Effect of Grazing Types on Community-Weighted Mean Functional Traits and Ecosystem Functions on Inner Mongolian Steppe, China

Wen Wang, Hua‐Min Liu, Jinghui Zhang, Zhiyong Li, Lixin Wang, Zheng Wang, Yantao Wu, Yang Wang, Cunzhu LiangSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different grazing types (no grazing, cattle, sheep, mixed) impact grassland ecosystem functions and plant traits in Inner Mongolia. It reveals that sheep grazing significantly reduces aboveground biomass and increases CO2 exchange, potentially harming ecosystem sustainability, and highlights how the interplay between plant traits and ecosystem functions mediates these grazing effects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Grasslands are crucial ecosystems facing threats from climate change and biodiversity loss. Understanding how grazing, a major disturbance, affects these systems is vital for their sustainable management. While the link between plant functional traits and ecosystem functions is well-studied, how different types of grazing (e.g., cattle vs. sheep) influence this relationship and, in turn, ecosystem functions remains unclear. This paper aims to disentangle these complex interactions by examining how various grazing regimes alter community-weighted mean (CWM) functional traits and key ecosystem functions like biomass production and carbon cycling.

Methods

The researchers conducted a seven-year grazing experiment in Inner Mongolia, China, with four distinct treatments: no grazing (NG), cattle grazing (CG), sheep grazing (SG), and mixed grazing by sheep and cattle (MG). They measured nine functional traits of dominant plant species and five ecosystem functions, including aboveground biomass (AGB), belowground biomass (BGB), ecosystem respiration (ER), net ecosystem CO2 exchange (NEE), and gross ecosystem productivity (GEP). Community-weighted mean (CWM) traits were calculated to represent the average trait values of the plant community. Statistical analyses, including one-way ANOVA and linear regression models, were employed to assess the effects of grazing types on CWM traits and ecosystem functions, and to explore the relationships between them.

Datasets

The study utilized field data collected from a typical steppe in Inner Mongolia, China, over a seven-year period (2013-2020). This involved measurements of plant functional traits and ecosystem functions under controlled grazing treatments. No new datasets were introduced; rather, existing field sites were used for experimental manipulation and data collection.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Grazing's Double-Edged Sword: Grazing generally reduces plant height, but paradoxically, it can increase nutrient content (nitrogen and phosphorus) in plants, potentially boosting belowground biomass.
  • Sheep vs. Cattle: A Tale of Two Grazers: Sheep grazing appears to be more detrimental to aboveground biomass and carbon sequestration capacity than cattle grazing, suggesting a need to manage sheep stocking rates.
  • Trait-Function Mediation is Key: The study strongly emphasizes that the relationships between plant functional traits and ecosystem functions are not static. These relationships can mediate how different grazing types ultimately impact the ecosystem, meaning the same trait might have different effects under different grazing pressures.
  • Nutrient-Trait-Carbon Link: Increased plant nutrient content (N and P) after cattle grazing was negatively correlated with NEE, suggesting that while nutrients increase, carbon sequestration might be suppressed in this scenario. This highlights a complex trade-off.

Key Results

  • Height Reduction: CWM height consistently decreased across all grazing types compared to no grazing.
  • Nutrient Boost: Cattle grazing (CG) and mixed grazing (MG) significantly increased CWM nitrogen and phosphorus content in plants.
  • Biomass Impact: Sheep grazing (SG) and mixed grazing (MG) caused a greater reduction in aboveground biomass (AGB) than cattle grazing (CG).
  • Carbon Exchange: Grazing generally increased Net Ecosystem CO2 Exchange (NEE) and Gross Ecosystem Productivity (GEP), indicating a shift towards a more active carbon cycle. SG and MG showed a more pronounced increase in NEE.
  • Trait-Function Correlations: Under sheep grazing (SG), higher CWM height correlated with higher ecosystem respiration (ER). Under cattle grazing (CG), increased plant nutrient content (leaf, stem, root N and P) was negatively correlated with NEE, while GEP was positively associated with root and stem nutrient content.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the observed negative correlation between plant nutrients and NEE under cattle grazing warrants further investigation to fully understand the underlying mechanisms. They also suggest that future research should explore the long-term implications of these findings for grassland sustainability and potentially investigate the role of specific plant species and their functional traits in mediating these responses. The study's focus on dominant species provides a good overview, but a more comprehensive analysis of all species could offer deeper insights.

Summary updated

Abstract

The relationships between community-weighted mean (CWM) functional traits and ecosystem functions have been extensively studied. However, how CWM traits and ecosystem functions respond to grazing types and whether the relationships between CWM traits and ecosystem functions mediate the response of ecosystem functions to grazing types remains controversial. In the present study, we set up a seven-year grazing experiment with four grazing types: no grazing (NG), cattle grazing (CG), sheep grazing (SG), and mixed grazing by sheep and cattle (MG) on Inner Mongolia grassland. Nine functional traits of dominant species and five ecosystem functions under different grazing types were determined, and the relationships between CWM traits and ecosystem functions were analyzed. The results showed that the CWM height decreased after grazing, while the CWM nitrogen and phosphorus contents increased after CG. SG caused a greater decrease in aboveground biomass (AGB) and a greater increase in the net ecosystem CO2 exchange (NEE) of grassland ecosystems than did CG. This result may be partially because the CWM nutrient content and NEE were more negatively related after CG; and the increase in the CWM nitrogen and phosphorus contents suppressed NEE after CG. Therefore, to protect the sustainability of grassland ecosystem functions, SG should be reduced. Additionally, our work emphasizes that the relationships between plant functional traits and ecosystem functions may mediate the response of ecosystem functions to grazing types.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2020effect,
  author = {Wen Wang and Hua‐Min Liu and Jinghui Zhang and Zhiyong Li and Lixin Wang and Zheng Wang and Yantao Wu and Yang Wang and Cunzhu Liang},
  title = {{Effect of Grazing Types on Community-Weighted Mean Functional Traits and Ecosystem Functions on Inner Mongolian Steppe, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12177169},
}

Loading related content...

Figure