Effect of Music Therapy Combined With Aerobic Exercise on Sleep Quality Among Patients With Chemotherapy After Radical Mastectomy: Results From a Randomized Controlled Trial

Chang Li, Yan Wang, Jie Zhang, Wenqian Zhao, Lei Yang, Xiaomei LiResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Sleep disorders are a prevalent and debilitating side effect for breast cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy following radical mastectomy. This study investigated the efficacy of a combined intervention of music therapy and aerobic exercise on sleep quality. In a randomized controlled trial of 100 female patients, the intervention group (n=51) received twice-daily music therapy and thrice-weekly aerobic exercise alongside routine care, while the control group (n=49) received routine care only. Sleep quality was assessed using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) at baseline and after the 1st, 3rd, and 6th chemotherapy cycles. Results indicated significant improvements in the intervention group across all PSQI dimensions compared to the control group, where sleep quality progressively declined. The study concludes that this non-pharmacological combined therapy is an effective strategy for improving sleep in this patient population.

Introduction

Breast cancer morbidity and mortality have risen significantly, with sleep disorders affecting up to 90% of patients during treatment. Poor sleep quality exacerbates fatigue, anxiety, and depression, severely impacting the quality of life for women recovering from radical mastectomies and undergoing chemotherapy. While individual benefits of music therapy and aerobic exercise have been documented, their combined effect during the critical post-mastectomy chemotherapy phase remains under-explored. This study aims to fill that gap by evaluating a structured, dual-modality intervention.

Methods

A randomized controlled trial was conducted at the Shaanxi Province Tumor Hospital involving 100 female breast cancer patients. Participants were recruited via convenient sampling and randomly assigned to either an intervention group (n=51) or a control group (n=49).

The intervention consisted of:

  1. Music Therapy: 30-minute sessions twice daily, featuring a selection of 334 instrumental tracks (nature sounds, classical, and folk).
  2. Aerobic Exercise: A 20–25 minute routine (including joint rotations and limb swings) performed three times per week.

The control group received standard nursing care. Baseline characteristics, including demographic and clinical data, were collected to ensure group comparability.

Baseline characteristics of the study participants (Part 1).

As shown in the tables above, there were no statistically significant differences (P > 0.05) between the two groups at baseline regarding age, marital status, education, income, or clinical stage, establishing a robust foundation for the trial.

Results

At baseline, 89% of all participants reported significant sleep issues (PSQI > 7), with a mean score of 8.86 ± 2.34. Over the course of six chemotherapy cycles, the two groups followed divergent trajectories:

  • Intervention Group: Demonstrated a steady decline in PSQI scores, indicating improved sleep. The mean score dropped from 8.82 at baseline to 6.08 by the third post-test.
  • Control Group: Experienced a significant worsening of sleep quality, with mean PSQI scores rising from 8.90 to 11.00.

Linear mixed model analysis confirmed that the intervention significantly improved all sub-dimensions of the PSQI, including subjective sleep quality, sleep latency, duration, and daytime dysfunction (P < 0.001). The treatment effect became more pronounced as the chemotherapy cycles progressed.

Discussion and Conclusion

The findings suggest a synergistic effect between music therapy and aerobic exercise. Music therapy likely addresses the psychological stressors and neuroendocrine imbalances associated with cancer treatment, while aerobic exercise enhances physical conditioning and promotes biochemical changes (e.g., increased serotonin) conducive to sleep.

Despite limitations such as reliance on self-reported data and a single-center design, the results provide strong evidence for integrating these low-cost, non-invasive therapies into standard oncological care. Future research should incorporate objective biomarkers and larger, multi-center cohorts to further validate these findings and explore long-term outcomes.

In conclusion, combining music therapy with aerobic exercise significantly improves sleep quality and mitigates the sleep degradation typically observed during chemotherapy for breast cancer patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background : The morbidity and mortality of breast cancer have gradually increased in recent years, seriously threatening women's health. Sleep disorder is one of the most common symptoms in patients with breast cancer. In recent years, with the increasing awareness of the importance of the quality of life of cancer patients, reducing symptoms and improving the quality of sleep have become the focus of cancer research. Some studies shown that music therapy can effectively promote the sleep quality. Other studies have indicated that aerobic exercise has the positive effect on sleep quality. However, the effects of these interventions on sleep quality of breast cancer patients, especially those in the chemotherapy after radical mastectomy is still unclear. Objective: The aim of this study was to explore the effect of music therapy combined with aerobic exercise on the sleep quality of patients undergoing chemotherapy after radical mastectomy. Methods: A randomized controlled trial was conducted at Breast Disease Diagnosis and Treatment Center, Shaanxi Province Tumor Hospital from November 2017 to January 2019.A total of 100 female breast cancer patients who underwent modified radical mastectomy (MRM) or extensive radical mastectomy (ERM), were recruited through convenient sampling, and randomly allocated into an intervention group of 51 patients and a control group with 49 patients respectively. The intervention group accepted music therapy combined with aerobic exercise from the first to the sixth admission to hospital for chemotherapy in addition to the routine nursing care, while the control group received only routine nursing care. Sleep quality of these patients were measured 3 times, eg, at the end of 10 days, the first cycle of chemotherapy, the third cycle of chemotherapy and the end of the sixth cycle of chemotherapy using Pittsburgh sleep quality index (PSQI), and to compare the total score of sleep quality and the difference of each factor between the two groups. A linear mixed model was used to measure the effect on PSQI of patients after controlling for other confounding factors. Results: The mean score of sleep quality of breast cancer patients who received chemotherapy after radical mastectomy, were 8.86±2.34.The patients with PSQI score greater than 7 points accounted for approximately 89.0%. Moreover, there were more than half of the patients with scores of subjective sleep quality, sleep duration, sleep disturbance and daytime dysfunction higher than 2 points. 56.0% of patients had the problem of poor subjective sleep quality; 42.0% of patients had the trouble in falling asleep; 34.0% of patients had sleep disturbance (easy to get up, get up early, frequently to go toilet at night). About 34.0% of patients slept less than 6 hours, and had daytime dysfunction such as energy shortage and fatigue.Significant improvements from baseline in all indices for sleep quality measurement were observed throughout the intervention period from 1st post-test to 3rd post-test.With the increase of chemotherapy cycle, the total score of PSQI and the score of sleep quality in the intervention group showed a decreasing trend. However, change in PSQI-total had increased from 1st post-test to 3rd post-test gradually increased in the intervention group (difference between groups: -1.31(-2.05,-0.57)to -2.102(-2.84,-1.36)) .On the contrary, significant increases in changes of the PSQI-total in control groups from 1st post-test to 3rd post-test was clear (difference between groups: 0.55 (-0.18,1.2752) to 2.75 (2.02,3.47)). Limitations : The data were self-reported, which could be influenced by many potential factors, and no biomarkers or physiological measurements were done, which need to be further explored. What’s more, bigger sample size was needed in the future studies to enhance the representativeness of the subjects. Conclusions: Music therapy combined with aerobic exercise intervention can significantly improve the sleepy quality of female breast cancer patients with chemotherapy after radical mastectomy, and it has a good continuous improvement effect on many aspects of reactive sleep.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021effect,
  author = {Chang Li and Yan Wang and Jie Zhang and Wenqian Zhao and Lei Yang and Xiaomei Li},
  title = {{Effect of Music Therapy Combined With Aerobic Exercise on Sleep Quality Among Patients With Chemotherapy After Radical Mastectomy: Results From a Randomized Controlled Trial}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-208542/v1},
}
Figure