Effect of Durability Treatment on Ultraviolet Resistance, Strength, and Surface Wettability of Wood Plastic Composite

Huiyuan Li, Zheng Zhang, Kunlin Song, Sun Young Lee, Sang‐Jin Chun, Zhou Ding-guo, Qinglin WuBioResources 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different additives (HALS, UVA, and ZnB) protect wood-plastic composites (WPCs) from UV degradation. The findings reveal that UV absorbers (UVA) are the most effective at preventing color change and surface degradation, while also maintaining mechanical properties better than other additives after prolonged UV exposure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wood-plastic composites (WPCs) are increasingly used in outdoor applications, but they are susceptible to degradation from ultraviolet (UV) radiation. This weathering causes color changes, loss of aesthetic appeal, and deterioration of mechanical properties. While various additives like hindered amine light stabilizers (HALS), ultraviolet absorbers (UVA), and zinc borate (ZnB) are used to combat this, a direct, comparative analysis of their effectiveness on WPC durability, specifically looking at surface degradation, color change, wettability, and mechanical performance, was lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by systematically evaluating these additives.

Methods

The researchers employed accelerated artificial UV weathering tests using a xenon-arc weatherometer, simulating prolonged outdoor exposure. They exposed WPC samples with different additive formulations to UV radiation for 500, 1000, and 2000 hours.

Key evaluation techniques included:

  • Color Change Measurement: Using a Konica Minolta CR-10 spectrometer to quantify color differences (ΔEab) based on the CIELAB color system.
  • Surface Wettability: Measuring the water contact angle of the WPC surfaces using a goniometer.
  • Mechanical Property Testing: Determining flexural properties, specifically the modulus of elasticity (MOE) and modulus of rupture (MOR), using an MTS Testing Machine under a three-point bending test.
  • Surface Morphology Analysis: Examining the surface structure using optical microscopy and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to observe physical changes like cracking and chalking.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used custom-formulated WPC samples with varying additive concentrations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • UVA Shines Brightest: The study strongly suggests that UV absorbers (UVA) are the superior choice for protecting WPCs from UV-induced color fading, especially after extended exposure (over 1000 hours). This is a crucial finding for material selection in outdoor applications.
  • Surface vs. Bulk Effects: While all additives offered some protection, UVA demonstrated a more comprehensive effect, not only preventing surface bleaching but also contributing to better retention of mechanical properties. This highlights the importance of considering both surface and bulk material integrity.
  • Wettability Reversal: Interestingly, the addition of UV stabilizers generally increased the initial contact angle, indicating reduced wettability. However, after weathering, all samples showed decreased contact angles (increased wettability). The UVA-treated samples maintained higher contact angles even after weathering, suggesting better resistance to surface changes that promote water absorption.
  • The "Bleaching" Effect: The most significant color change (ΔEab) and lightening (ΔL) occurred in the initial stages of UV exposure (first 500 hours), particularly for untreated samples. This indicates that early protection is critical.
  • Morphological Clues: Visual inspection via microscopy confirmed that untreated WPCs suffered significant surface degradation, becoming rougher and chalky with visible cracks. UVA-treated samples showed much less of this surface damage.

Key Results

  • Color Stability: UVA-treated WPCs (AT-2) exhibited the lowest color difference (ΔEab) after 2000 hours of irradiation, indicating superior resistance to bleaching compared to HALS and ZnB.
  • Surface Morphology: After 2000 hours, the surface of the control WPC became white and chalky, with significant cracking observed under SEM. UVA-treated samples (AT-2) showed minimal surface degradation.
  • Surface Wettability: While all WPCs became more wettable after weathering, UVA-treated samples (AT) maintained the highest contact angles (around 82° after 2000 hours), suggesting better resistance to surface changes that increase hydrophilicity.
  • Mechanical Properties: All WPC samples experienced a decrease in flexural strength (MOR) and modulus (MOE) after weathering. However, UVA-treated WPCs (AT) showed the highest retention rates for both MOR and MOE, with AT-2 retaining 93% of its initial MOR and 92% of its MOE after 2000 hours.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Additive Concentration: The study primarily focused on specific concentrations of additives. Further research could explore the optimal concentration ranges for each additive to maximize performance and cost-effectiveness.
  • Synergistic Effects: While this study compared individual additives, investigating synergistic effects between different types of stabilizers could lead to even more robust WPC formulations.
  • Real-World Conditions: The study used accelerated weathering. While valuable, long-term outdoor exposure studies would provide further validation of these findings under actual environmental conditions.
  • Wood Species and Processing: The study used pine wood flour and a specific HDPE matrix. Future work could explore how different wood species, particle sizes, and polymer matrices interact with these stabilizers.

Summary updated

Abstract

A comparative analysis of photostabilizing effects of hindered amine light stabilizers (HALSs), an ultraviolet absorber (UVA), and zinc borate (ZnB) on wood plastic composites (WPCs) was made in this study to show the influence of the accelerated weathering on the surface degradation and loss of mechanical properties of treated WPCs. The results showed that the UVA was the most effective in preventing composite from being bleached, especially when the aging time was longer than 1000 hours. With the addition of the ultraviolet stabilizers, the contact angles increased, indicating increased water wettability. The contact angle of UVA-containing samples was greater than that of the control and the other samples treated with HALSs and ZnB. Flexural properties of all materials decreased after being weathered under xenon-arc light. Materials treated with UVA had higher retention rates in flexural strength and modulus. The results show that, among the agents used, UVA was the most effective additive in preventing WPCs from ultraviolet degradation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2014effect,
  author = {Huiyuan Li and Zheng Zhang and Kunlin Song and Sun Young Lee and Sang‐Jin Chun and Zhou Ding-guo and Qinglin Wu},
  title = {{Effect of Durability Treatment on Ultraviolet Resistance, Strength, and Surface Wettability of Wood Plastic Composite}},
  booktitle = {BioResources},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.15376/biores.9.2.3591-3601},
}
Figure