Effect of a Virtual Reality-Based Restorative Environment on the Emotional and Cognitive Recovery of Individuals with Mild-to-Moderate Anxiety and Depression

Hongqidi Li, Wenyi Dong, Zhimeng Wang, Nuo Chen, Jian Wu, Guangxin Wang, Ting JiangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores the use of Virtual Reality (VR) to create restorative environments for individuals experiencing mild-to-moderate anxiety and depression. By combining VR technology with principles of environmental psychology, the research demonstrates that immersive VR scenes can significantly improve emotional well-being and cognitive function, with the sense of presence playing a crucial mediating role.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rapid urbanization and the demands of modern life contribute to increased stress, anxiety, and depression. Traditional approaches to mental health often rely on therapeutic interventions or access to natural environments, which may not always be readily available or effective for everyone. This paper addresses the need for accessible and engaging interventions that can promote emotional and cognitive recovery. Specifically, it investigates whether VR, a technology offering immersive experiences, can effectively simulate restorative environments and provide therapeutic benefits for individuals struggling with anxiety and depression, bridging the gap between psychological theory and technological application.

Methods

The study employed a multi-phase approach. Initially, a VR restorative garden scene was developed and validated for its healing effects on a small group. Subsequently, a larger experiment involved 195 participants diagnosed with mild-to-moderate anxiety and depression. These participants were exposed to various VR environments, including a VR urban scene (control) and several VR restorative scenes (naturalistic garden with different interaction levels).

Key techniques included:

  • VR Environment Design: Creation of 3D dynamic VR scenes using Unity, incorporating elements like forests, lawns, gardens, and water features. Interactive elements such as watering and fishing were also integrated.
  • Psychological Testing: Standardized questionnaires were used to assess emotional states (Positive and Negative Affect Scale - PANAS, Self-Rating Depression Scale - SDS), anxiety (State-Trait Anxiety Inventory - STAI), and self-efficacy (General Self-Efficacy Scale - GSES). The Restorative Environment Scale (RES) and Presence Questionnaire (PQ) were used to measure perceived restoration and presence.
  • Physiological Monitoring: Electromyography (EMG) was used to measure muscle activity (body involvement), and Electroencephalography (EEG) was employed to assess brain activity (prefrontal lobe activation, alertness, engagement, and calmness).

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 195 participants who met the criteria for mild-to-moderate anxiety and depression. These participants were recruited from Beijing Forestry University and Beijing Normal University. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation; instead, data was collected through direct experimentation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • VR as a Restorative Tool: The study strongly supports the idea that VR can effectively create restorative environments, offering a viable alternative or supplement to real-world nature exposure.
  • The Power of Presence: The "sense of presence" in VR was identified as a critical mediator. Higher presence significantly contributed to improved emotional states and self-efficacy. This highlights that simply being in a VR environment isn't enough; the feeling of being there is key.
  • Urban vs. Natural VR: Intriguingly, the VR urban environment showed a higher recovery score than natural environments in this study, a finding that contrasts with real-world observations. This suggests that for individuals accustomed to indoor, high-stress environments, a novel, less demanding urban VR scene might offer a unique form of escape and restoration.
  • Interactive VR Enhances Presence: Interactive elements within VR scenes, such as gardening or fishing, significantly boosted the sense of presence compared to passive visual experiences.
  • Brain Activity Correlates with Recovery: EEG data revealed that VR restorative scenes activated the prefrontal lobe, which is associated with cognitive functions, supporting the cognitive recovery aspect.

Key Results

  • Emotional Improvement: All VR scenes, including the urban environment, significantly reduced negative emotions. Positive emotions showed a slight improvement, though not always statistically significant across all groups.
  • Self-Efficacy Boost: Self-efficacy improved significantly across most VR restorative environment groups, particularly those with interactive elements.
  • No Subjective Difference in Restoration: While physiological and presence measures showed differences, participants did not report significant differences in their subjective feeling of restoration across the various VR scenes.
  • EEG Findings: VR restorative scenes led to increased prefrontal alertness and engagement, and decreased calmness signals, indicating a shift towards a more active cognitive state conducive to recovery.
  • EMG Findings: EMG data indicated increased arm muscle activity during VR experiences, suggesting greater body involvement and engagement.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Sensory Input: The study primarily focused on visual and auditory (though not explicitly detailed as a variable) VR experiences, neglecting other sensory modalities that could enhance restoration.
  • Short Experience Duration: Participants experienced the VR scenes for only 10 minutes, which might not be sufficient for profound, long-term effects.
  • Potential for Motion Sickness: Some participants experienced discomfort, which could have influenced their experience and perception of presence.
  • Within-Subject Design: The study design did not allow participants to experience all five scenes, potentially limiting the detection of subtle differences.
  • Lack of Sound Integration: The absence of sound in some VR scenes was noted as a potential factor affecting immersion and restoration.

Future research directions include:

  • Integrating Multi-Sensory VR: Incorporating touch, smell, and more advanced auditory elements.
  • Longitudinal Studies: Investigating the long-term effects of VR restorative interventions.
  • Exploring Individual Preferences: Understanding how personal preferences for environments influence VR effectiveness.
  • Optimizing Scene Design and Duration: Balancing scene richness, interaction complexity, and experience time to maximize benefits and minimize discomfort.
  • Investigating the Mechanism of Presence: Further exploring the intricate relationship between presence, emotion, and cognitive function in VR.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, restorative environment theory and virtual reality (VR) technology were combined to build different 3D dynamic VR interactive scenes. We discuss the effects of a VR restorative environment on the emotional and cognitive recovery of individuals with mild-to-moderate anxiety and depression. First, we built a VR restorative garden scene, divided into four areas: forest, lawn, horticultural planting, and water features. The scene was verified to have a good recovery effect in 26 participants. Then, 195 participants with mild-to-moderate anxiety and depression were selected as experimental subjects. Through psychological testing and EMG (Electromyography) and EEG (Electroencephalography) data feedback, we further explored the differences in the sense of presence in VR restorative scenes and their effect on individual emotional and cognitive recovery. The results showed that (1) both the restorative environment images and the VR scenes had a healing effect (the reduction in negative emotions and the recovery of positive emotions and cognition), with no difference in the subjective feeling of recovery among the different scenes, but the recovery score of the VR urban environment was higher than that of the natural environment (differing from the results in real environments); (2) a high sense of presence can be experienced in different VR scenes, and interactive activities in VR scenes can provide a great presence experience; (3) the recovery effects of VR restorative environment on emotion and self-efficacy are realized through the presence of VR scenes; (4) a VR restorative environment is helpful for the emotional improvement and cognitive recovery of individuals with mild-to-moderate anxiety and depression. VR urban scenes also have good recovery effects. In terms of cognitive recovery, self-efficacy improved significantly. In addition, from the perspective of EEG indicators, the VR restorative scene experience activated the prefrontal lobe, which is conducive to cognitive recovery in individuals with mild-to-moderate anxiety and depression. In terms of emotional improvement, negative emotions were significantly reduced in the different VR scene groups. In conclusion, we further explored ways to help individuals with mild-to-moderate anxiety and depression, in order to promote the development and application of mental health.
BibTeX
@article{li2021effect,
  author = {Hongqidi Li and Wenyi Dong and Zhimeng Wang and Nuo Chen and Jian Wu and Guangxin Wang and Ting Jiang},
  title = {{Effect of a Virtual Reality-Based Restorative Environment on the Emotional and Cognitive Recovery of Individuals with Mild-to-Moderate Anxiety and Depression}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph18179053},
}
Figure