Edge Computing Based IoT Architecture for Low Cost Air Pollution Monitoring Systems: A Comprehensive System Analysis, Design Considerations & Development

Zeba Idrees, Zhuo Zou, Li‐Rong ZhengSensors 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents an edge-computing-based IoT architecture for low-cost, real-time air quality monitoring. By offloading processing to edge devices and optimizing data transmission, the system significantly reduces computational burden on battery-powered sensors, leading to lower costs and improved power efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional air quality monitoring systems are often expensive, bulky, and provide limited spatial and temporal resolution. This makes it difficult to get a comprehensive, real-time picture of air quality, especially in dynamic urban environments. Existing low-cost sensor networks, while more accessible, often struggle with accuracy, data validation, and sensor drift. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a system that is cost-effective, accurate, and provides the necessary spatial and temporal resolution for effective air quality monitoring.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution is an edge-computing-based IoT architecture with three layers: Sensing, Edge Computing, and Application.

  • Sensing Layer: Utilizes low-cost electrochemical sensors (for PM2.5, PM10, CO, NO2, SO2, O3) and a DHT11 sensor for temperature and humidity. To address the limitations of low-cost sensors, the system incorporates:
  • Pre-calibration: Algorithms to extrapolate coefficients from sensor datasheets to account for individual sensor variations.
  • Auto-calibration: Algorithms to adjust readings based on real-time temperature and humidity data.
  • Data Smoothing: A statistical algorithm to detect and remove outliers from sensor readings.
  • Edge Computing Layer: Employs an Arduino-based Edge Computing Device (ECD) that acts as an IoT gateway. This layer performs local data processing, including AQI calculation, data analysis, and power management. A key feature is the local data storage on an SD card, with only aggregated or significantly changed AQI values being sent to the cloud.
  • Application Layer: Leverages IBM Watson IoT platform for cloud-based data storage, visualization, and analysis. This layer allows users to define rules for alerts, notifications, and access data through web or mobile applications.

A novel Data Transmission Strategy is implemented to reduce power consumption. Sensing nodes only transmit data to the ECD if there's a significant change in the measured value. Similarly, the ECD only sends data to the cloud if the calculated AQI changes its window (e.g., moves from "Good" to "Moderate"). This minimizes redundant network traffic and power usage.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention training datasets. For evaluation, the system's measurements were compared against:

  • Official AQI data: This includes data from China's Ministry of Environmental Protection and other bodies, as well as recognized PM2.5 databases (e.g., from young-0.com/airquality/).
  • Experimental data: Collected over 15 consecutive days from a dormitory building at Fudan University, with 24 readings per day.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Edge Computing for Efficiency: Offloading processing to the edge significantly reduces the computational burden on resource-constrained sensing nodes, enabling longer battery life and lower overall system cost.
  • Addressing Low-Cost Sensor Limitations: The combination of pre-calibration, auto-calibration, and data smoothing algorithms is crucial for achieving acceptable accuracy with inexpensive sensors.
  • Intelligent Data Transmission: Transmitting data only when significant changes occur is a highly effective strategy for reducing power consumption and network bandwidth usage in IoT deployments.
  • Scalability and Modularity: The layered architecture allows for easy scaling and integration of additional sensors or nodes as needed.
  • Optimal Deployment Height: The study suggests that optimal deployment height for sensors is crucial for accurate readings, with a sweet spot identified around 9 meters for capturing pollution near its source.

Key Results

  • Computational Burden Reduction: The proposed system reduces the computational burden on sensing nodes by up to 70%.
  • Power Consumption Reduction: The data transmission strategy leads to a power consumption reduction of up to 23% for the sensing node.
  • Cost Reduction: The system offers a significant low-cost advantage compared to conventional monitoring systems.
  • Accuracy: The system achieves data accuracy around 75-80% under different circumstances, with algorithms to manage cross-sensitivity and temporary errors.
  • Experimental Validation: The system's effectiveness was demonstrated through experiments in various settings (living room, office, outdoor environment) and by comparing its measurements with official data, showing good correlation in trends.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Accuracy of Low-Cost Sensors: While the system mitigates issues, the inherent accuracy of low-cost sensors may still not match that of high-end, conventional monitoring stations. The paper notes that data accuracy is around 75-80%.
  • Static Sensor Networks: The current model is primarily designed for static sensor networks, as pollution sensors perform best in static conditions.
  • Industrial Monitoring: For industrial monitoring, the current versions may need to be upgraded for higher accuracy.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that nodes are scalable and allow for easy upgrades according to demand, implying potential for future enhancements and broader applications. The paper also hints at the need for further research in power management strategies for larger networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the swift growth in commerce and transportation in the modern civilization, much attention has been paid to air quality monitoring, however existing monitoring systems are unable to provide sufficient spatial and temporal resolutions of the data with cost efficient and real time solutions. In this paper we have investigated the issues, infrastructure, computational complexity, and procedures of designing and implementing real-time air quality monitoring systems. To daze the defects of the existing monitoring systems and to decrease the overall cost, this paper devised a novel approach to implement the air quality monitoring system, employing the edge-computing based Internet-of-Things (IoT). In the proposed method, sensors gather the air quality data in real time and transmit it to the edge computing device that performs necessary processing and analysis. The complete infrastructure & prototype for evaluation is developed over the Arduino board and IBM Watson IoT platform. Our model is structured in such a way that it reduces the computational burden over sensing nodes (reduced to 70%) that is battery powered and balanced it with edge computing device that has its local data base and can be powered up directly as it is deployed indoor. Algorithms were employed to avoid temporary errors in low cost sensor, and to manage cross sensitivity problems. Automatic calibration is set up to ensure the accuracy of the sensors reporting, hence achieving data accuracy around 75⁻80% under different circumstances. In addition, a data transmission strategy is applied to minimize the redundant network traffic and power consumption. Our model acquires a power consumption reduction up to 23% with a significant low cost. Experimental evaluations were performed under different scenarios to validate the system's effectiveness.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{idrees2018edge,
  author = {Zeba Idrees and Zhuo Zou and Li‐Rong Zheng},
  title = {{Edge Computing Based IoT Architecture for Low Cost Air Pollution Monitoring Systems: A Comprehensive System Analysis, Design Considerations \& Development}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/s18093021},
}
Figure