Efeitos das lutas no comportamento reativo-agressivo de escolares

Francisco C. Pereira, Eldernilson Lima Nery, Rosângela Lima da Silva, Alan Pantoja Cardoso, Francivaldo José da Conceição Mendes, Smayk Barbosa Sousa, Gileno Edu Lameira de Melo, José Robertto Zaffalon JúniorCuadernos 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Violence is a persistent element of human society, manifesting in various social spaces, including schools. Educational institutions, as sites of social interaction, often become venues for aggressive behavior. This study analyzed the influence of martial arts (lutas) on the behavior of schoolchildren through an exploratory and descriptive field study with a quantitative approach. Data were collected using the Q-CARP questionnaire from 59 elementary and high school students across three schools in Gurupá, Pará. Results indicated that martial arts practitioners had a significantly lower mean aggressive behavior score (7.50 ± 1.71) compared to non-practitioners (9.03 ± 3.02, p = 0.019). Conversely, practitioners showed higher reactive behavior scores (23.86 ± 6.91) than non-practitioners (19.06 ± 5.19, p = 0.004). These findings suggest that martial arts practice significantly influences behavior, potentially debunking myths of inherent violence and supporting its inclusion in school physical education.

Introduction

School violence has become a critical issue in contemporary education. In Brazil, the Ministry of Education reported a 45% increase in school-related incidents in 2022. As educators seek tools for emotional regulation and socialization, martial arts—often referred to as "lutas" in the Brazilian curriculum—emerge as a potential pedagogical resource. However, these disciplines frequently face a stigma that equates combat sports with the promotion of violence, leading to their exclusion from many physical education programs. This research investigates whether martial arts practice correlates with aggressive tendencies or if it serves as a stabilizing force for student behavior.

Methodology

The study employed a quantitative, exploratory, and descriptive design conducted in Gurupá, Pará, Brazil. The participant pool consisted of 59 students (ages 14–18) from three municipal schools: Raimundo Ribeiro Dias, Padre Giullio Lupi, and Marcílio Dias.

The primary assessment tool was the Questionnaire of Aggressive and Reactive Behavior among Peers (Q-CARP). This 20-item instrument distinguishes between:

  1. Proactive Aggressive Behavior (8 items): Unprovoked actions intended to harm or dominate others.
  2. Reactive Behavior (12 items): Responses to perceived provocation or conflict.

Statistical analysis included Levene’s test for normality and Student’s t-test for independent samples to compare practitioners ($n=28$) and non-practitioners ($n=31$), with a significance level set at $p < 0.05$.

Results and Discussion

The analysis revealed a statistically significant divergence in behavior between the two groups.

Variable Practitioners ($n=28$) Non-practitioners ($n=31$) $p$-value
Aggressive Behavior $7.50 \pm 1.71$ $9.03 \pm 3.02$ $0.019$
Reactive Behavior $23.86 \pm 6.91$ $19.06 \pm 5.19$ $0.004$

The Aggression Paradox

The lower proactive aggression scores among practitioners suggest that the structured environment of martial arts—emphasizing discipline, hierarchy, and mutual respect—acts as a deterrent to impulsive violence. Rather than fostering a "bully" mentality, the training appears to provide students with the emotional tools to avoid unprovoked aggression.

Understanding Reactivity

A counterintuitive finding was the higher reactive score among practitioners. The authors argue this does not indicate increased volatility. Instead, it reflects heightened self-efficacy and confidence. Practitioners, feeling more capable of defending themselves or managing conflict, are more likely to engage with and attempt to resolve provocative situations through non-physical means, as they lack the insecurity that often drives unprovoked "pre-emptive" aggression.

Conclusion

This study provides empirical evidence that martial arts can be a powerful tool for behavioral management in schools. By focusing on the philosophical and moral foundations of these arts—rather than just the physical techniques—educators can foster self-control and reduce proactive violence. While the study's sample size and gender imbalance (fewer female practitioners) limit broad generalization, the results strongly support the inclusion of martial arts like Capoeira and Jiu-Jitsu in the school curriculum as a means of promoting social development and emotional intelligence.

Summary updated

Abstract

A violência se apresenta em meio a sociedade humana desde os princípios da civilização e se perpetua até os dias atuais sendo observada em meio aos diferentes grupos sociais, e se manifesta nos mais variados espaços, inclusive nas escolas. As instituições de ensino escolar são um local de convívio social e por tanto, um lugar onde as diferenças se encontram e se tornam lugares propícios para comportamentos agressivos. O presente trabalho analisou a influência das lutas no comportamento de escolares, realizado por meio de uma pesquisa de campo, com objetivos exploratório e descritivo e abordagem quantitativa. Os dados foram coletados por meio do questionário Q-CARP. A pesquisa foi realizada em três escolas, das quais participaram 59 escolares do ensino fundamental e médio. Os resultados obtidos apontaram que os escolares praticantes de lutas apresentaram escore médio de comportamento agressivo igual a 7,50 ± 1,71 e os não praticantes igual a 9,03 ± 3,02 (p = 0,019). Quanto ao comportamento reativo, o escore médio dos praticantes de luta foi igual a 23,86 ± 6,91 e dos não praticantes igual a 19,06 ± 5,19 (p=0,004). A presente pesquisa apontou que a prática das lutas possui grande influência no comportamento agressivo de escolares, desmistificando a violência das lutas, sugerindo assim que as lutas possam ser fomentadas como conteúdo da educação física escolar.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pereira2024efeitos,
  author = {Francisco C. Pereira and Eldernilson Lima Nery and Rosângela Lima da Silva and Alan Pantoja Cardoso and Francivaldo José da Conceição Mendes and Smayk Barbosa Sousa and Gileno Edu Lameira de Melo and José Robertto Zaffalon Júnior},
  title = {{Efeitos das lutas no comportamento reativo-agressivo de escolares}},
  booktitle = {Cuadernos},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.55905/cuadv16n13-010},
}
Figure