Ecological feedback in quorum-sensing microbial populations can induce heterogeneous production of autoinducers

Matthias Bauer, Johannes Knebel, Matthias Lechner, Peter Pickl, Erwin FreyeLife 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel mechanism for how microbial populations can develop diverse production levels of signaling molecules (autoinducers) without relying on traditional "all-or-none" gene regulation. By modeling the interplay between individual cell growth, environmental feedback through quorum sensing, and population dynamics, the authors demonstrate that this ecological feedback can naturally lead to stable subpopulations with distinct autoinducer production rates. This finding offers an alternative explanation for observed phenotypic heterogeneity in microbial communities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Microbial communities often exhibit "quorum sensing," a system where cells communicate using signaling molecules called autoinducers to coordinate group behaviors like virulence or bioluminescence. Recent observations have shown that even genetically identical cells within a population can have vastly different levels of autoinducer production, a phenomenon known as phenotypic heterogeneity. While some models explain this by assuming "bistable" gene regulation (where a gene is either fully on or fully off), the exact mechanism for this heterogeneity, especially when gene regulation is not strictly bistable, has remained unclear. This paper tackles the question of how this phenotypic diversity arises and is maintained in microbial populations, particularly when cells' production of autoinducers impacts their own environment and their growth rate.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of theoretical modeling and numerical simulations. They develop a stochastic many-particle model of quorum sensing, where individual cells have a "production degree" for autoinducers. Key to their model are two core assumptions:

  1. Fitness Cost: Producing autoinducers incurs a metabolic cost, making non-producers grow faster than producers.
  2. Sense-and-Response: Cells sense the average autoinducer level in their environment and can adjust their own production accordingly, with a certain probability (response probability $\lambda$).

They then derive a macroscopic mean-field equation (the "autoinducer equation") from this microscopic model, which describes the evolution of the population's production distribution. This equation captures the coupling between ecological dynamics (driven by fitness differences and environmental feedback) and population dynamics. Numerical simulations using Gillespie's algorithm are used to explore the model's behavior under various conditions, and mathematical analysis is performed on the mean-field equation to understand the stability of different population states.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ecological Feedback as a Driver of Heterogeneity: The most significant insight is that the interaction between individual cell fitness (non-producers grow faster) and the collective environmental feedback (cells up-regulate production based on sensed autoinducers) can induce and maintain phenotypic heterogeneity. This is a form of ecological feedback loop.
  • Beyond Bistable Regulation: The paper demonstrates that phenotypic heterogeneity can arise even with "monostable" response functions, where production is up-regulated across all sensed autoinducer levels, not just above a threshold. This challenges the common assumption that bistable gene regulation is a prerequisite for such diversity.
  • Stable Coexistence of Phenotypes: The model predicts the stable coexistence of two distinct subpopulations: one that produces very little autoinducer (low producers) and another that produces significantly more (high producers). This bimodal distribution is quasi-stationary and can persist for long periods.
  • Robustness to Noise: The emergent heterogeneity is shown to be robust against various sources of noise, including noisy inheritance of traits, noisy perception of the environment, and noisy response mechanisms. This suggests that the phenomenon is a fundamental outcome of the ecological feedback, not an artifact of simplified assumptions.
  • Fine-Tuning of Average Production: While heterogeneity arises, the average autoinducer level in the population is still robustly controlled, allowing for the coordinated functions of quorum sensing to be maintained. This average level is finely tuned by the balance between the response probability and the selection strength.

Key Results

  • Bimodal Stationary Distributions: For small response probabilities ($\lambda$), the model predicts and simulations confirm the emergence of bimodal (two-peaked) distributions of autoinducer production degrees. These are quasi-stationary states where subpopulations of producers and non-producers coexist.
  • Long-Lived Heterogeneous States: These heterogeneous states are shown to be long-lived, with the time to reach a homogeneous state increasing exponentially with population size.
  • Phase Transitions: The system exhibits phase transitions between homogeneous and heterogeneous states as the response probability ($\lambda$) changes. Specifically, as $\lambda$ approaches a critical value ($\lambda_{up} = s/2$), the population transitions from a heterogeneous state to a homogeneous one.
  • Mathematical Characterization: The authors derived a mean-field equation that accurately describes the population dynamics and analytically characterized the conditions for stable heterogeneous stationary distributions. They found that heterogeneity is favored when the response probability is small and the response function exhibits up-regulation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Function of Heterogeneity: The paper focuses on how heterogeneity arises, not why it is beneficial. The authors suggest future work could explore the functional advantages, such as bet-hedging strategies or division of labor, by extending the fitness function to include explicit benefits of signaling.
  • Spatio-Temporal Scales: The model assumes a well-mixed environment. The authors acknowledge that spatial structure (e.g., in biofilms) could alter how autoinducers are sensed and dispersed, and suggest that future models might incorporate these complexities.
  • Experimental Validation: The authors propose specific single-cell experiments to simultaneously monitor autoinducer levels, gene expression, and growth rates. These experiments could help distinguish between their proposed ecological feedback mechanism and alternative explanations like stochastic gene expression in bistable circuits, and to quantify parameters like response rates.
  • Monostable vs. Bistable Regulation: While the model shows heterogeneity can arise from monostable regulation, they suggest experimental tests to determine if observed heterogeneity in real microbes is linked to monostable or bistable gene regulation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Autoinducers are small signaling molecules that mediate intercellular communication in microbial populations and trigger coordinated gene expression via 'quorum sensing'. Elucidating the mechanisms that control autoinducer production is, thus, pertinent to understanding collective microbial behavior, such as virulence and bioluminescence. Recent experiments have shown a heterogeneous promoter activity of autoinducer synthase genes, suggesting that some of the isogenic cells in a population might produce autoinducers, whereas others might not. However, the mechanism underlying this phenotypic heterogeneity in quorum-sensing microbial populations has remained elusive. In our theoretical model, cells synthesize and secrete autoinducers into the environment, up-regulate their production in this self-shaped environment, and non-producers replicate faster than producers. We show that the coupling between ecological and population dynamics through quorum sensing can induce phenotypic heterogeneity in microbial populations, suggesting an alternative mechanism to stochastic gene expression in bistable gene regulatory circuits.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bauer2017ecological,
  author = {Matthias Bauer and Johannes Knebel and Matthias Lechner and Peter Pickl and Erwin Frey},
  title = {{Ecological feedback in quorum-sensing microbial populations can induce heterogeneous production of autoinducers}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.25773},
}
Figure