Effect of the 2020 hypersensitivity pneumonitis guideline on the pathologic diagnosis of interstitial pneumonia

Mutsumi Ozasa, Andrey Bychkov, Yoshiaki Zaizen, Kazuhiro Tabata, Wataru Uegami, Yasuhiko Yamano, Kensuke Kataoka, Takeshi Johkoh, Hiroshi Mukae, Yasuhiro Kondoh, Junya FukuokaScientific 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

A new 2020 guideline for diagnosing hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP) has significantly altered pathological diagnoses of fibrotic interstitial pneumonia (fIP), reclassifying 25% of cases from non-fHP to fHP. While this guideline aims to standardize diagnosis, its impact on overdiagnosis and the utility of different biopsy methods, particularly transbronchial lung cryobiopsy (TBLC), require further investigation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Diagnosing fibrotic interstitial pneumonia (fIP) is notoriously challenging due to overlapping features with other interstitial lung diseases. Hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP), particularly its fibrotic form (fHP), is a key differential diagnosis. Historically, there's been a lack of consensus on diagnostic criteria for fHP, leading to high interobserver variability and potential misdiagnosis. A major concern is that fHP might be overdiagnosed, especially when compared to idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF). In 2020, international guidelines were published to standardize HP diagnosis. This paper investigates the practical impact of these new guidelines on pathological diagnoses of fIP, specifically examining how they alter existing diagnoses and whether they introduce potential for overdiagnosis.

Methods

The researchers retrospectively reviewed 289 cases of fibrotic interstitial pneumonia diagnosed between 2014 and 2019 from a single pulmonary center. They applied the 2020 HP guideline criteria to these cases, classifying them into "typical HP," "probable HP," and "indeterminate for HP," as well as identifying "alternative diagnoses." They then compared these new classifications to the original pathological diagnoses for 217 of these cases. Clinical data, including serum markers and pulmonary function tests, were analyzed to compare groups with changed diagnoses versus those with unchanged diagnoses. The study also specifically compared the diagnostic yield of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) biopsies versus transbronchial lung cryobiopsy (TBLC) in the context of the new guideline.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 289 fibrotic interstitial pneumonia cases collected between 2014 and 2019 from a single medical institution. These cases were initially diagnosed based on either VATS biopsy or TBLC. No new datasets were created; the study involved re-evaluating existing pathology records and associated clinical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Significant Diagnostic Shift: The 2020 HP guideline dramatically reclassifies existing fIP cases, suggesting it's a powerful tool for standardizing diagnosis but also raising questions about its sensitivity and specificity.
  • Potential for Overdiagnosis: A substantial portion of cases previously diagnosed as non-fHP were reclassified as fHP, highlighting the guideline's tendency to increase fHP diagnoses. The authors raise concerns about whether this increase constitutes overdiagnosis.
  • TBLC Limitations: Transbronchial lung cryobiopsy (TBLC) appears less effective than VATS biopsy in yielding diagnoses that fit the "typical" or "probable" fHP categories under the new guideline. This suggests TBLC might underestimate fHP diagnoses when using these new criteria.
  • Clinical Data Ambiguity: While clinical data (like bird antigen exposure and BALF lymphocyte fraction) showed differences between groups, they didn't clearly distinguish between typical/probable fHP and indeterminate fHP cases, suggesting pathology remains the primary driver of diagnosis under the new guideline.
  • ACF as a Key, Yet Ambiguous, Criterion: Airway-centered fibrosis (ACF) is a crucial pathological feature in the new guideline. However, its precise definition and interpretation, especially in the context of smoking-related changes, remain areas for clarification.

Key Results

  • Of the 217 cases analyzed, 54 (25%) were reclassified from a non-fHP diagnosis to fHP under the 2020 HP guideline.
  • Of these 54 reclassified cases, 8 were classified as "typical fHP" and 46 as "probable fHP."
  • The proportion of "typical" and "probable" fHP diagnoses was significantly lower when using TBLC compared to VATS biopsies (15% vs. 37% for VATS, and 4.6% vs. 7.7% for TBLC, respectively, p < 0.001).
  • Clinical data for cases reclassified as fHP showed more resemblance to those diagnosed as "indeterminate for fHP" than to those classified as "typical" or "probable" fHP.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Pathology-Focused: The study focused solely on the pathological assessment of the guideline's impact. Multidisciplinary discussion (MDD), which integrates clinical and radiological findings, was not performed, meaning the "true" diagnostic impact might differ.
  • Retrospective Design: The study relied on existing data, which can introduce biases.
  • Single-Center Study: Data from a single center might not be generalizable to other populations or healthcare systems.
  • Granuloma Interpretation: The interpretation of granuloma location and significance can be subjective and may vary between raters.

Future work should involve:

  • MDD Integration: Evaluating the guideline's impact within a full MDD process.
  • Clinical Significance: Investigating whether the diagnostic changes identified by the guideline have a tangible impact on patient prognosis and treatment outcomes.
  • Clarifying Criteria: Further research is needed to refine the interpretation of key pathological criteria, such as ACF, and to establish consensus on their diagnostic weight, especially in complex cases with co-existing conditions like smoking-related lung disease.
  • TBLC Optimization: Exploring ways to improve the diagnostic yield of TBLC for fHP under the new guideline.

Summary updated

Abstract

It was reported that the 2020 guideline for hypersensitivity pneumonitis (HP) might result in the overdiagnosis of fibrotic HP (fHP). fHP and other types of interstitial pneumonias have several overlapping characteristics, and a high diagnostic concordance rate of fHP is rarely obtained. Therefore, we investigated the impact of the 2020 HP guideline on the pathological diagnosis of cases previously diagnosed as interstitial pneumonia. We identified 289 fibrotic interstitial pneumonia cases from 2014 to 2019 and classified them into four categories according to the 2020 HP guideline: typical, probable, and indeterminate for fHP and alternative diagnosis. The original pathological diagnosis of 217 cases were compared to their classification as either typical, probable, or indeterminate for fHP according to the 2020 guideline. The clinical data, including serum data and pulmonary function tests, were compared among the groups. Diagnoses changed from non-fHP to fHP for 54 (25%) of the 217 cases, of which, 8 were typical fHP and 46 were probable fHP. The ratio of typical and probable fHP cases to the total number of VATS cases was significantly lower when using transbronchial lung cryobiopsy (p < 0.001). The clinical data of these cases bore a more remarkable resemblance to those diagnosed as indeterminate for fHP than to those diagnosed as typical or probable. The pathological criteria in the new HP guidelines increase the diagnosis of fHP. However, it is unclear whether this increase leads to overdiagnosis, and requires further investigation. Transbronchial lung cryobiopsy may not be helpful when using the new criteria to impart findings for fHP diagnosis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ozasa2023effect,
  author = {Mutsumi Ozasa and Andrey Bychkov and Yoshiaki Zaizen and Kazuhiro Tabata and Wataru Uegami and Yasuhiko Yamano and Kensuke Kataoka and Takeshi Johkoh and Hiroshi Mukae and Yasuhiro Kondoh and Junya Fukuoka},
  title = {{Effect of the 2020 hypersensitivity pneumonitis guideline on the pathologic diagnosis of interstitial pneumonia}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-35986-9},
}
Figure