Effect of Lanthanum-Cerium Rare Earth Elements on Steel at Atomic Scale: A Review

Yuhang Liu, Jianguo Zhi, Ziyu Lyu, Chao Gu, Wangcai Diao, Zhibo Qu, Yanping BaoMetals 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This review delves into the atomic-scale effects of lanthanum (La) and cerium (Ce) rare earth elements in steel, primarily using first-principles density-functional theory (DFT) calculations. It highlights how these elements influence inclusion formation, solid solution behavior, and electronic structure, ultimately enhancing steel properties like toughness and corrosion resistance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While rare earth (RE) elements like La and Ce are known to improve steel properties, the precise atomic-level mechanisms behind these improvements remain complex and challenging to study experimentally. Traditional methods struggle to probe the rapid, microscopic interactions of RE atoms and their resulting inclusions within the steel matrix. This paper aims to bridge this gap by reviewing how first-principles DFT calculations can elucidate these intricate atomic-scale behaviors, providing a deeper understanding for designing advanced RE steels.

Methods

The core methodology discussed is first-principles calculations based on Density-Functional Theory (DFT). This approach leverages quantum mechanics to solve the Schrödinger equation for electrons and nuclei in a material, allowing for the prediction of properties without empirical parameters. The paper outlines the general steps involved: selecting appropriate software (like VASP or CASTEP), defining the material model (protocell or supercell), setting calculation parameters (e.g., energy cutoffs, k-point grids), performing structural optimization, and then analyzing results such as electronic structures, formation energies, and mechanical properties. The review specifically focuses on how DFT is applied to study RE inclusions (nucleation, stability, mechanical properties, corrosion behavior) and the behavior of dissolved RE atoms (solid solution sites, segregation, microalloying effects).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review of existing research and computational studies, not a presentation of new experimental data or a dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual Nature of REs: La and Ce act both as inclusion formers and solid solution microalloying elements, each contributing to property enhancements.
  • Ce's Unique Valence: Cerium's ability to exist in both Ce³⁺ and Ce⁴⁺ states leads to distinct nucleation and stability characteristics compared to La.
  • Inclusion Formation Hierarchy: RE oxides generally form preferentially over sulfides, with a specific order of stability (e.g., Re₂O₃ > ReAlO₃ > Re₂O₂S > ReSx).
  • Mechanical Enhancement by ReAlO₃: Among RE inclusions, ReAlO₃ shows particularly strong mechanical properties, suggesting it can significantly improve steel's deformation and fracture resistance.
  • Grain Refinement Nucleation: Certain RE oxides (like CeO₂ and La₂O₃) can act as effective heterogeneous nucleation sites for austenite, leading to finer grains.
  • Solid Solution Site Preference: RE atoms tend to occupy specific interstitial or substitutional sites (S-sites in particular) in the Fe matrix, with their behavior influenced by electron release and polarization effects.
  • Segregation at Boundaries: Due to their large atomic radii, RE atoms preferentially segregate at grain boundaries and dislocations, enhancing cohesion and stabilizing these regions.
  • Microalloying via Electronic Structure Modification: RE atoms hybridize with Fe's d-orbitals, altering the electronic density of states, reducing magnetic moments, and increasing toughness.
  • Corrosion Tendency Varies: The corrosion behavior of RE inclusions is composition-dependent, with some (like CeAlO₃) potentially enhancing corrosion resistance while others (like Ce₂O₃) increase susceptibility.

Key Results

The paper summarizes findings from numerous DFT studies:

  • Inclusion Stability: Formation enthalpies indicate a clear preference for certain RE inclusion types (e.g., Re₂O₃ is more stable than ReS).
  • Mechanical Properties: ReAlO₃ exhibits significantly higher bulk modulus (B), shear modulus (G), and Young's modulus (E) compared to other RE inclusions and pure Fe. Ductile materials include Fe, Re₂O₃, Re₂O₂S, and ReS, while others are brittle.
  • Heterogeneous Nucleation: CeO₂ and La₂O₃ are identified as effective nucleation cores for y-Fe, with specific chemical potential conditions required for ReAlO₃ to act as a nucleation core for y-Fe and a-Fe.
  • Solid Solution: RE atoms are found to occupy specific sites in Fe (e.g., S-sites in α-Fe for La).
  • Corrosion Tendency: Theoretical corrosion tendencies are ranked, showing, for example, LaS > La₂O₂S > LaAlO₃ > Fe for La-containing inclusions.
  • Electronic Structure: RE doping leads to hybridization of RE d/f orbitals with Fe d-orbitals, reducing the magnetic moment of Fe and increasing electron cloud density.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Challenges in DFT Application: The paper acknowledges challenges in applying DFT, including the computational cost for large systems, the need for accurate treatment of complex electronic structures (especially for REs), and the difficulty in fully capturing multi-scale phenomena (from atomic to macroscopic).
  • Future Directions:
    • More comprehensive studies are needed on the nucleation mechanisms of La-based inclusions.
  • Future research should integrate first-principles calculations with dislocation dynamics simulations to better understand the interaction between dislocations and RE inclusions.
  • There's a need for more in-depth studies on the coupling relationship between multiple scales (atomic to macroscopic) to understand how atomic-level mechanisms influence macroscopic performance.
  • Combining first-principles calculations with multi-scale models (like molecular dynamics) and experimental verification is crucial for a more realistic system environment and a comprehensive understanding of RE behavior in steel.

Summary updated

Abstract

Lanthanum-cerium rare earth (RE) elements play a vital role in metallurgy as essential microalloying elements. Their addition significantly modifies inclusion characteristics, enhances mechanical properties, and improves corrosion resistance. This review emphasizes the distinct and synergistic roles of lanthanum (La) and cerium (Ce) in steel at the atomic scale, elucidated through first-principles calculations based on density-functional theory (DFT). The primary focus includes the nucleation mechanisms and characteristics of rare earth inclusions, the solid solution and segregation behavior of rare earth atoms, and their microalloying effects on electronic structure and interfacial bonding. Although both elements form stable inclusions Re2O3 and ReAlO3 and exhibit grain refinement effects, Ce exhibits a unique dual valence state (Ce3+/Ce4+). This results in nucleation behavior and oxide stability for Ce ions that differ slightly from those of La. Both elements alter the electronic structure of the Fe matrix through hybridization with d-orbitals, reducing magnetic moment and enhancing toughness. Compared to other alloying elements, La and Ce exhibit unique behaviors due to their large atomic radii and high chemical reactivity, which influence their solid solubility, segregation tendencies, and interactions with other atoms such as Cr, C, and N. Finally, this paper discusses the challenges that exist when first-principles computational methods are used to study the mechanism of action of RE elements in steel, and proposes measures and methods to address these challenges, aiming to provide an in-depth understanding of the mechanism of action of REs in steel at the microscopic level and to promote the application of computational chemistry in the field of metallurgy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025effect,
  author = {Yuhang Liu and Jianguo Zhi and Ziyu Lyu and Chao Gu and Wangcai Diao and Zhibo Qu and Yanping Bao},
  title = {{Effect of Lanthanum-Cerium Rare Earth Elements on Steel at Atomic Scale: A Review}},
  booktitle = {Metals},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/met15090993},
}
Figure