Effect of prosthodontic planning on lateral occlusion scheme: a comparison between conventional and digital planning

Jaafar Abduo, Mohammed Bennamoun, Marc Tennant, John K. McGeachieJournal of Applied Oral Science 2015 · DOI

Abstract

Although the prosthodontic planning had influenced the pattern of the lateral occlusion scheme and contacts, there was no difference between the conventional and digital prosthodontic planning.

Introduction

In modern prosthodontics, the "wax-up" serves as a critical 3D blueprint for proposed dental treatments. Traditionally, these are crafted manually by applying wax to stone models. With the advent of digital dentistry, virtual wax-ups have become a viable alternative. However, a key concern remains: do digital tools accurately replicate the functional dynamics of lateral occlusion—the way teeth interact during side-to-side jaw movements? This study investigates whether transitioning from conventional to digital planning impacts the resulting lateral occlusion patterns, specifically focusing on canine-guided occlusion versus group function.

Methods

The study compared two planning methods using dental models from 10 patients requiring fixed prosthodontic treatment.

  1. Conventional Planning: An experienced technician created manual wax-ups on physical articulators.
  2. Digital Planning: Physical models were scanned using a micro-CT scanner to generate high-resolution STL images. Virtual "physiological teeth" were then manually fitted to these models using Geomagic Studio software.
Digital representation of a dental arch used for virtual prosthodontic planning.

To evaluate functional outcomes, the researchers simulated horizontal mandibular movement at four positions (0.5, 1.0, 2.0, and 3.0 mm). Contacts were detected at 0.05 mm vertical increments. The primary variables measured were the prevalence of occlusion schemes, the average number of contacting teeth, and the specific teeth involved in contact.

Results and Discussion

The analysis revealed that both planning methods significantly altered the patient's pre-treatment occlusion, typically shifting it toward a more protected, canine-dominant scheme. This "reset" is likely due to the restoration of ideal tooth anatomy that may have been lost to wear.

Virtual simulation of lateral jaw movement and contact detection at various positions (A-E).

Key findings include:

  • Digital Parity: There was no statistical difference between conventional and digital wax-ups regarding the number of contacting teeth or the type of occlusion scheme produced.
  • Progressive Occlusion: The study observed that occlusion is dynamic; a patient might exhibit group function at a 0.5 mm excursion but transition to canine-guided occlusion at 3.0 mm.
  • Canine Dominance: In both groups, canine-guided occlusion increased as the jaw moved further from the center (from ~20% at 0.5 mm to ~60-65% at 3.0 mm). The canines and first premolars were the most frequent contacting teeth.

Conclusion

Digital wax-ups provide a reliable alternative to traditional manual methods for functional prosthodontic planning. While both methods influence the lateral occlusion scheme by increasing canine guidance, they yield statistically similar results. Future research should focus on the clinical performance of the final manufactured restorations to ensure that the virtual precision translates effectively to patient outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although the prosthodontic planning had influenced the pattern of the lateral occlusion scheme and contacts, there was no difference between the conventional and digital prosthodontic planning.
BibTeX
@article{abduo2015effect,
  author = {Jaafar Abduo and Mohammed Bennamoun and Marc Tennant and John K. McGeachie},
  title = {{Effect of prosthodontic planning on lateral occlusion scheme: a comparison between conventional and digital planning}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Oral Science},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1590/1678-775720140491},
}
Figure