Abstract
The effect of the COVID-19 outbreak has led policymakers around the world to attempt transmission control. However, lockdown and shutdown interventions have caused new social problems and designating policy resumption for infection control when reopening society remains a crucial issue. We investigated the effects of different resumption strategies on COVID-19 transmission using a modeling study setting. We employed a susceptible-exposed-infectious-removed model to simulate COVID-19 outbreaks under five reopening strategies based on China’s business resumption progress. The effect of each strategy was evaluated using the peak values of the epidemic curves vis-à-vis confirmed active cases and cumulative cases. We found that a hierarchy-based reopen strategy performed best when current epidemic prevention measures were maintained save for lockdown, reducing the peak number of active cases and cumulative cases by 50% and 44%, respectively. However, the modeled effect of each strategy decreased when the current intervention was lifted somewhat. Additional attention should be given to regions with significant numbers of migrants, as the potential risk of COVID-19 outbreaks amid society reopening is intrinsically high. Business resumption strategies have the potential to eliminate COVID-19 outbreaks amid society reopening without special control measures.
Introduction
As the first wave of COVID-19 subsided in early 2020, policymakers faced a "double-edged sword": maintaining strict lockdowns to prevent a second wave while risking economic collapse, or reopening the economy and risking a catastrophic resurgence of the virus. The challenge lies in the implementation of resumption. This paper seeks to quantify the trade-offs of different resumption patterns—such as prioritizing industries or staggering returns—to provide a data-driven roadmap for "flattening the potential outbreak" during societal reopening.
Methodology
The researchers employed a modified Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Removed (SEIR) compartmental model. A critical modification involved splitting the "Infectious" category into Undetected ($I_u$) and Detected ($I_d$) subjects. Detected subjects are assumed to be immediately hospitalized or isolated, effectively removing them from the transmission chain, while undetected subjects continue to drive the outbreak.
The model was calibrated using epidemic data from Beijing to determine parameters such as the daily infection detection rate and recovery rate. The key parameters used for the simulations are detailed in the table below.
The team simulated five specific strategies:
- Direct Reopening (DR): A baseline "business as usual" scenario where the entire workforce returns simultaneously.
- Risk-based Reopening (RR): Only workers from low-to-moderate-risk regions return.
- Order-based Reopening (OR): Workers return in batches (e.g., 25% every three weeks).
- Theme-based Reopening (TR): Prioritizes essential services (medical, daily necessities) first, followed by construction and industry.
- Hierarchical Reopening (HR): A comprehensive approach combining RR, OR, and TR.
Results and Key Insights
The study tested these strategies against three different reproductive numbers ($R_0 = 1.4, 2.2, \text{and } 3.9$) to represent varying levels of ongoing social distancing.
Strategy Efficiency
Under the "standard" $R_0$ of 2.2, the Hierarchical Reopening (HR) strategy was the most effective, reducing the peak number of active cases by ~50% and cumulative cases by ~44% compared to Direct Reopening. The Risk-based (RR) strategy alone reduced peak cases to about 70% of the baseline, demonstrating that screening worker origins is a powerful, low-cost intervention.
The "Threshold of Futility"
A striking insight is that reopening strategies only matter if background transmission is controlled. At $R_0 = 3.9$ (representing a total lift of interventions), all five strategies failed to flatten the curve significantly. The specific method of reopening only provides a benefit if society continues practicing basic precautions like masking and distancing.
Spatial Heterogeneity
Regions with high migrant densities, such as Beijing’s Chaoyang District, are inherently higher risk. The researchers emphasize that reopening plans must be spatially heterogeneous; a "one size fits all" plan ignores the reality that some districts are more susceptible to outbreaks than others.
Discussion and Limitations
While the study provides a robust framework for reopening, it has limitations. The model assumes homogeneous mixing within districts and simplified occupational risk profiles (e.g., assuming all workers within a "theme" have similar transmission risks). Furthermore, the assumption that returning workers are asymptomatic and isolated from residents represents an optimistic scenario for corporate compliance.
Future work could incorporate more granular "agent-based" data to identify how specific infrastructure, such as subway lines or office buildings, acts as super-spreader nodes.
Conclusion
Hierarchical business resumption strategies have the potential to mitigate COVID-19 outbreaks during societal reopening. By combining risk-based screening, staggered returns, and industry prioritization, policymakers can significantly flatten the epidemic curve, provided that basic non-pharmaceutical interventions remain in place to keep the reproductive number low.
Summary updated