Effect of long-term rotation on astigmatism following EVO-toric intraocular collamer lens implantation

Xun Chen, Huamao Miao, Mingrui Cheng, I-Chun Lin, Boliang Li, Yinjie Jiang, Yadi Lei, Xiaoying Wang, Xingtao ZhouFrontiers in Medicine 2023 · DOI

Abstract

EVO-TICL implantation is safe and effective, with good predictability and stability. OPD-Scan is a fast device to detect the axial position of the TICL without mydriasis, and the axial position is relatively stable in the long term postoperatively. A slight rotation of low-astigmatic TICL may not cause postoperative astigmatism, whereas rotation of the high-astigmatic TICL may cause it.

Introduction

For patients with high myopia and astigmatism, the EVO-toric intraocular collamer lens (EVO-TICL) offers a surgical alternative to laser-based refractive procedures. As these lenses are toric, their effectiveness depends on precise alignment with the eye's astigmatic axis. While short-term stability is well-documented, long-term data on rotational stability—and how it impacts visual outcomes for different levels of astigmatism—has been limited. This study addresses this gap through a three-year prospective analysis.

Methods

The study followed 40 eyes from 22 patients at the Fudan University Eye Ear Nose and Throat Hospital. Patients were evaluated at 1 month and 3 years post-implantation. A key methodological advancement was the use of the OPD-Scan III aberrometer to measure the lens's axial position. Unlike traditional slit-lamp examinations, this device operates without mydriasis (pupil dilation), providing a faster and more natural assessment of the lens position.

OPD-Scan III measurement of the EVO-TICL axis, showing the steep (red) and flat (blue) axes and the calculated lens axis (green).

Researchers used Alpin vector analysis to compare target versus achieved astigmatism correction and categorized outcomes into "low astigmatism" (<2.0D) and "high astigmatism" (≥2.0D) groups.

Results

The procedure demonstrated excellent safety and efficacy over the three-year period. The safety index was 1.32, and the efficacy index was 1.01. At the three-year mark, 97.5% of eyes achieved a Uncorrected Distance Visual Acuity (UDVA) of 20/40 or better.

Distribution of changes in Snellen lines of CDVA 36 months post-surgery, showing high safety with no eyes losing two or more lines.

Regarding rotational stability, 90% of lenses rotated less than 15° over three years. However, there was a statistically significant increase in the mean absolute rotation from 3.70° at one month to 6.00° at three years (p < 0.001). Despite this slight "creep," 75% of eyes remained within ±0.50D of the target refractive astigmatism.

Discussion and Key Insights

The study revealed a critical "tolerance gap" between astigmatism levels. Patients with low astigmatism (<2D) could often tolerate rotations up to 10° without significant residual astigmatism. In contrast, those with high astigmatism (≥2D) were much more sensitive, where rotations as small as 5° could lead to noticeable visual impairment.

Additionally, the study noted a minor shift toward myopia (mean spherical equivalent changing from 0.06D to -0.36D), which was attributed to natural axial elongation in high-myopia patients rather than lens instability. The OPD-Scan III proved to be a superior tool for long-term tracking due to its non-invasive nature and efficiency in locating TICL axis markers.

Limitations

The study's primary limitations include a relatively small sample size (40 eyes) and the absence of immediate (Day 0) postoperative measurements, which makes it difficult to distinguish initial surgical misalignment from subsequent rotation. Future research should explore how lens sizing and "vault" (the space between the TICL and the natural lens) influence long-term rotational stability.

Summary updated

Abstract

EVO-TICL implantation is safe and effective, with good predictability and stability. OPD-Scan is a fast device to detect the axial position of the TICL without mydriasis, and the axial position is relatively stable in the long term postoperatively. A slight rotation of low-astigmatic TICL may not cause postoperative astigmatism, whereas rotation of the high-astigmatic TICL may cause it.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023effect,
  author = {Xun Chen and Huamao Miao and Mingrui Cheng and I-Chun Lin and Boliang Li and Yinjie Jiang and Yadi Lei and Xiaoying Wang and Xingtao Zhou},
  title = {{Effect of long-term rotation on astigmatism following EVO-toric intraocular collamer lens implantation}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Medicine},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fmed.2023.1194006},
}

Loading related content...

Figure