Effect of Hybrid Carbon-Based Fillers on Electrical and Mechanical Performance of Strain-Hardening Cementitious Composites (SHCCs)

Liangliang Wei, Chenxi Xiao, Bixuan Yang, shouwang hu, Y. G. ZhengBuildings 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the synergistic effects of combining carbon black (CB) and carbon fibers (CF) in strain-hardening cementitious composites (SHCC) to achieve both high electrical conductivity and robust mechanical performance. By optimizing the hybrid filler content, the researchers significantly reduced electrical resistivity by three orders of magnitude while simultaneously enhancing tensile strength and strain, offering a promising pathway for developing advanced multifunctional concrete.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cementitious composites are ubiquitous in construction, but their traditional role is limited to structural support. There's a growing interest in developing "multifunctional" concrete that can perform additional tasks, such as self-sensing, electrothermal heating, or energy harvesting, all of which rely on electrical conductivity. However, achieving high electrical conductivity in ductile cementitious composites like Strain-Hardening Cementitious Composites (SHCC) has been challenging. While individual conductive fillers like carbon black (CB) or carbon fibers (CF) have been studied, their combined effects and synergistic mechanisms for optimizing both electrical and mechanical properties remain underexplored. A key challenge is that adding conductive fillers often compromises the mechanical integrity of the composite, creating a trade-off that this research aims to overcome.

Methods

The researchers developed various SHCC mixes incorporating different combinations and amounts of nano carbon black (NCB) and chopped carbon fibers (CF), alongside standard polyethylene (PE) fibers.

  • Material Preparation: They used a standard cementitious matrix with silica fume and fine quartz sand. The conductive fillers included a nano carbon black dispersion liquid (CBDL) and chopped carbon fibers. PE fibers were used as the primary reinforcement for SHCC.
  • Mixing Procedure: A specific mixing protocol was followed using a mortar mixer, ensuring uniform dispersion of the fillers. The workability of the fresh mixtures was assessed using a flowability test.
  • Electrical Conductivity Measurement: The four-electrode voltammetry method was employed to measure electrical resistivity at 7, 14, and 28 days of curing. This method is chosen to eliminate contact resistance and polarization effects.
  • Mechanical Property Testing: Compressive and flexural strengths were evaluated according to standard GB/T17671-2021. Uniaxial tensile tests were conducted following JSCE recommendations for high-performance fiber-reinforced cement composites, using clip-on extensometers to measure deformation.
  • Microscopic Analysis: Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) was used to examine the fracture surfaces of selected specimens, providing insights into the microstructure, filler dispersion, and the formation of conductive networks. Energy Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDS) was used for elemental mapping.
  • Hybrid Efficiency Index (HEI): A novel HEI was proposed to quantitatively assess the trade-offs between electrical conductivity and mechanical properties, allowing for a balanced evaluation of different formulations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from the prepared SHCC specimens.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Enhancement: The combination of carbon black (CB) and carbon fibers (CF) in SHCC leads to a synergistic effect, significantly improving electrical conductivity beyond what either filler can achieve alone.
  • Reduced Resistivity: Hybrid fillers dramatically reduce electrical resistivity, achieving values below 150 Ω·cm (a reduction of three orders of magnitude) with optimal combinations (e.g., 5 wt.% NCB and 0.2-0.4 vol.% CF).
  • Mechanical Property Trade-off Mitigation: While single CB addition often degrades mechanical properties, the hybrid approach, particularly with optimized CF content, can enhance tensile strength and strain, and even improve compressive and flexural strength compared to single-filler systems.
  • Mechanism of Conductivity: The research elucidates how CB contributes to conductivity through direct contact and quantum tunneling, while CF acts as a "bridge," linking CB particles and forming a more robust 3D conductive network. This multi-phase conductive path is key to the enhanced performance.
  • Hybrid Efficiency Index (HEI): The introduction of HEI provides a valuable tool for material designers to quantitatively balance the competing demands of electrical conductivity and mechanical performance, allowing for tailored material design based on application priorities.

