TL;DR
This paper explores how Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) strategically choose the quality of new products when they either remanufacture in-house or outsource this process to Contracted Remanufacturers (CRs). The study finds that OEMs tend to lower new product quality when outsourcing to reduce competition from CRs, which negatively impacts both the OEM and the overall industry economically, but can be environmentally beneficial under certain conditions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The remanufacturing industry is growing, offering economic and environmental benefits by restoring used products. While previous research has examined the economic and environmental impacts of remanufacturing, most studies assume OEMs handle it themselves or use independent remanufacturers (IRs). However, a common practice is OEMs outsourcing remanufacturing to CRs, often leading to legal disputes with unauthorized IRs. This paper addresses a gap by investigating how OEMs' strategic decisions about the quality of their new products are influenced by whether they remanufacture in-house or outsource to a CR. This quality choice is crucial because it affects the pricing and market appeal of both new and remanufactured products, potentially leading to cannibalization of new product sales.
Methods
The authors develop two theoretical models to analyze two distinct scenarios:
- Model I (In-house Remanufacturing): The OEM handles both the production of new products and remanufacturing operations.
- Model O (Outsourcing Remanufacturing): The OEM produces new products and outsources remanufacturing to a CR.
Both models employ a single-period game theory framework where the OEM first decides the optimal quality level for new products and the license fee (in Model O). Subsequently, the OEM and the CR (or just the OEM in Model I) simultaneously decide on production quantities. The analysis uses backward induction to derive equilibrium outcomes for quality, quantities, and profits. Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) methodology is applied to evaluate environmental impacts across different stages (manufacturing, usage, disposal, remanufacturing).
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and numerical experiments using MATLAB.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Quality as a Competitive Lever: OEMs use new product quality not just for market segmentation but also as a strategic tool to manage competition, particularly from remanufactured products.
- Outsourcing Drives Down Quality: When OEMs outsource remanufacturing, they strategically lower the quality of their new products. This is a tactic to reduce the competitive advantage of the CR and mitigate the cannibalization of new product sales.
- Economic Trade-offs: Outsourcing remanufacturing, while potentially beneficial for the CR, is detrimental to both the OEM and the overall industry economically. This is attributed to increased competition and a "double marginalization problem" between the OEM and CR.
- Environmental Nuance: The environmental impact of outsourcing is not always negative. There's a critical threshold based on the relative environmental costs of different life cycle stages. Below this threshold, outsourcing can be more environmentally friendly, despite lower profits. Above it, in-house remanufacturing is superior for both economic and environmental outcomes.
Key Results
- Optimal Quality: The optimal quality level of new products is always lower when remanufacturing is outsourced to a CR compared to when it's done in-house ($s_O^* < s_I^*$).
- Production Quantities: OEMs produce more new products when outsourcing ($q_n^O > q_n^I$). However, the quantity of remanufactured products is lower when outsourced ($q_r^O < q_r^I$), due to vertical competition and the double marginalization problem.
- Profitability:
- OEM Profit: The OEM's profit is lower under outsourcing ($π_m^O < π_m^I$).
- Industry Profit: The total industry profit is also lower under outsourcing ($π_{industry}^O < π_{industry}^I$).
- Environmental Impact:
- Outsourcing is more environmentally friendly when the ratio of manufacturing, usage, and disposal costs to remanufacturing costs is below a certain threshold.
- In-house remanufacturing is definitively better for both economics and the environment when this ratio exceeds the threshold.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:
- Profit Optimization vs. Multi-objective Optimization: The current models focus solely on profit optimization. Future work could explore multi-objective optimization to incorporate sustainability more holistically.
- OEM-centric Quality Decisions: The models assume only OEMs decide product quality. Future research could investigate the CR's influence on remanufactured product quality.
- Cost Simplification: The models primarily consider production costs. Future studies could incorporate reverse logistics costs (collection, disassembly, transportation) for a more comprehensive analysis.
- Single-Period Model: The analysis is based on a single-period model. Extending this to a multi-period setting could reveal dynamic strategic interactions.
Summary updated