Effect of subgingival plaque control by a direct irrigation technique. 1. The clinical and microbiological changes after the irrigation with distilled water or 1/30 diluted iodine complex solution.

Satsuki Hagiwara, Nobuya Ogura, Mariko Kuchira, Tomoko Seki, Isao Ishikawa1988 · DOI

Abstract

This study evaluates the efficacy of a direct irrigation technique for subgingival plaque control in deep periodontal pockets. Twelve adult patients with pockets ≥ 4mm were treated using a specialized irrigation device (Pocket Irrigator PT-01) with either distilled water or a 1/30 diluted iodine solution. While clinical parameters like the gingival index showed no immediate significant changes, microbiological analysis revealed a substantial reduction in total bacterial counts and a favorable shift in microbial composition for up to seven days. The results suggest that the mechanical flushing action of direct irrigation is a potent tool for managing subgingival microflora.

Introduction

Periodontal disease is primarily driven by subgingival plaque—complex bacterial communities residing in the pockets between teeth and gingival tissue. A significant challenge in non-surgical periodontal therapy is the inability of standard oral hygiene tools, such as toothbrushes and floss, to reach depths exceeding 3mm. While chemical agents are available, their delivery into deep pockets remains problematic. This study investigates whether a direct, pulsating irrigation technique can effectively disrupt these deep-seated bacterial colonies and whether the addition of an antiseptic provides a measurable advantage over mechanical flushing alone.

Methodology

The study involved 12 patients exhibiting periodontal pockets of at least 4mm. The primary intervention utilized the "Pocket Irrigator PT-01," a device designed to deliver a pulsating jet of fluid at 2,000–3,000 pulses per minute.

Design of the specialized irrigation needle featuring side-ports for safe fluid delivery. *[Effect of subgingival plaque control by a direct irrigation technique.

  1. The clinical and microbiological changes after the irrigation with distilled water or 1/30 diluted iodine complex solution., page 2](/pdf/art_b87a6a7cd1214cc8b9ba73f80c1a6c70#page=2)*

A critical component of this technique was the use of a specialized 21-gauge needle. Unlike standard needles with terminal openings, this design featured side-ports to ensure lateral fluid movement, preventing the accidental forcing of bacteria or debris deeper into the periodontal tissues.

Clinical application of the direct irrigation technique in a periodontal pocket. *[Effect of subgingival plaque control by a direct irrigation technique.

  1. The clinical and microbiological changes after the irrigation with distilled water or 1/30 diluted iodine complex solution., page 3](/pdf/art_b87a6a7cd1214cc8b9ba73f80c1a6c70#page=3)*

Pockets were irrigated for 30 seconds with either distilled water or a 1/30 diluted povidone-iodine solution. Researchers monitored clinical markers (Plaque Index, Gingival Index, Probing Depth) and microbiological markers at baseline, immediately post-irrigation, and at intervals of 1 hour, 1 day, and 1 week. Bacterial samples were analyzed via dark-field microscopy to quantify total load and categorize morphology, specifically focusing on motile rods and spirochetes associated with active disease.

Results and Discussion

Mechanical vs. Chemical Efficacy

A key finding was that distilled water performed remarkably similarly to the iodine solution in reducing bacterial load. This indicates that the mechanical debridement—the "power washing" effect of the pulsating jet—is the primary mechanism of action for short-term bacterial reduction.

Microbiological Shifts

Total bacterial counts dropped significantly from baseline levels (approx. $10^7$–$10^8$ cells/ml) to roughly $10^6$ cells/ml immediately following irrigation. In the iodine group, the proportion of harmful motile microorganisms plummeted from 29.4% to 6.7%. This suppression of "bad actors" remained significant for approximately 24 hours before a gradual return toward baseline levels began.

Clinical Lag

Despite the immediate microbiological improvements, clinical indices such as gingival redness and swelling did not show significant changes within the one-week observation period. This suggests a "biological lag," where the inflammatory response of the host tissue takes longer to resolve than the bacterial population takes to be disrupted.

Conclusion

Direct subgingival irrigation is an effective method for reducing bacterial load and altering the microbial composition of deep periodontal pockets for up to seven days. However, the rapid rebound of motile bacteria after 24 hours suggests that irrigation should be viewed as a frequent maintenance tool rather than a one-time cure. For optimal therapeutic outcomes, this technique should supplement professional scaling and root planing to address hardened calculus that irrigation alone cannot remove.

Summary updated

Abstract

The efficacy of subgingival plaque control by the direct irrigation technique was studied. Twelve adult patients with periodontal pockets of 4mm or more received an initial treatment, followed by irrigation using the device called Pocket Irrigator PT-01 with distilled water or 1/30 diluted iodine complex solution. The clinical and microbiological parameters were recorded prior to the irrigation and immediately after, at 1 hour, 1 day and 1 week after the irrigation. The plaque index (P1. I.), gingival index (G. I.), gingival crevicular fluid (G. C. F.) and probing depth were used as clinical parameters. Samples of the bacteria were collected with paper points from the periodontal pockets. The samples were examined by dark field microscopy with the Petroff-Hauser counting chamber. The total number of bacteria and the microbial composition of each of the 12 pockets were examined. The clinical data showed no significant changes before and after the irrigation. The total number of bacteria decreased immediately after the irrigation and then increased gradually. The number of bacteria, however, maintained a lower level than those of the baseline during the whole experimental period. A significant change in the microbial composition also appeared. The proportion of motile rods and spirochetes decreased until 1 day and then increased gradually near to that of the baseline. The results indicate that pocket irrigation by distilled water or 1/30 diluted iodine complex solution is effective to eliminate the subgingival plaque until 7 days.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hagiwara1988effect,
  author = {Satsuki Hagiwara and Nobuya Ogura and Mariko Kuchira and Tomoko Seki and Isao Ishikawa},
  title = {{Effect of subgingival plaque control by a direct irrigation technique. 1. The clinical and microbiological changes after the irrigation with distilled water or 1/30 diluted iodine complex solution.}},
  booktitle = {THE},
  year = {1988},
  doi = {10.5357/koubyou.55.492},
}
Figure