Effect of Cu Content on Hardness and Wear Properties in (Cr, Mo, Cu)N Film

Yuta Suzuki, Yuji Sutou, Daisuke Ando, Junichi KoikeJournal of the Japan Institute of Metals and Materials 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Effects of Cu addition on hardness and wear properties of (Cr, Mo)N films were investigated by nanoindentation and ball-on-disk measurements. (Cr100-x-yMoxCuy)N films were deposited onto a stainless steel substrate by a reactive DC magnetron sputtering of Cr50Mo50 and Cu targets under the mixture of argon (45 ccm) and nitrogen (5 ccm) gases. The hardness of the film increased from 21.9 to 23.5 GPa by Cu addition of y=3.4 and then drastically decreased with further increasing Cu addition. The drastic decrease in hardness is caused by the formation of amorphous structure. In crystalline films, it was found that the change of hardness obeys the inverse Hall-Petch relationship. The wear mechanism of the film was changed by increasing Cu addition: adhesive wear (y=0), lubricated wear (3.4 ≤ y ≤ 12.6), and abrasive wear (y ≥ 20.4). It was also found from wear track observation that the lubricated wear in the Cu content region of 3.4 ≤ y ≤ 12.6 was obtained by the formation of oxide debris. With further increase in Cu content (y ≥ 20.4), the film was severely worn because of the low hardness of the amorphous film.

Introduction

In industrial sectors like automotive and aerospace, Chromium Nitride (Cr-N) coatings are prized for their hardness and oxidation resistance. However, they often perform poorly against materials like stainless steel due to adhesive wear. Molybdenum Nitride (Mo-N) is known to form lubricating oxides ($MoO_3$), but it lacks stability. This research explores the (Cr, Mo, Cu)N system, investigating whether adding copper can trigger the formation of self-lubricating phases like $CuMoO_4$ to create a coating that is both hard and exceptionally wear-resistant.

Experimental Methods

(Cr, Mo, Cu)N films were synthesized via reactive DC magnetron sputtering on SUS304 stainless steel substrates. By adjusting the power to the Cu target, the researchers produced samples with copper concentrations ($y$) of 0, 3.4, 10.6, 12.6, and 20.4 at.%. Mechanical properties, specifically hardness ($H$) and effective Young’s modulus ($E^*$), were measured using nanoindentation. Wear properties were evaluated through ball-on-disk testing against a stainless steel ball. Structural transitions were monitored using X-ray diffraction (XRD) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM).

Results and Discussion

Mechanical Properties and Structural Evolution

The addition of copper has a non-linear effect on the film's mechanical integrity. As illustrated in Figure 1, the hardness initially increases from 21.9 GPa at $y=0$ to a peak of 23.5 GPa at $y=3.4$. However, further Cu addition leads to a sharp decline, with hardness dropping to approximately 14 GPa at $y=20.4$.

Hardness and effective Young's modulus as a function of Cu content.

This trend correlates with a structural shift. At low Cu levels, the films are crystalline, and the initial hardening is likely due to grain refinement. As Cu content increases, the grain size decreases further, eventually leading to an inverse Hall-Petch effect where grain-boundary sliding reduces hardness. At the highest Cu concentration ($y=20.4$), the film becomes entirely amorphous, explaining the significant loss in mechanical strength.

Wear Mechanisms and Self-Lubrication

The wear performance exhibits a clear transition across three regimes, visible in the SEM images of the wear tracks (Figure 2).

SEM images of wear tracks for films with different Cu contents: (a) y=0, (b) y=3.4, (c) y=10.6, (d) y=12.6, and (e) y=20.4.

Without copper ($y=0$), the film suffers from adhesive wear, characterized by material transfer. In the range of 3.4–12.6 at.% Cu, the wear track width is significantly reduced. In this regime, the film generates oxide debris that acts as a solid lubricant, preventing the stainless steel ball from adhering to the surface. However, once the film becomes amorphous at $y=20.4$, it lacks the hardness to resist mechanical stress, resulting in severe abrasive wear and total film failure.

Conclusion

This study identifies an optimal copper content range (3.4–12.6 at.%) for (Cr, Mo, Cu)N films to achieve a self-lubricating effect without sacrificing mechanical stability. While the formation of lubricating oxides significantly reduces wear, exceeding the amorphous tipping point at ~20 at.% Cu leads to a drastic reduction in hardness and a transition to severe abrasive wear. Future work should focus on definitively identifying the oxide phases and testing performance at elevated temperatures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Effects of Cu addition on hardness and wear properties of (Cr, Mo)N films were investigated by nanoindentation and ball-on-disk measurements. (Cr100-x-yMoxCuy)N films were deposited onto a stainless steel substrate by a reactive DC magnetron sputtering of Cr50Mo50 and Cu targets under the mixture of argon (45 ccm) and nitrogen (5 ccm) gases. The hardness of the film increased from 21.9 to 23.5 GPa by Cu addition of y=3.4 of Cu addition and then drastically decreased with further increasing Cu addition. The drastic decrease in hardness is caused by the formation of amorphous structure. In crystalline films, it was found that the change of hardness obeys the inverse Hall-Petch relationship. The wear mechanism of the film was changed by increasing Cu addition, adhesive wear (y=0), lubricated wear (3.4 ≤ y≤ 12.6) and abrasive wear (y≥ 20.4). It was also found from wear track observation that the lubricated wear in the Cu content region of 3.4 ≤ y≤ 12.6 was obtained by the formation of the oxide debris resulted from the film with as small amount of Cu (3.4 ≤ y ≤ 12.6). With further increase in Cu content (y≥ 20.4), the film was severely worn because of its low hardness of the amorphous film.
BibTeX
@article{suzuki2017effect,
  author = {Yuta Suzuki and Yuji Sutou and Daisuke Ando and Junichi Koike},
  title = {{Effect of Cu Content on Hardness and Wear Properties in (Cr, Mo, Cu)N Film}},
  journal = {Journal of the Japan Institute of Metals and Materials},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.2320/jinstmet.jbw201613},
}
Figure