Effect of Carboxylic Acids on Corrosion of Type 410 Stainless Steel in Pyrolysis Bio-Oil

Dino Sulejmanovic, James R. Keiser, Yi‐Feng Su, Michael D. Kass, Jack R. Ferrell, Mariefel V. Olarte, John E. Wade, Jiheon JunSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different carboxylic acids in pyrolysis bio-oil affect the corrosion of Type 410 stainless steel (SS410). They found that formic acid significantly increases corrosion, while acetic, propionic, and hexanoic acids appear to have a mild inhibitory effect, offering insights into material selection for bio-oil handling.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Biomass-derived bio-oils are a promising renewable energy source, but their complex chemical composition, particularly the presence of organic acids, can lead to significant corrosion of storage and processing equipment. Type 410 stainless steel (SS410), a common material in such applications, is known to be susceptible to corrosion in these environments, especially due to its relatively low chromium content. While the general corrosivity of bio-oils is recognized, the specific impact of different carboxylic acids and their concentrations on SS410 corrosion has not been thoroughly quantified. This paper aims to fill that gap by systematically evaluating the corrosion behavior of SS410 when exposed to bio-oil with varying concentrations of four common carboxylic acids: formic, acetic, propionic, and hexanoic.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of experimental techniques to assess the corrosion of SS410.

  • Corrosion Exposure: SS410 coupons were immersed in a specific bio-oil (FR3) spiked with varying concentrations of formic, acetic, propionic, and hexanoic acids. These exposures were conducted at a controlled temperature of 50 °C for 48 hours.
  • Mass Change Measurement: After exposure and cleaning, the coupons were weighed to determine the mass change, which directly indicates the extent of material loss due to corrosion.
  • Capillary Electrophoresis (CE): This technique was used to quantify the concentrations of various carboxylate anions present in the bio-oil samples, allowing for precise control and analysis of the acidic components.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Energy Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDS): SEM was used to visualize the surface morphology of the corroded SS410 specimens, while EDS elemental mapping provided information on the distribution of elements (like Cr, Fe, Mn, Si, and O) on the surface and in cross-sections, helping to identify corrosion products and compositional changes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a specific bio-oil (FR3) obtained from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) and prepared custom mixtures with varying concentrations of carboxylic acids.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Formic Acid is the Primary Culprit: The study strongly implicates formic acid as the most aggressive carboxylic acid in causing SS410 corrosion. Its presence leads to a clear, linear increase in mass loss with increasing concentration.
  • Unexpected Inhibition: Counterintuitively, acetic, propionic, and hexanoic acids, when added to the bio-oil, showed a mild inhibitory effect on SS410 corrosion. This suggests that the longer-chain or different functional groups of these acids might offer some protective mechanism.
  • Dilution Matters (Sometimes): The method of introducing formic and acetic acids (diluted vs. concentrated) showed a slight difference in corrosion behavior, particularly for formic acid. Diluting formic acid with water appeared to make the bio-oil slightly less corrosive, possibly due to a dilution effect or improved diffusion.
  • Homogeneous Attack: SEM/EDS analysis revealed a relatively homogeneous corrosion attack on the SS410 surfaces, without deep pitting or localized corrosion ditches, even with formic acid. This suggests a more general dissolution process.

Key Results

  • Formic Acid: A linear correlation was observed between increasing formic acid concentration and SS410 mass loss. The average mass loss in baseline bio-oil was 6.1 mg/cm², with corrosion rates increasing up to 4.93 mm/yr at the highest formic acid addition.
  • Acetic, Propionic, and Hexanoic Acids: The addition of these acids resulted in a slight decrease in mass loss compared to the baseline bio-oil, indicating a mild inhibitory effect. This effect was observed even with concentrated acid additions.
  • Baseline Bio-oil Corrosion: The corrosion rate in the baseline bio-oil was comparable to that of SS410 exposed to 1 M HCl or 20% NaCl aqueous solutions at elevated temperatures, highlighting the inherent corrosivity of bio-oil.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Short-Term Exposure: The study focused on 48-hour exposures. Longer-term studies would be beneficial to understand the sustained corrosion behavior and the evolution of corrosion products.
  • Single Bio-oil Type: The experiments were conducted with one specific bio-oil (FR3). Future work could explore how different bio-oil compositions (e.g., varying ash content, other oxygenates) influence these corrosion trends.
  • Limited Acid Types: While four common carboxylic acids were tested, bio-oils contain a complex mixture of organic compounds. Investigating the synergistic or antagonistic effects of multiple acids and other functional groups would provide a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Mechanism Elucidation: While the study identifies formic acid as aggressive and others as potentially inhibitory, a deeper mechanistic understanding of why this occurs (e.g., surface film formation, electrochemical reactions) would be valuable. The authors suggest that further experiments are needed to explore the role of specific functional groups and their interactions with the SS410 surface.

Summary updated

Abstract

Biomass-derived oils are renewable fuel sources and commodity products and are proposed to partially or entirely replace fossil fuels in sectors generally considered difficult to decarbonize such as aviation and maritime propulsion. Bio-oils contain a range of organic compounds with varying functional groups which can lead to polarity-driven phase separation and corrosion of containment materials during processing and storage. Polar compounds, such as organic acids and other oxygenates, are abundant in bio-oils and are considered corrosive to structural alloys, particularly to those with a low-Cr content. To study the corrosion effects of small carboxylic acids present in pyrolysis bio-oils, type 410 stainless steel (SS410) specimens were exposed in bio-oils with varying formic, acetic, propionic and hexanoic acid contents at 50 °C during 48 h exposures. The specific mass change data show a linear increase in mass loss with increasing formic acid concentration. Interestingly, a mild corrosion inhibition effect on the corrosion of SS410 specimens was observed with the addition of acetic, propionic and hexanoic acids in the bio-oil.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sulejmanovic2022effect,
  author = {Dino Sulejmanovic and James R. Keiser and Yi‐Feng Su and Michael D. Kass and Jack R. Ferrell and Mariefel V. Olarte and John E. Wade and Jiheon Jun},
  title = {{Effect of Carboxylic Acids on Corrosion of Type 410 Stainless Steel in Pyrolysis Bio-Oil}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141811743},
}
Figure