Effect of Gig Workers’ Psychological Contract Fulfillment on Their Task Performance in a Sharing Economy—A Perspective from the Mediation of Organizational Identification and the Moderation of Length of Service

Wenlong Liu, Changqing He, Yi Jiang, Rongrong Ji, Xuesong ZhaiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how gig workers' perceptions of fulfilled promises (psychological contracts) influence their job performance in the sharing economy. It finds that both transactional (e.g., pay) and relational (e.g., respect) contract fulfillment boost performance, partly by fostering organizational identification. Crucially, the impact of these contracts on performance and identification varies significantly with how long the gig worker has been with the platform.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rise of the "gig economy" and "sharing economy" platforms (like ride-sharing services) has created new employment models. However, these models often lead to worker isolation and a weaker sense of connection to the organization, potentially impacting performance. Traditional employment research on psychological contracts (the unwritten expectations between employers and employees) and their link to performance is well-established. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining these relationships specifically within the unique context of gig work, exploring how psychological contract fulfillment (PCF) affects gig workers' task performance, with a focus on the mediating role of organizational identification and the moderating role of service length.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative, survey-based approach. They collected data from 223 Didi (a ride-hailing company in China) drivers using a structured questionnaire. The questionnaire measured:

  • Transactional Contract Fulfillment (TCF): focusing on economic aspects like income and profit sharing.
  • Relational Contract Fulfillment (RCF): focusing on aspects like fair treatment, respect, and company support.
  • Organizational Identification (OI): the extent to which workers feel a sense of belonging and oneness with the organization.
  • Task Performance (TP): how effectively workers complete their core job responsibilities.

Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) was used to test the proposed hypotheses, including mediation and moderation analyses.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 223 Didi drivers in China, collected through an interview survey between March and September 2019. This dataset is specific to the context of ride-sharing in China and is not a publicly released benchmark.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Transactional: Relational Matters for Long-Termers: While both transactional and relational contract fulfillment positively impact performance, the type of contract fulfillment that matters most shifts with tenure. Newcomers benefit more from transactional aspects for identification, while long-term workers see greater performance gains from relational aspects.
  • Organizational Identification as a Bridge: The study confirms that organizational identification acts as a crucial intermediary. When gig workers feel a sense of belonging, it amplifies the positive effects of fulfilled psychological contracts on their performance.
  • The "Gig" Context is Different: The findings highlight that the typical isolation and lack of formal employment in the gig economy mean that organizational identification might be weaker but still a vital driver of performance, especially when psychological contracts are met.
  • Tenure is a Key Differentiator: The impact of psychological contracts isn't uniform. How long a gig worker has been with the platform significantly alters how contract fulfillment translates into organizational identification and, ultimately, task performance.

Key Results

  • Direct Effects: Both TCF and RCF directly and positively influence gig workers' task performance.
  • Indirect Effects: Both TCF and RCF indirectly influence task performance through organizational identification.
  • Moderation by Length of Service (LoS):
    • TCF & OI: TCF has a stronger positive effect on organizational identification for drivers with short LoS (less than a year) compared to those with long LoS.
  • RCF & OI: No significant difference was found in the relationship between RCF and OI based on LoS.
  • TCF & TP: TCF has a similar significant effect on task performance for both short and long LoS groups.
  • RCF & TP: RCF has a stronger effect on task performance for drivers with long LoS (more than a year) compared to those with short LoS.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Specificity: The study focused solely on Didi drivers in China. Generalizing these findings to other gig economy platforms or regions might require further research.
  • Job Perception: The study notes that many Didi drivers work long hours, potentially viewing it as a full-time job. Future research could explore how gig workers' perception of their work (career vs. side hustle) influences these relationships.
  • Beyond Task Performance: While task performance was the focus, the paper suggests that fulfilled contracts and organizational identification might also drive other positive behaviors like organizational loyalty, sportsmanship, altruism, and civic virtue, which could be explored in future studies.
  • Contract Breach: The study focused on fulfillment. Future research could investigate the impact of psychological contract breach in the gig economy, as breaches can have significant negative effects.
  • Participant Recruitment: The authors mention that recruiting drivers was challenging, suggesting that future research might need enhanced strategies to encourage participation in gig worker studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Workers' isolation may occur in gig employment in the sharing economy, which generates a weak perception of the organization and unpredictable work performance. Drawing on social exchange theory, this paper proposes a framework to explore the effect of psychological contract fulfillment on gig workers' task performance from the perspective of the mediation of organizational identification and the moderation of the length of service. A total of 223 samples were recruited from Didi (a ride-hailing company in China) drivers. The results show that both transactional and relational psychological contract fulfillment can directly affect gig workers' task performance and also indirectly affect it via organizational identification. When the length of service for the current company is taken into consideration, transactional contract fulfillment, as the representation of a company's recognition of gig workers' effort, has a stronger effect on the organizational identification of gig workers who have been working for the company for less than a year compared with those who have been working for a longer period. The results show no difference in the relationship between relational psychological contract and organizational identification between the two groups. Transactional psychological contract fulfillment exhibits the same significant effect on gig workers' task performance in both groups. By contrast, relational psychological contract fulfillment has a stronger effect on long-serving Didi drivers than on those who joined the company within the year. These findings generate certain theoretical and practical implications for gig employment management in the sharing economy.
BibTeX
@article{liu2020effect,
  author = {Wenlong Liu and Changqing He and Yi Jiang and Rongrong Ji and Xuesong Zhai},
  title = {{Effect of Gig Workers’ Psychological Contract Fulfillment on Their Task Performance in a Sharing Economy—A Perspective from the Mediation of Organizational Identification and the Moderation of Length of Service}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph17072208},
}
Figure