Editors' Introduction

Florian Kerschbaum, Michelle L. MazurekProc. Priv. Enhancing Technol 2022 · DOI

Introduction

The Proceedings on Privacy Enhancing Technologies (PoPETS) serves as a premier venue for high-quality research in the field of privacy. This editorial introduction provides an overview of Issue 4 of the 2022 volume, detailing the journal's unique review model and presenting the statistical outcomes of the most recent submission cycle.

The PoPETS Hybrid Review Model

PoPETS operates on a hybrid conference-journal model designed to address the limitations of traditional academic publishing. While traditional conferences often rely on a binary "accept or reject" decision culture that can stifle promising research, PoPETS emphasizes iterative improvement. This model combines the rapid dissemination and community engagement of a conference with the constructive, revision-focused approach of a journal.

By allowing authors to resubmit revised work across multiple "issues" within a single year, PoPETS fosters a collaborative environment where reviewers and authors work together to refine research. This approach aims to move away from the adversarial nature of peer review, ensuring that promising ideas are not lost due to fixable flaws.

Review Methodology

The journal employs a rigorous double-blind peer-review process managed by a large, diverse editorial board. The methodology consists of several key stages:

  • Two-Round Review: Each submission is initially assessed by two Regular Editorial Board members and one Senior Editorial Board member (the meta-reviewer). Papers that show potential proceed to a second round, receiving a total of four reviews.
  • Iterative Decision Scale: Decisions are more nuanced than simple acceptance or rejection. They include Accept, Accept with Minor Revisions, Major Revisions, Reject and Resubmit, and Reject. This scale encourages authors to address specific feedback and resubmit their work rather than starting from scratch at a different venue.
  • Meta-Reviewing: The meta-reviewer synthesizes the individual reviews and the subsequent discussion into a single document. This provides authors with clear, actionable guidance on the changes required for acceptance.
  • Conflict of Interest (COI) Management: To maintain the integrity of the double-blind process, COIs are strictly managed. Board memberships are published in advance, and the Editors-in-Chief manually verify potential conflicts to ensure fairness.

Issue 4 Statistics

The submission pool for Issue 4, Volume 2022, reflects the vibrancy and growth of the privacy research community. A total of 166 papers were submitted for consideration.

Submission Breakdown

The iterative nature of the journal is evident in the submission data:

  • New Submissions: 120 papers.
  • Major Revisions: 29 papers were resubmissions of work previously given a "Major Revisions" decision.
  • Rejected Resubmissions: 17 papers were resubmissions of work previously rejected from earlier issues.

Acceptance and Outcomes

The final decisions for this issue resulted in an overall acceptance rate of approximately 22%:

  • Accepted Outright: 18 papers.
  • Conditionally Accepted (Minor Revisions): 19 papers.
  • Major Revisions Invited: 32 papers.
  • Reject and Resubmit: 63 papers.
  • Desk Rejections: 16 papers (approx. 10%) were rejected without review for non-compliance with scope, page limits, or anonymity requirements.

The scale of this operation was supported by a massive editorial effort involving 152 Regular Editorial Board members, 28 Senior Editorial Board members, and 53 external reviewers, including "junior experts" nominated by the community to gain reviewing experience.

Artifact Review and Reproducibility

PoPETS continues to champion transparency and reproducibility through its optional artifact review process. Authors of accepted papers are encouraged to submit their source code, datasets, or proofs to an artifact-review committee. This committee evaluates the quality and usability of these artifacts, which are then hosted alongside the final papers on the PETS website. This initiative ensures that the research community can build upon and verify the findings presented in the journal, improving the overall transparency of privacy research.

Conclusion

The 2022 Issue 4 of PoPETS demonstrates the success of the journal's hybrid model in fostering high-quality, iterative research. By prioritizing constructive feedback and reproducibility, PoPETS remains at the forefront of the privacy-enhancing technologies field, supporting both established researchers and the next generation of reviewers.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kerschbaum2022editors,
  author = {Florian Kerschbaum and Michelle L. Mazurek},
  title = {{Editors' Introduction}},
  journal = {Proc. Priv. Enhancing Technol.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.56553/popets-2022-0095},
}
Figure