Effect of irradiation on silicate aggregates’ density and stiffness

N. M. Anoop Krishnan, Yann Le Pape, Gaurav Sant, Mathieu BauchyJournal of Nuclear Materials 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses atomistic simulations to investigate how neutron irradiation affects the density and stiffness of common silicate minerals, which are crucial components in nuclear concrete. The findings reveal that irradiation causes swelling and structural disordering, with the extent depending on the mineral's inherent structure rather than its mineralogical family. This work provides valuable insights for selecting radiation-resistant aggregates to ensure the long-term integrity of nuclear structures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nuclear power plants and facilities for storing low-level nuclear waste often use concrete as a structural material. Silicate minerals are abundant and make up a significant portion of this concrete, acting as aggregates. When exposed to high-energy radiation, these silicate aggregates can undergo changes that might compromise the concrete's structural integrity. Specifically, irradiation can cause the minerals to swell, leading to internal stresses, micro-cracks, and potential failure of the concrete. While some studies have looked at a few archetypal minerals, a comprehensive understanding of how irradiation affects a broader range of silicate minerals, and the underlying mechanisms, has been lacking. This gap in knowledge is concerning for predicting and ensuring the safety and longevity of concrete in nuclear environments.

Methods

The researchers employed molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to model the effects of neutron irradiation on eight different silicate minerals. The process involved:

  • Atomistic Simulations: Simulating the behavior of individual atoms within the mineral structures.
  • Ballistic Cascade Modeling: Simulating the impact of energetic neutrons, which knock atoms out of their positions, creating a cascade of atomic displacements.
  • Structural Analysis: Using the pair distribution function (PDF) to characterize the atomic structure and identify changes in local order and density.
  • Elastic Property Calculation: Computing the complete elastic tensor to determine the stiffness of the minerals before and after irradiation.
  • Vitrification Comparison: Preparing isochemical glassy counterparts of the minerals to compare their properties with irradiated states, serving as a potential surrogate for predicting swelling.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data generated through MD simulations, not on pre-existing experimental datasets for training. Experimental data is used for validation of the simulation results.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structure Trumps Family: The degree of swelling and structural change upon irradiation is primarily dictated by the mineral's specific crystal structure and atomic arrangement (topology), not by its broad mineralogical family (nesosilicate, inosilicate, tectosilicate).
  • Vitrification as a Predictor: The swelling observed in irradiated minerals is comparable to that seen in their vitrified (glassy) counterparts. This suggests that studying glasses can provide a reliable estimate of the upper limit of irradiation-induced swelling.
  • Isotropy Upon Irradiation: Irradiated minerals, much like glasses, tend to become elastically isotropic, meaning their stiffness is uniform in all directions.
  • Swelling Drives Stress: The magnitude of internal stress developed in confined minerals due to irradiation is strongly correlated with the extent of volumetric swelling.
  • Stiffness Matters Too: While swelling is a primary driver of stress, changes in the mineral's stiffness (either stiffening or softening) upon irradiation also play a significant role in determining the magnitude of the induced stress.

Key Results

  • All eight silicate minerals studied exhibited structural disordering upon irradiation, leading to a more disordered, liquid-like structure at saturation.
  • Swelling was observed in most minerals, with quartz showing a significant volumetric swelling of up to 18%, consistent with experimental data.
  • Density changes upon irradiation were generally in agreement with trends observed during vitrification, though irradiation-induced swelling was often slightly less pronounced.
  • The elastic moduli of the minerals became isotropic after irradiation.
  • Calculated internal stresses in confined conditions were significantly higher than the typical strength of cement hydrates, highlighting the potential for cracking. For example, quartz showed increased stress due to stiffening, while jadeite and almandine experienced reduced stress due to softening.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Comparison Challenges: The authors note that direct comparison with experimental results is difficult due to potential issues in experiments such as the development of microcracks, incomplete saturation of damage, and sensitivity to ambient conditions.
  • Confined vs. Bulk Behavior: While the study models confined conditions, the exact behavior in a complex concrete matrix, with multiple aggregate types and a cementitious binder, will be more intricate.
  • Future Work: The study suggests that the findings can guide the selection of optimal aggregate minerals to minimize the risk of concrete failure in nuclear environments. Further work could focus on extending these simulations to more complex aggregate mixtures and investigating the interaction between irradiated aggregates and the cement matrix. The use of vitrification as a surrogate for predicting swelling is also highlighted as a valuable avenue for future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{krishnan2018effect,
  author = {N. M. Anoop Krishnan and Yann Le Pape and Gaurav Sant and Mathieu Bauchy},
  title = {{Effect of irradiation on silicate aggregates’ density and stiffness}},
  journal = {Journal of Nuclear Materials},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jnucmat.2018.10.009},
}
Figure