Effect of Freeze–Thaw Cycles and Initial Water Content on the Pore Structure and Mechanical Properties of Loess in Northern Shaanxi

Zhenxing Pan, Gengshe Yang, Wanjun Ye, Hui Liu, Bo Liang, Qian Yang, Gang LiSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how freeze-thaw cycles and initial water content affect the pore structure and mechanical strength of loess in Northern Shaanxi, a region prone to slope spalling. The research reveals that increased water content amplifies porosity changes and significantly weakens the loess, with pore structure transforming from micro to larger pores. These findings are crucial for understanding and mitigating slope instability in seasonally frozen environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Loess slopes in Northern Shaanxi are susceptible to "spalling disease" caused by repeated freezing and thawing. This phenomenon leads to significant deterioration of the soil's physical and mechanical properties, ultimately compromising slope stability. While the general impact of freeze-thaw cycles on loess is recognized, a detailed understanding of how varying initial water content interacts with these cycles to alter pore structure and mechanical strength, particularly in the context of Northern Shaanxi's specific loess characteristics, remains an area needing further exploration. This paper aims to fill this gap by systematically examining these relationships.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of laboratory techniques to analyze the loess samples:

  • Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) Spectroscopy: This technique was used to probe the internal pore structure of the loess. By measuring the relaxation time (T2) of hydrogen atoms in pore water, the study could infer the size and distribution of pores within the soil. This allowed for the quantification of porosity changes.
  • Triaxial Compression Tests: These tests were conducted to evaluate the mechanical strength of the loess samples under various confining pressures. By measuring the stress-strain behavior, the study determined key parameters like cohesion and internal friction angle, and how they degrade with freeze-thaw cycles and water content.

The study involved preparing remolded loess samples with four different initial water contents (7%, 9%, 12%, and 14%) and subjecting them to six different numbers of freeze-thaw cycles (0, 1, 3, 5, 10, and 20).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized laboratory-prepared samples based on field measurements of water content.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Water Content is a Critical Amplifier: The initial water content isn't just a passive factor; it actively amplifies the effects of freeze-thaw cycles. Higher water content leads to more significant porosity increases and a greater reduction in mechanical strength.
  • Pore Structure Transformation: Freeze-thaw cycles don't just increase pore size; they fundamentally change the type of pores. Loess transitions from a dominance of micropores and small pores to a greater proportion of medium and large pores as freeze-thaw cycles and water content increase.
  • Strength Decay is Staged: The degradation of cohesion and internal friction angle isn't linear. It occurs in distinct stages: a rapid decrease in the initial cycles, followed by a slower decline, and finally stabilization. This suggests different mechanisms are at play during different phases of the freeze-thaw process.
  • Water-Ice Phase Change is the Primary Driver: The study strongly suggests that the phase change of pore water into ice, leading to volume expansion and water migration, is the fundamental mechanism behind the observed deterioration of loess strength.

Key Results

  • Porosity Increase: Porosity increased with both freeze-thaw cycles and initial water content. The porosity growth for a 14% water content sample was nearly five times greater than for a 7% water content sample after 20 cycles.
  • Stress-Strain Behavior: The number of freeze-thaw cycles, initial water content, and confining pressure all significantly impacted stress-strain curves. Higher freeze-thaw cycles and water content led to a decrease in peak partial stress.
  • Strength Parameter Decay: Cohesion and internal friction angle showed a decay pattern over freeze-thaw cycles, with the most significant drop occurring within the first three cycles. For instance, cohesion decreased by up to 25.96% and internal friction angle by up to 12.72% for the 7% water content sample after 20 cycles.
  • Pore Size Distribution: Loess pore structure is predominantly micropores and small pores. With increasing freeze-thaw cycles and water content, the proportion of micropores decreased, while medium and large pores increased. This transformation was particularly pronounced when water content rose from 9% to 12%.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study was conducted in a closed, non-replenishing laboratory environment. In real-world engineering projects, slopes are open systems with continuous water infiltration. Future research should consider:

  • A wider range of water contents and freeze-thaw cycle temperatures.
  • Investigating the impact of these factors in open, replenishing environments.
  • Expanding the scope to include ecological protection and management strategies for freeze-thaw diseases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spalling disease caused by freeze–thaw cycles often occurs on the loess cut-slopes in northern Shaanxi. The deterioration of the pore structure and mechanical strength of loess under a freeze–thaw environment is one of the critical reasons underlying the occurrence of spalling disease in the slopes. In order to explore the effects of freeze–thaw cycles on the pore structure and the mechanical strength of loess, four initial water contents (7%, 9%, 12%, and 14%) and six freeze–thaw cycles (zero, one, three, five, 10, and 20) were considered in this study. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and triaxial compression tests were carried out to analyze and reveal the mechanisms of effect causing the deterioration of the soil strength that affects the stability of loess cut-slopes. The results showed that the porosity growth increased with the initial water content and continued to increase during the freeze–thaw process until a later stage of the freeze–thaw cycle, when it gradually stabilized. The stress–strain curves were primarily influenced by the number of freeze–thaw cycles, the initial water content of the samples, and the confining pressure. Both the cohesion and the internal friction angle exhibited a decay law that showed a significant decrease, then a slow decrease, and finally stabilization during the freeze–thaw process. Small and micropores were predominant among the pore structures of the loess, while medium pores were the second most common, and large pores were the least common. With the increase in the initial water content, the pores transformed from micropore structures to medium and large pore structures. The soil strength deterioration was primarily driven by the phase changes of the pore water, as well as the water migration during the freeze–thaw process. This study will be beneficial for identifying the characteristics and types of freeze–thaw disease in cut-slope engineering in seasonally frozen loess areas and providing a theoretical reference and design basis for achieving green and sustainable development in slope engineering, management, and maintenance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pan2023effect,
  author = {Zhenxing Pan and Gengshe Yang and Wanjun Ye and Hui Liu and Bo Liang and Qian Yang and Gang Li},
  title = {{Effect of Freeze–Thaw Cycles and Initial Water Content on the Pore Structure and Mechanical Properties of Loess in Northern Shaanxi}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151410937},
}
Figure