Effect of Cross-Joints Fin on the Thrust Performance of Bionic Pectoral Fins

Yang Lu, Yonghui Cao, Guang Pan, Qiaogao Huang, Xin DongJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how varying spanwise and chordwise stiffness in a simplified bionic pectoral fin (Cross-Joints Fin or CJF) affects thrust generation. They found that while overall stiffness plays a role at low speeds, spanwise stiffness becomes significantly more influential than chordwise stiffness at higher speeds, offering crucial design insights for bio-inspired underwater vehicles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Underwater vehicles often struggle with achieving both high maneuverability and efficient long-distance travel, qualities that marine animals like cownose rays possess naturally. Cownose rays utilize a complex "cross-bracing" structure in their pectoral fins for propulsion. However, replicating this intricate biological structure directly is challenging. Researchers aim to understand how specific mechanical properties, like stiffness, contribute to the propulsive performance of these fins. This paper specifically addresses the need to disentangle the individual and combined effects of spanwise and chordwise stiffness on thrust generation in a simplified, bio-inspired pectoral fin design, moving beyond studies that only examine one stiffness direction at a time.

Methods

The researchers developed a simplified bionic pectoral fin called the Cross-Joints Fin (CJF) that mimics the skeletal structure of a cownose ray. This CJF design allowed for systematic variation of stiffness by altering the width of "joints" along both the spanwise and chordwise directions. They created 18 different CJF designs by varying joint widths (2-6 mm) and fin thicknesses (1.5 mm and 2.5 mm). The stiffness of these joints was experimentally confirmed to increase with joint width.

Experiments were conducted in a still water tank. The CJFs were subjected to various motion parameters, including three stroke amplitudes (30°, 50°, 70°) and three flapping frequencies (0.4 Hz, 0.6 Hz, 0.8 Hz), resulting in 162 distinct test conditions. Thrust and lift forces were measured using an ATI force sensor. The data was normalized to compare performance across different designs and conditions. Wingtip Reynolds numbers were calculated to characterize the flow regimes.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data generated from 18 different CJF designs tested under 9 kinematic parameter sets (3 amplitudes x 3 frequencies), totaling 162 unique experimental conditions. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stiffness is a Double-Edged Sword: At low speeds (low Reynolds numbers), overly stiff fins can actually reduce thrust due to limited deformability, hindering effective interaction with the water.
  • Spanwise Dominance at Speed: As the flow speed increases (higher Reynolds numbers), the influence of spanwise stiffness on thrust generation becomes significantly more pronounced than that of chordwise stiffness. This suggests that optimizing spanwise flexibility is key for high-speed propulsion.
  • Thickness Matters: The fin thickness (1.5 mm vs. 2.5 mm) plays a crucial role in how stiffness affects performance. Thicker fins, being inherently stiffer, exhibit different responses to joint width variations compared to thinner fins.
  • Simplification is Powerful: Even a simplified model like the CJF can reveal fundamental principles of bio-inspired propulsion, providing valuable insights without needing to replicate the full biological complexity.

Key Results

  • Low Reynolds Number Behavior: At low wingtip Reynolds numbers, higher overall stiffness (achieved through wider joints and thicker fins) led to a significant reduction in thrust.
  • High Reynolds Number Behavior: At higher wingtip Reynolds numbers, the effect of changing spanwise stiffness on thrust was more significant than changing chordwise stiffness. For instance, at a Reynolds number of 50,518, the maximum thrust variation due to spanwise stiffness changes was 35.6% (for 1.5 mm thick fins), compared to 22.7% for chordwise stiffness changes.
  • Average Thrust Trends: For 1.5 mm thick fins, average thrust generally increased with spanwise joint width (up to 11.22%), while for 2.5 mm thick fins, it decreased (up to 25.08%). Chordwise joint width changes had a smaller impact on average thrust (max 6.37% and 4.74% respectively).
  • Thrust-to-Lift Ratio: The T/Flift ratio analysis suggested that for low-stiffness fins, increasing stiffness can improve thrust percentage, while for high-stiffness fins, softer components might be beneficial for reducing lift and enhancing propulsion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Model: The CJF is a simplification of the complex biological cross-bracing structure. Future work could explore more intricate designs that better capture biological nuances.
  • Single Direction Focus: While this paper compares spanwise and chordwise effects, the interaction between them is complex. Future research could focus on optimizing the synthesis of these stiffnesses.
  • Limited Reynolds Number Range: The experiments covered a specific range of Reynolds numbers. Exploring a wider range, especially lower and higher values, could reveal further insights.
  • Future Research: The authors suggest that their findings provide a basis for future research on the combined effects of spanwise and chordwise stiffness. They also highlight the importance of considering spanwise stiffness magnitude in the design of oscillating pectoral fins for improved propulsion. Variable stiffness fins could be designed to enhance overall thrust, with a particular emphasis on optimizing spanwise stiffness distribution.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cownose rays have a high forward propulsive performance due to their unique oscillating fin structure (named the cross-bracing structure), which differs from undulatory fish. The cross-bracing structure obtained through anatomy, on the other hand, is extremely complex. Hence, researchers used simple structures to model the biological structure to target the individual factors that affect cownose ray cruising performance. This paper simplified the cross-bracing fin structure to a cross-joints fin (CJF) structure with 18 designs. CJFs had five different joint widths (2 mm, 3 mm, 4 mm, 5 mm, and 6 mm) in both spanwise and chordwise directions, and these had two fin thicknesses (1.5 mm, 2.5 mm). The joint widths of CJF are related to the stiffness of the spanwise and chordwise fins (Fin stiffness increases with joint width). The experiments were conducted in a still water tank (1.5 m × 0.8 m × 0.8 m) with three stroke amplitudes (30°, 50°, 70°) and three flapping frequencies (0.4 Hz, 0.6 Hz, 0.8 Hz) for each fin, making up 162 distinct sets of data. The experimental results showed the following: (1) at low wingtip Reynolds numbers, the high stiffness of the CJF causes a significant reduction in thrust. In particular, high stiffness results in a low thrust averaged from all motion parameters; (2) at high wing tip Reynolds numbers, the effect of changing spanwise stiffness on thrust is more significant than the effect of changing chordwise stiffness. This paper compares the effects of spanwise and chordwise stiffness on thrust performance, indicating that the magnitude of spanwise stiffness should be considered when designing the bionic oscillating pectoral fin structure.
BibTeX
@article{lu2022effect,
  author = {Yang Lu and Yonghui Cao and Guang Pan and Qiaogao Huang and Xin Dong and Yong Cao and Yong Cao and Yong Cao},
  title = {{Effect of Cross-Joints Fin on the Thrust Performance of Bionic Pectoral Fins}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse10070869},
}
Figure