TL;DR
This paper investigates how spraying polyurea on Ultra-High Performance Concrete (UHPC) slabs affects their resistance to near-field explosions. Using finite element modeling validated by field tests, the study found that polyurea significantly enhances blast performance, particularly by reducing crack width and mitigating damage, with an optimal thickness identified for practical applications.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Ultra-High Performance Concrete (UHPC) offers superior mechanical properties compared to traditional concrete, making it suitable for critical structures. However, UHPC slabs can still suffer severe flexural failure and fragment under extreme dynamic loads like near-field explosions, posing risks to personnel and surrounding infrastructure. While polyurea has shown promise in improving the blast resistance of various materials, its effectiveness on UHPC slabs, especially under near-field blast conditions, remained unclear. This research aims to fill that knowledge gap by quantifying the benefits of polyurea strengthening for UHPC slabs and identifying optimal application parameters.
Methods
The study employed a multi-faceted approach:
- Finite Element (FE) Modeling: A detailed FE model was developed using LS-DYNA to simulate the dynamic response of UHPC and polyurea-strengthened UHPC (PUHPC) slabs under near-field explosions. The model incorporated advanced material models for UHPC (KCC model with modified damage function) and polyurea (*MAT_SIMPLIFIED_RUBBER/FOAM model), along with Hughes-Liu beam elements for steel reinforcement.
- Field Blast Tests: The FE model was rigorously validated against experimental data from field blast tests. This validation involved comparing damage patterns and deflection measurements of UHPC and PUHPC slabs subjected to controlled explosions.
- Parametric Analysis: Once validated, the FE model was used to conduct extensive parametric studies. The influence of key factors such as scaled distance, polyurea thickness, span-to-depth ratio of the slab, and longitudinal reinforcement ratio on the anti-blast performance was systematically investigated.
- Prediction Formula Development: Based on the parametric analysis, a multivariate nonlinear regression algorithm was used to develop a prediction formula for estimating the end rotation of UHPC slabs, with and without polyurea, under various near-field explosion scenarios.
Datasets
The study utilized data from field blast tests involving five UHPC slab specimens. These tests provided crucial experimental data for validating the FE model, including damage patterns and deflection measurements under different scaled distances. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing experimental data was used for model calibration and validation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Polyurea as a Protective Layer: Spraying polyurea on the rear face of UHPC slabs effectively reduces crack width and mitigates overall damage, acting as a protective layer that absorbs and dissipates blast energy.
- Synergy with Deformation: The strengthening effect of polyurea becomes more pronounced as the UHPC slab experiences larger deflections, suggesting its enhanced role in preventing catastrophic failure under severe blast loads.
- Optimal Polyurea Thickness: There's a threshold for polyurea thickness beyond which further increases yield diminishing returns. For the tested UHPC slabs with a span-to-depth ratio of 20, an optimal polyurea thickness of 8-12 mm was identified for balancing performance enhancement and material usage.
- Reinforcement Ratio Matters: Polyurea's effectiveness is more significant for UHPC slabs with lower longitudinal reinforcement ratios, as it helps compensate for the reduced inherent strength and improves post-peak behavior.
- Span-to-Depth Ratio Influence: The strengthening effect of polyurea is more pronounced when the UHPC slab primarily undergoes flexural damage, which tends to occur with larger span-to-depth ratios.
Key Results
- Damage Reduction: Polyurea application consistently reduced crack width and distribution on the rear face of UHPC slabs compared to unstrengthened UHPC.
- Deflection Mitigation: Maximum and residual deflections of UHPC slabs were significantly reduced by polyurea spraying. For instance, at a scaled distance of 0.4 m/kg¹/³, deflections were reduced by approximately 5-6 mm, and at 0.3 m/kg¹/³, reductions reached 11-14 mm.
- Energy Absorption: While the total absorbed internal energy of PUHPC slabs was lower than UHPC slabs (due to polyurea absorbing energy), the polyurea layer itself contributed significantly to energy dissipation, especially at smaller scaled distances.
- Prediction Formula Accuracy: The developed prediction formula for end rotation showed a good match with numerical simulations (R² score of 0.990226), enabling quick assessment of blast damage.
Limitations and Future Work
- Scaled Distance Range: The current study focused on near-field explosions (0.3-0.6 m/kg¹/³). The authors suggest further investigation into the effectiveness of polyurea under smaller scaled distances or contact detonation scenarios.
- Boundary Conditions: The prediction formula, while validated, could be improved by incorporating more parameters like boundary conditions, slab width, and standoff distance of the explosive.
- Failure Modes: The developed formula is not suitable for UHPC slabs experiencing combined flexural-shear failure.
- Damage Assessment Criterion: The authors recommend developing a more comprehensive damage assessment criterion for polyurea-strengthened UHPC slabs.
Summary updated