Key Results

  • Electrical Conductivity: The electrical resistivity of PE-SHCC increased with curing, while the addition of hybrid fillers significantly decreased it. Optimal combinations (5 wt.% NCB + 0.2-0.4 vol.% CF) reduced resistivity to <150 Ω·cm.
  • Mechanical Properties:
    • Compressive Strength: Single CB addition reduced compressive strength significantly. Single CF addition also reduced it, but to a lesser extent. Hybrid fillers (e.g., 5 wt.% NCB + 0.2 vol.% CF) showed an 18.4% increase in compressive strength compared to single-filler systems.
  • Flexural Strength: Similar trends were observed, with hybrid fillers showing potential for improvement.
  • Tensile Strength and Strain: The optimal hybrid formulation (5 wt.% NCB + 0.4 vol.% CF) resulted in a 37.3% increase in tensile strength and an 82.6% increase in tensile strain compared to the reference PE-SHCC.
  • HEI: The HEI demonstrated that hybrid fillers generally yield higher efficiency scores, especially when prioritizing electrical conductivity or a balanced approach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Long-term Performance: The study acknowledges that the long-term performance, durability, electrical stability, and resistance to environmental factors (freeze-thaw, wetting-drying, sustained loading) of these hybrid SHCCs have not been thoroughly investigated.
  • Filler Content Range: The study focused on a defined range of filler contents and a fixed PE fiber volume fraction. Further exploration of wider ranges and different fiber types could yield further optimizations.
  • Microscopic Understanding: While SEM and EDS provided valuable insights, advanced characterization techniques like X-ray computed tomography could offer a deeper quantitative understanding of the 3D conductive network formation, filler dispersion, and fiber-matrix interfaces across multiple scales.
  • HEI Subjectivity: The HEI's interpretation and weighting coefficients (α and β) are subjective and depend on specific application requirements. Further research could explore standardized weighting schemes or adaptive HEI formulations.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: While the paper mentions considering reduced cost, a detailed cost-benefit analysis of the optimized hybrid formulations would be beneficial for practical implementation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electrically conductive cement-based composites exhibit significant potential for a range of multifunctional applications. Nonetheless, the electrical and mechanical performance of ductile cement-based composites incorporating compound conductive additives has not been sufficiently explored. This study examines the effects of two distinct carbon-based fillers, namely carbon black and chopped carbon fibers, on strain-hardening cementitious composites (SHCC), and elucidates the synergistic mechanism of hybrid conductive fibers and fillers within SHCC. The findings indicate that a sufficiently high electrical conductivity can be achieved by incorporating 5 wt.% carbon black and 0.2–0.4 vol.% carbon fibers. The introduction of hybrid carbon-based fillers reduces the resistivity of SHCC by three orders of magnitude to less than 150 Ω∙cm, surpassing the performance of composites with a single carbon-based filler. Furthermore, the incorporation of hybrid carbon-based fillers and fibers enhances the compressive and flexural strength of cementitious composites. Compared to the referenced PE-SHCC, the tensile strength and strain of SHCC with 5 wt.% carbon black and 0.4 vol.% carbon fibers increased by 37.3% and 82.6%, respectively. A hybrid efficiency index (HEI) is proposed to assess both electrical conductivity and mechanical properties of SHCC incorporating with carbon-based fillers. The study’s findings offer an effective approach for utilizing hybrid carbon-based conductive fillers in the multifunctional applications of SHCC.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wei2026effect,
  author = {Liangliang Wei and Chenxi Xiao and Bixuan Yang and shouwang hu and Y. G. Zheng},
  title = {{Effect of Hybrid Carbon-Based Fillers on Electrical and Mechanical Performance of Strain-Hardening Cementitious Composites (SHCCs)}},
  booktitle = {Buildings},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.3390/buildings16020267},
}
Figure