Ecosystem Stability Assessment of Yancheng Coastal Wetlands, a World Natural Heritage Site

Peng Tian, Luodan Cao, Jialin Li, Ruiliang Pu, Yongchao Liu, Haitao Zhang, Caiyi WangLand 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study developed a comprehensive ecosystem stability evaluation system for the Yancheng coastal wetlands, a UNESCO World Heritage site, using a multi-source data approach. The findings reveal that the overall ecosystem stability is at an "early warning" stage, highlighting specific areas and factors contributing to this vulnerability, which is crucial for guiding conservation efforts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal wetlands are vital ecosystems, offering significant ecological and socioeconomic benefits. However, they face increasing pressure from human activities, leading to degradation and reduced stability. Existing ecosystem stability evaluations often rely on limited data or focus on simpler systems, leaving a gap in understanding the complex dynamics of coastal wetlands. This paper aims to address this by providing a robust, multi-faceted assessment of ecosystem stability in the Yancheng coastal wetlands, a globally significant site, to inform sustainable management and conservation strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a Pressure-State-Response (PSR) model, a widely recognized framework for assessing environmental conditions. They constructed a hierarchical evaluation index system with 33 indicators, categorized into four layers: Target Layer (overall stability), Criterion Layer (pressure, state, response), Factor Layer (resource, environmental, socioeconomic pressures; soil, water, biological, landscape states; protection response), and Index Layer (specific measurable indicators). This system was designed to integrate both internal (natural environmental) and external (human-induced) factors influencing wetland stability. The evaluation utilized a multi-source data approach, combining field measurements (soil and water quality) with remote sensing data and socioeconomic statistics. AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process) was used for weighting the indicators, and a five-level grading standard (extremely dangerous to stable) was applied to assess the results.

Datasets

The study utilized a combination of datasets:

  • Field-measured data: Soil samples (analyzed for available nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, organic matter, pH, and salinity) and water samples (analyzed for TP, TN, COD, and ammonia nitrogen) collected across different seasons in 2018-2019.
  • Remote Sensing Data: Landsat 5 TM (1991) and Landsat 8 OLI (2019) imagery were used for landscape pattern analysis, specifically for land use classification.
  • Socioeconomic Data: Data from the 2019 Yancheng Statistical Yearbook and related county-level statistical departments were incorporated.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holistic Approach is Crucial: The study emphasizes that understanding coastal wetland stability requires integrating diverse data sources and considering both natural processes and human impacts, moving beyond single-factor analyses.
  • "Early Warning" is a Wake-Up Call: The finding that the Yancheng coastal wetlands are in an "early warning" stage underscores the urgent need for targeted interventions to prevent further degradation.
  • Spatial Heterogeneity Matters: Stability is not uniform across the Yancheng wetlands. Identifying specific segments (like Binhai being relatively stable vs. Dafeng facing high pressure) is vital for localized management.
  • Interconnected Pressures: High resource and socioeconomic pressures, coupled with poor water quality, are identified as major drivers of instability, highlighting the interconnectedness of environmental and human systems.

Key Results

  • Overall Stability: The Yancheng coastal wetlands ecosystem stability value was 2.27 in 2019, placing it in the "early warning" stage.
  • Segment-Specific Stability: The Binhai segment was found to be in a "relatively stable" state (3.15), while Xiangshui (2.67), Sheyang (2.93), Dafeng (2.24), and Dongtai (2.61) segments were all in the "early warning" stage. The Dafeng segment exhibited the weakest stability.
  • Pressure Distribution: The southern segments (Dafeng and Dongtai) generally faced higher ecosystem stability pressure than the northern segments (Xiangshui and Binhai). Dafeng District and the entire Yancheng District experienced the highest pressure.
  • State Levels: The Sheyang segment showed the highest ecosystem stability state, followed by Binhai and Xiangshui.
  • Factor Layer Insights: The entire Yancheng District faces significant resource and socioeconomic pressures, with poor water quality. However, soil, biological, and landscape states are generally favorable, and the response to wetland protection is active.
  • Key Influencing Factors: The ecosystem stability was significantly influenced by alien species invasion, changes in natural and artificial wetland areas, aquafarm expansion, fertilizer application intensity, and dominant vegetation coverage.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subjectivity in Weighting: While AHP is pragmatic, it introduces some subjectivity in determining indicator weights. The authors suggest combining AHP with the entropy method in future studies to achieve a more objective weighting.
  • Verification Challenges: Verifying evaluation results is difficult due to variations in methodologies across studies. The authors suggest comparing results with field measurements or studies on similar areas to enhance persuasiveness.
  • Data Scope: The study suggests expanding the time and spatial span of sampling data to establish long-term series for spatiotemporal differentiation analysis.
  • Indicator Impact: Further research is needed to expand the understanding of the degree of impact each indicator has on coastal wetland ecosystem functions.
  • Grading Standards: Developing more scientific and reasonable grading standards is recommended to enhance rigor and applicability.
  • Broader Application: The authors propose applying the developed index system to different ecosystems to analyze similarities and differences, thereby verifying its suitability.

Summary updated

Abstract

By evaluating the stability of coastal wetland ecosystems, health conditions of regional ecosystems can be revealed and the sustainable development of coastal wetlands can be promoted. Coastal wetlands have been scarcely involved in present ecosystem stability evaluation studies, these being performed with relatively simple evaluation data sources. Therefore, in this research, a comprehensive and representative ecosystem stability evaluation index system was constructed by using the pressure-state-response model and multi-source datasets from perspectives of internal and external environmental changes of the Yancheng coastal wetlands, Jiangsu, China. The analysis results indicated that: (1) The ecosystem stability of the Yancheng coastal wetlands was at an early warning stage, and all segments except the Binhai segment (relatively stable) were in an early warning state. (2) In the criterion layer, the Dafeng District and the whole Yancheng District were faced with the highest pressure, followed by the Dongtai, Xiangshui and Binhai segments, successively. The Sheyang segment reached the highest state level, followed by the Binhai, Xiangshui and Dafeng segments in succession. (3) In the factor layer, the whole Yancheng District was faced with high resource and socioeconomic double pressures, with a poor water quality state and relatively low environmental pressure; favorable soil, biological and landscape states; and positive response to wetland protection. Various factors varied from county to county. (4) In the index layer, the ecosystem stability of the Yancheng coastal wetlands was significantly influenced by the invasion of alien species, change rate of natural wetland area (D32), change rate of artificial wetland area, increment of aquafarm area, intensity of fertilizer application and coverage of dominant vegetations. The novel significance of this research lies in enriching global coastal wetlands ecosystem stability evaluation investigations by providing a typical case study.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tian2022ecosystem,
  author = {Peng Tian and Luodan Cao and Jialin Li and Ruiliang Pu and Yongchao Liu and Haitao Zhang and Caiyi Wang},
  title = {{Ecosystem Stability Assessment of Yancheng Coastal Wetlands, a World Natural Heritage Site}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/land11040564},
}
Figure