EcoSpeak: Cost-Efficient Bias Mitigation for Partially Cross-Lingual Speaker Verification

Divya V. SharmaNAACL 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical issue of linguistic bias in speaker verification systems, which disproportionately affects bilingual users. They introduce EcoSpeak, a novel, cost-efficient approach that uses contrastive linguistic attention and a bias corrector to mitigate this bias, demonstrating improved robustness on partially cross-lingual test sets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Speaker verification systems, used in everything from security to e-commerce, are designed to identify individuals based on their voice. While these systems have seen significant advancements with deep learning, they often suffer from linguistic bias. This bias arises because models trained on one language may perform poorly when presented with speech in another, especially in "partially cross-lingual" scenarios where one audio sample in a trial pair is in the training language and the other is in an unseen target language. This mismatch can lead to unfairness and exclusion for the vast global population of bilingual speakers. Adapting models to every language is computationally expensive and environmentally taxing. The paper aims to find a cost-effective solution to this partially cross-lingual bias problem.

Methods

The core of EcoSpeak is a novel architecture that builds upon a lightweight ResNet (Lite) for extracting speaker embeddings. The key innovations are:

  • Contrastive Linguistic (CL) Attention: This mechanism specifically leverages the linguistic differences between the two audio samples in a trial pair. It generates attention weights that highlight or de-emphasize parts of the speaker embeddings that are more influenced by language, thereby focusing on language-invariant acoustic features.
  • Bias Corrector: This module performs a joint language verification and bias adjustment. It first determines if the two audio samples are in the same language. Based on this, it applies a penalty to either the positive or negative class decision in the speaker verification task, preventing the model from being unfairly influenced by linguistic similarity or dissimilarity.
  • Residual Connections: The authors hypothesize and investigate that residual connections in deep neural networks help mitigate linguistic bias by allowing the model to emphasize low-level acoustic features, which are less language-dependent.

Datasets

  • VoxCeleb-2 dev set: Used to pre-train the ResNet (Lite) model for speaker identification.
  • VoxCeleb-1 test set: Used for evaluating the pre-trained ResNet (Lite).
  • NISP dataset: A multi-lingual dataset containing speech from bilingual speakers of Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, or Kannada, who also speak English. This dataset was crucial for creating the partially cross-lingual test sets.
  • NISP-Hindi speaker data: Used for fine-tuning EcoSpeak models.
  • Indian-accented English data (NPTEL 2020 lectures): Used for training the s-Detect model.
  • Other datasets: Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, and Kannada conversational speech recordings from various sources (OpenSLR, Microsoft Speech Corpus) were also used to train the s-Detect model.

The paper created seven Low-Resource Language (LRL) test sets, including fully cross-lingual and partially cross-lingual scenarios, to evaluate their models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Linguistic similarity is a double-edged sword: High linguistic similarity in negative trial pairs (e.g., both in the same target language) and low similarity in positive trial pairs (e.g., one in source, one in target) leads to performance degradation in baseline models. Conversely, linguistic match in positive pairs and mismatch in negative pairs leads to better performance.
  • Residual connections offer some robustness: Models incorporating residual connections (like ResNet+) show more stable performance across different linguistic scenarios compared to standard baselines, suggesting their utility in mitigating bias. However, they are not a complete solution.
  • Data balancing is key for cost-efficient bias mitigation: Fine-tuning EcoSpeak with carefully balanced training sets, particularly those with more "complex" trial pair types (those exhibiting linguistic mismatch), leads to more stable performance. Scheme-C, with a higher proportion of complex pairs, yielded the most stable results.
  • Language verification accuracy impacts speaker verification: EcoSpeak's performance shows a negative correlation between language verification accuracy and speaker verification EER. This highlights the importance of a robust language identification component for effective bias mitigation.

Key Results

  • EcoSpeak (specifically Scheme-C) consistently outperformed baselines across most partially cross-lingual test sets, achieving lower Equal Error Rates (EERs). For instance, on the Tamil-LRL test sets, EcoSpeak (Scheme-C) achieved EERs as low as 6.26% on the ss-ss test set, compared to baselines that often exceeded 20%.
  • EcoSpeak demonstrated significantly better stability than baselines, with smaller variations in EER across different test sets.
  • The CL attention mechanism was shown to be effective, particularly in challenging partially cross-lingual scenarios like ts-tt and st-ss.
  • EcoSpeak models fine-tuned on NISP-Hindi (a weakly related but diverse dataset) performed better on target low-resource languages (Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Kannada) than models fine-tuned on smaller, strongly related datasets, suggesting that diversity can be more beneficial than strict relatedness when data is scarce.
  • EcoSpeak is cost-efficient, boasting a smaller model size and fewer parameters than most baselines, and exhibiting lower inference costs in terms of time, carbon emissions, and electricity consumption.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Correlation between language and speaker verification: EcoSpeak's performance is influenced by its s-Detect model. A more robust s-Detect could further enhance speaker verification performance.
  • Limited experimental validation for CL Attention: While promising, the CL attention mechanism was tested on only five partially cross-lingual test sets. More extensive validation across a wider range of languages and scenarios is needed.
  • Training s-Detect on target languages: The s-Detect model was trained on general language identification datasets rather than explicitly fine-tuned on the specific target low-resource languages. While practical due to data availability, direct fine-tuning might yield further improvements.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more robust domain-invariant architectures, investigating greener approaches to speech processing, leveraging diverse datasets in weakly related languages for bias mitigation, and conducting detailed cost analyses for developing inclusive and environmentally friendly models.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sharma2024ecospeak,
  author = {Divya V. Sharma},
  title = {{EcoSpeak: Cost-Efficient Bias Mitigation for Partially Cross-Lingual Speaker Verification}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.18653/v1/2024.findings-naacl.27},
}
Figure