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Task-Specific Distraction: Not all mobile phone use is equal. Different operations (e.g., dialing vs. talking) have distinct impacts on driver control, suggesting that a one-size-fits-all regulatory approach might be insufficient.
  • Driver Self-Regulation: Drivers adapt their behavior based on the distraction's intensity. They tend to reduce longitudinal control (e.g., acceleration) during tasks like answering or dialing, and lateral control during viewing, to manage the increased workload.
  • Cognitive vs. Manual Distraction: While manual-visual tasks like dialing and viewing are obvious distractions, cognitive load from conversations (talking/listening) also significantly impairs control sensitivity and stability, highlighting the importance of addressing cognitive aspects.
  • Lingering Effects: The impact of viewing information on driver sensitivity and stability can persist for several seconds after the phone is put down, suggesting a delayed recovery period.

Key Results

  • Answering Calls: Significantly decreased longitudinal control activity and sensitivity. Talking/listening during calls had a more pronounced negative effect on longitudinal control stability than other sub-operations. Lateral control was less affected.
  • Dialing Calls: Led to a significant decline in longitudinal control activity, sensitivity, and longitudinal control state stability. Lateral control was not significantly impacted.
  • Viewing Information: While longitudinal control activity was not significantly affected, lateral control activity decreased. Crucially, viewing significantly reduced control sensitivity, and this effect lingered for up to 5 seconds after the task ended. Longitudinal control state stability was also significantly deteriorated.
  • Hanging Up: Had a minimal impact on driver control behavior, suggesting drivers can manage this brief distraction effectively.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Research Environment: The study's background is primarily highways/expressways. Naturalistic driving on urban roads is more complex and requires further investigation.
  • Hands-Free Devices: The study focused on hand-held calls. The impact of hands-free devices, while often less visually and manually distracting, still involves cognitive load and warrants further research. The authors suggest future work will explore hands-free calling.
  • Duration of Distraction: While the study found no significant correlation between duration and longitudinal control stability for talking/listening within the current study's duration range, the longer and more discrete nature of this task suggests duration could be a factor in other contexts.
  • Generalizability: While the SH-NDS is a large-scale study, the findings are based on a specific population and driving environment.

The authors advocate for restricting smartphone use for viewing information, especially on highways, and suggest that hands-free calls should also be considered for restriction due to their cognitive impact.

Summary updated

Abstract

Distracted driving behaviors are closely related to crash risk, with the use of mobile phones during driving being one of the leading causes of accidents. This paper attempts to investigate the impact of cell phone use while driving on drivers' control behaviors. Given the limitation of driving simulators in an unnatural setting, a sample of 134 cases related to cell phone use during driving were extracted from Shanghai naturalistic driving study data, which provided massive unobtrusive data to observe actual driving process. The process of using mobile phones was categorized into five operations, including dialing, answering, talking and listening, hanging up, and viewing information. Based on the concept of moving time window, the variation of the intensity of control activity, the sensitivity of control operation, and the stability of control state in each operation were analyzed. The empirical results show strong correlation between distracted operations and driving control behavior. The findings contribute to a better understanding of drivers' natural behavior changes with using mobiles, and can provide useful information for transport safety management.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2019effect,
  author = {Lanfang Zhang and Boyu Cui and Minhao Yang and Feng Guo and Junhua Wang},
  title = {{Effect of Using Mobile Phones on Driver’s Control Behavior Based on Naturalistic Driving Data}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph16081464},
}
Figure