Abstract
In this paper, we present a study of supercooled liquids interacting with the Lennard Jones potential and the corresponding purely repulsive (Weeks-Chandler-Andersen) potential, over a range of densities and temperatures, in order to understand the origin of their different dynamics in spite of their structures being similar. Using the configurational entropy as the thermodynamic marker via the Adam Gibbs relation, we show that the difference in the dynamics of these two systems at low temperatures can be explained from thermodynamics. At higher densities both the thermodynamical and dynamical difference between these model systems decrease, which is quantitatively demonstrated in this paper by calculating different parameters. The study also reveals the origin of the difference in pair entropy despite the similarity in the structure. Although the maximum difference in structure is obtained in the partial radial distribution function of the B type of particles, the rdf of AA pairs and AB pairs gives rise to the differences in the entropy and dynamics. This work supports the observation made in an earlier study and shows that they are generic in nature, independent of density.
Introduction: The Structural Paradox of Supercooled Liquids
A fundamental tenet of liquid state physics, the "van der Waals picture," posits that the structure of a fluid is primarily dictated by short-range repulsive forces, with attractive forces acting as a uniform background. This leads to the expectation that the Lennard-Jones (LJ) potential and its purely repulsive counterpart, the Weeks-Chandler-Andersen (WCA) potential, should yield nearly identical physical properties.
However, in the supercooled regime, a mystery emerges: while the structures remain remarkably similar, their dynamics diverge significantly. The LJ system becomes "sluggish" much faster than the WCA system as temperature drops. This study investigates whether this discrepancy is purely kinetic or rooted in the underlying thermodynamics of the energy landscape.
Dynamics and the Role of Density
Using Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of the Kob-Andersen binary mixture, we analyzed the relaxation time ($\tau$) and diffusion coefficients across densities $\rho = 1.2, 1.4,$ and $1.6$. At lower densities, the LJ system exhibits much slower dynamics compared to WCA at the same temperature.
As shown in Figure 1, the dynamical gap between LJ and WCA is most pronounced at $\rho = 1.2$ but narrows significantly as density increases to $\rho = 1.6$. This suggests that at high compression, the harsh repulsive cores dominate the physics, rendering attractive forces negligible.
Thermodynamics as the Driver: The Adam-Gibbs Relation
To resolve why these structurally similar liquids move differently, we employed the Adam-Gibbs (AG) relation, which connects a liquid's relaxation time to its configurational entropy ($S_c$): $\tau = \tau_0 \exp(A/TS_c)$.
When the dynamics are plotted against the thermodynamic marker $1/TS_c$ (Figure 2), the data for both LJ and WCA systems collapse onto nearly linear trajectories. This confirms that the differences in "sluggishness" are not merely kinetic anomalies but are quantitatively explained by the available configurational states in the thermodynamic landscape.
Insights into Pair Entropy and Fragility
The study further decomposes entropy to understand the role of specific particle interactions. Interestingly, while the largest structural difference between LJ and WCA is observed in the B-type particles, the entropy calculations reveal that the AA and AB pairs are primarily responsible for the dynamical differences.
Furthermore, the "fragility" of the systems—how rapidly viscosity increases upon cooling—converges at high densities. The Kauzmann temperature ($T_K$), where configurational entropy theoretically vanishes, also shows convergence as the systems are compressed.
Conclusion
This work demonstrates that the dynamical differences between LJ and WCA systems in supercooled states are fundamentally thermodynamic in origin. By utilizing the Adam-Gibbs relation, we show that configurational entropy serves as a robust marker for dynamics across a range of densities. As density increases, the influence of attractive forces wanes, leading to a convergence of both thermodynamic and kinetic properties, supporting a more unified picture of glass-forming liquids at high pressure.
Summary updated