Introduction
Standard political economy models typically operate on the assumption that voters are "pocketbook" actors—rational individuals who vote based on their direct material interests. However, this framework struggles to explain a persistent phenomenon in modern democracies: why many low-income voters support candidates whose economic platforms, such as tax cuts for the wealthy or deregulation, appear to run counter to their own financial well-being.
This paper bridges the gap between materialist "interest-based" politics and "ideational" politics. By synthesizing the Stigler-Becker approach (politics driven by vested interests) with the Keynes-Hayek perspective (ideas as the primary drivers of change), the authors investigate how political entrepreneurs use ideas to reshape a voter’s understanding of their own interests. Specifically, they examine how economic shocks—such as the decline of manufacturing due to global trade—alter the "supply" of political messaging regarding identity and worldviews.
Theoretical Framework: The Role of "Memes"
At the heart of the authors' model is the "political entrepreneur." In a scenario where a wealthy political challenger competes for the votes of a lower-income median voter, the challenger can invest resources to discover and deploy "memes"—narratives, cues, or frames designed to shift voter preferences. These ideational tools function through two primary channels:
- Worldview Politics: These memes shift a voter’s belief regarding the mapping of policy to outcomes. For example, a narrative might suggest that "austerity is common sense" or that "tax cuts for the rich create jobs for the working class."
- Identity Politics: These memes increase the salience of a latent identity (such as religion, ethnicity, or nationality). By doing so, the voter begins to derive utility from the status and success of their group rather than focusing solely on their individual income.
Ideational Complementarity
A central contribution of the theory is the concept of ideational complementarity. The authors argue that worldview and identity politics are not substitutes but complements. A successful identity meme that makes a voter identify strongly with a high-status group (the "Association Effect") makes them more receptive to worldview memes that favor that group’s economic interests. As inequality rises, the "return on investment" for these ideational strategies increases for the party representing the wealthy, as they have more to lose from redistribution.
Empirical Strategy
To test this model, the authors employ an Instrumental Variables (IV) approach centered on the "China Shock"—the exogenous variation in U.S. local labor markets caused by the surge in Chinese import competition between 1990 and 2011. They analyze how this localized economic distress changed the content of televised political advertisements using the following datasets:
- Wesleyan Media Project (WMP): A database of over 60,000 unique political television ads aired between 2000 and 2018, coded by issue (e.g., abortion, taxes, jobs).
- China Shock Data: Commuting-zone level data on manufacturing employment changes and import exposure.
- Gallup "Most Important Problem" (MIP) Surveys: Used to distinguish between the "supply" of ideas from politicians and the "demand" for issues from voters.
Key Findings
1. The Asymmetric Response
The empirical results reveal a stark difference in how political parties respond to economic distress. In areas hit hardest by the China Shock, Republican candidates significantly intensified their messaging on "ideational" issues. There was a marked increase in ads focused on moral values (such as abortion and gay marriage) and terrorism. Conversely, while Democrats increased messaging regarding employment, they did not pivot to identity-based memes, sticking instead to traditional redistributive themes like healthcare and welfare.
2. Supply-Side Primacy
The data suggests that political entrepreneurs often lead the charge rather than simply reacting to voter concerns. The shift in political advertising toward identity issues frequently preceded shifts in what voters reported as their "most important problem" in Gallup surveys. This suggests that politicians actively shape the salience of these issues to move the needle on voter preferences.
3. Quantitative Shifts
The impact of the China Shock on the share of ads mentioning moral values was not only statistically significant but also cumulative. The effect grew over time, particularly following the 2008–2010 election cycles, confirming the model's prediction that economic shocks provide a fertile ground for the deployment of identity-based narratives.
Conclusion
This research demonstrates that when economic inequality rises or shocks occur, the political landscape shifts from a debate over redistribution to a battle of ideas. By strategically deploying memes that link identity to specific worldviews, political actors can successfully decouple voting behavior from material interests. While the current study focuses on the United States and the Republican party's strategy, the framework provides a robust lens through which to view the global rise of populism and the increasing importance of ideational conflict in modern democracy.
Summary updated