Effect of annealing temperature on the structure and properties of FeCoCrNiMo high-entropy alloy

Sheng Lei, Xue Zhengwei, Ya‐Feng Liu, Yun Li, Jiang Dongsheng, Ping WangHigh 2022 · DOI

This research paper, published in High Temperature Materials and Processes, investigates how heat treatment (annealing) can be used to "tune" the mechanical properties of a specific high-entropy alloy (HEA) composed of iron, cobalt, chromium, nickel, and molybdenum (FeCoCrNiMo).

TL;DR

Researchers discovered that annealing the FeCoCrNiMo high-entropy alloy at 1,073 K (800 °C) optimizes its performance by triggering a phase transformation where the $\mu$ phase decomposes into the $\sigma$ phase. This specific treatment results in the highest hardness and compressive strength, making it a promising candidate for high-temperature structural applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of extreme engineering—think jet engines or nuclear reactors—materials must maintain their strength at blistering temperatures. Traditional nickel-base superalloys often struggle because they form brittle "Topologically Close-Packed" (TCP) phases at high temperatures, which can degrade their mechanical properties.

High-entropy alloys (HEAs) are a relatively new class of materials made by mixing five or more elements in roughly equal proportions. They are known for their "cocktail effect," often showing superior thermal stability and strength compared to traditional alloys. However, we still don't fully understand how different temperatures affect the internal "microstructure" (the arrangement of atoms and phases) of these complex mixes. This paper specifically looks at the FeCoCrNiMo system to find the "Goldilocks" annealing temperature that yields the best properties.

Methods

The researchers used a standard metallurgical workflow but applied it to a complex five-element system:

  1. Fabrication: They used vacuum arc melting to create the initial alloy ingots, remelting them five times to ensure the elements were perfectly blended.
  2. Heat Treatment: Samples were vacuum-annealed for two hours at three distinct temperatures: 873 K, 1,073 K, and 1,273 K.
  3. Characterization:
    • XRD (X-ray Diffraction): To identify which crystal phases (like FCC, $\sigma$, or $\mu$) were present.
  4. SEM (Scanning Electron Microscopy): To visually inspect the dendritic (tree-like) structure and fracture surfaces.
  5. TG-DSC (Thermal Analysis): To check for mass changes or energy shifts during heating.
  6. Mechanical Testing: Using Vickers microhardness and universal testing machines to measure how much stress the material could handle before breaking.

Datasets

As an experimental materials science paper, it does not use external digital datasets. Instead, it generates original experimental data, including:

  • Phase composition tables: Detailing the atomic percentages of elements in different regions (dendrites vs. interdendritic areas).
  • Hardness values: Comparing the as-cast state to the three annealing temperatures.
  • Stress-strain curves: Quantitative data on yield strength, fracture strength, and deformation rates.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Phase Shuffle: The alloy naturally forms a "dendritic" structure where Chromium (Cr) and Molybdenum (Mo) cluster together in the "branches" (dendrites) to form the hard $\sigma$ and $\mu$ phases, while Iron (Fe), Cobalt (Co), and Nickel (Ni) form a softer FCC matrix between them.
  • The 1,073 K "Sweet Spot": At 873 K, the structure is stable but hasn't changed much. At 1,073 K, a significant change occurs: the $\mu$ phase (hexagonal) decomposes into the $\sigma$ phase (tetragonal). This increase in the $\sigma$ phase significantly boosts the alloy's strength.
  • Dissolution at High Heat: When pushed to 1,273 K, the $\sigma$ phase actually begins to dissolve back into the FCC matrix. This makes the material more ductile (it can stretch more) but reduces its peak strength.
  • Thermal Stability: The TG-DSC analysis showed the alloy is remarkably stable, with no major mass loss or chemical reactions occurring up to 1,273 K, confirming its potential for high-heat environments.

Key Results

  • Peak Hardness: The 1,073 K annealed sample reached a hardness of 699.96 $HV_{0.2}$, which is approximately 147 HV higher than the original as-cast state.
  • Maximum Strength: The yield strength reached 1530.1 MPa and the fracture strength hit 2180.5 MPa at the 1,073 K mark—the highest across all tested conditions.
  • Improved Ductility: While the 1,073 K sample was the strongest, the 1,273 K sample was the most "flexible," reaching a compressive deformation rate of 14.1% (a 5.4% improvement over the as-cast state).
  • Fracture Mode: Despite the strength gains, the alloy remains inherently brittle, failing via intergranular fracture (cracking along the boundaries between grains) and cleavage fracture.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while the alloy is incredibly strong, its brittleness is a concern. The presence of the $\sigma$ phase, while great for strength, is the primary culprit for the low ductility and brittle fracture mechanism.

Future research might focus on:

  • Micro-alloying: Adding small amounts of other elements to "toughen" the grain boundaries.
  • Long-term Aging: This study looked at a 2-hour anneal; real-world applications require stability over hundreds or thousands of hours.
  • Corrosion Resistance: While Mo is known to help with corrosion, this specific study did not test the alloy's performance in harsh chemical environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract FeCoCrNiMo high-entropy alloy was melted by vacuum arc melting. The alloys were vacuum annealed at 873, 1,073, and 1,273 K, respectively. X-ray diffractometer (XRD), scanning electron microscope (SEM), simultaneous thermal analyzer, microhardness tester, and universal testing machine were used to study the microstructure, the thermal stability, hardness and compression mechanics of as-cast and annealed FeCoCrNiMo alloys. The results show that the alloy is composed of face-centered cubic (FCC) phase and σ phase in both as-cast and annealed states, and the σ phase and μ phase can maintain structural stability at 873 K annealing temperature. The μ phase decomposes to form the σ phase after annealing at 1,073 K, and part of the σ phase dissolves in the FCC phase when annealed at 1,273 K. Both the as-cast and annealed alloys have a typical dendritic structure. The σ phase is enriched in dendrites, and the FCC phase exists between the dendrites. The microstructure of the alloys in the annealed state is more refined than that of the alloy in the as-cast state. In the 1,073 K annealed state, the FeCoCrNiMo alloy has the highest hardness, yield strength, and fracture strength. The fracture mechanism of the alloy is intergranular brittle fracture and cleavage fracture.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lei2022effect,
  author = {Sheng Lei and Xue Zhengwei and Ya‐Feng Liu and Yun Li and Jiang Dongsheng and Ping Wang},
  title = {{Effect of annealing temperature on the structure and properties of FeCoCrNiMo high-entropy alloy}},
  booktitle = {High},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1515/htmp-2022-0048},
}
Figure