TL;DR
This paper investigates how bearing support parameters (position and stiffness) affect the deformation of rotor shaft gears in a coaxial reversing dual rotor shaft (CRDRS) system. By developing a static model and using a novel iterative solution method, they found that bearing position is the dominant factor in minimizing gear deformation, with stiffness playing a secondary role, offering crucial insights for optimizing helicopter gearbox design.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Helicopter rotor shafts are critical for transmitting engine power to the rotor. However, their deformation can significantly impact the meshing performance of output stage gears in the main gearbox, leading to reduced load transfer efficiency and potential performance issues. While previous research has touched upon rotor system dynamics, there's a need for a deeper understanding of how specific bearing support parameters influence the static deformation of rotor shaft gears, especially in complex dual-rotor systems like the CRDRS, which presents unique challenges for supporting the inner rotor shaft. This paper aims to fill that gap by analyzing the effects of bearing support position and stiffness on gear deformation in CRDRS configurations.
Methods
The authors employ a multi-faceted approach:
- Timoshenko Beam Theory: This forms the basis for modeling the rotor shaft, accounting for shear deformation, which is crucial for accurate analysis of shafts under load.
- Lagrange Equations: These are used to derive the static equations governing the system's behavior.
- Relaxation Iterative Method (Two-Level): A novel iterative approach is introduced to solve the complex static equations. This method uses a relaxation factor to enhance convergence and a two-layer structure to efficiently handle the differing computational demands of bearing support stiffness and spline contact stiffness calculations. This is presented as a more efficient alternative to single-layer iterations.
- Finite Element Modeling: A static model of the CRDRS system is built, integrating substructures for rotor shafts, bearings, and gears.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a developed theoretical model and simulation based on provided structural parameters for the rotor shaft and bearings.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bearing Position is King: The most striking finding is that the position of the bearings has a far greater impact on gear deformation than their stiffness. This suggests that optimizing bearing placement should be the primary focus in design.
- Inner vs. Outer Shaft Deformation: The outer rotor shaft gear consistently exhibits smaller radial and angular deformations than the inner rotor shaft gear. This is attributed to the outer shaft's shorter, thicker structure and closer proximity to bearings.
- Monotonic Linear Relationships: Both bearing position and stiffness influence gear deformation in a predictable, monotonic linear fashion. This simplifies analysis and design optimization.
- Support Configuration Matters: The choice between simply supported and cantilevered support for the inner rotor shaft significantly alters deformation patterns, particularly for the inner gear.
- Novel Iterative Solution: The proposed two-level relaxation iterative method offers a significant computational efficiency improvement (175.5% speedup reported) compared to single-layer iterations, making complex static analyses more tractable.
Key Results
- Dominant Role of Bearing Position: Adjusting bearing positions showed a more pronounced effect on reducing gear deformation compared to adjusting stiffness. Specifically, the position of bearing b3 relative to gear s2 was highlighted as critical.
- Limited Impact of Stiffness: While bearing stiffness adjustments also followed a linear trend, their overall impact on deformation was relatively limited compared to positional changes.
- Support Configuration Impact: The cantilevered support configuration for the inner rotor shaft resulted in smaller deformations for the inner gear compared to the simply supported configuration, especially under bending moments.
- Gear s1 vs. Gear s2: Gear s1 consistently showed smaller deformations than gear s2 across both support configurations.
- Computational Efficiency: The two-level iterative method reduced calculation time from 383s to 139s for a set of system displacement vectors.
Limitations and Future Work
- Static Analysis: The study focuses solely on static deformation. Dynamic effects, such as vibrations and transient loads, are not considered.
- Simplified Bearing Model: While the paper uses a bearing stiffness model, it acknowledges the complexity of real-world bearings, including diagonal and cross-coupling stiffnesses, which are simplified in the analysis.
- Material Properties: The analysis uses specific material properties for TC4 titanium alloy. Variations in material or manufacturing tolerances are not explored.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that their findings can guide the design of CRDRS bearing support structures to improve mechanical performance and reliability. The proposed static iterative solution method is presented as a valuable tool for future analyses of transmission systems. Further research could explore dynamic analysis and the impact of varying operating conditions.
Summary updated