TL;DR
This study quantifies the significant impact of water conservancy projects on the Irtysh River's flow and ecohydrological characteristics, leading to reduced biomass. It proposes improved methods for calculating ecological water demand for terrestrial and lake ecosystems, offering crucial insights for sustainable management and remediation in the basin and similar regions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Human activities, particularly the construction of water conservancy projects, are altering natural hydrological processes in river basins worldwide. These changes can disrupt ecosystem stability, leading to ecological challenges like reduced biomass and compromised ecosystem functions. The Irtysh River Basin, a trans-boundary river system with unique ecosystems, has experienced such alterations due to upstream water diversion projects. This paper addresses the critical need to understand and quantify these ecohydrological variations and, importantly, to determine the ecological water demand for key components of the basin's ecosystem – namely, valley forests and grasslands, and the Ulungur Lake system. Without this quantitative understanding, effective ecological protection and remediation strategies are difficult to implement.
Methods
The study employed a multi-faceted approach:
- Indicators of Hydrologic Alteration (IHA) and Range of Variability Approach (RVA): These standard methods were used to quantify the changes in river flow patterns (e.g., monthly flow, extreme flows, timing of flows) before and after the operation of water conservancy projects. This allowed for a statistical assessment of hydrological alteration.
- Improved Ecological Water Demand Calculation for Terrestrial Ecosystems: The paper adapted the Penman-Monteith equation for calculating reference crop evapotranspiration (ET₀). Recognizing the data limitations of the standard method, they introduced a novel approach by using water surface evaporation data to derive a conversion coefficient, enabling the calculation of long-sequence ET₀. This ET₀ was then used with ecological water demand coefficients and vegetation areas to estimate the total ecological water demand for valley forests and grasslands.
- Novel Ecological Lake Level Calculation: For Ulungur Lake, the study combined several methods to determine both minimum and maximum ecological lake levels. This included:
- Lake Morphological Analysis: Relating lake area changes to water levels.
- Fish-Salinity-Water Relationship Method: Considering salinity thresholds critical for fish survival.
- Habitat Control Method: Focusing on maintaining suitable conditions for biological communities.
- Natural Water Level Data: Using historical observations. This integrated approach aimed to provide a more robust estimation of ecological lake levels, crucial for maintaining ecosystem balance and preventing issues like salinization.
Datasets
- Hydrological Data: Flow data from the Burqin hydrological station on the Irtysh River. Data from 1956-1990 represented natural conditions, while data from 2002-2015 represented conditions after the operation of water conservancy projects. Data from 1991-2001 were missing.
- Meteorological and Evaporation Data: Data from Fuhai Station were used for calculating reference crop evapotranspiration. Specifically, short-series meteorological and evaporation data (2016-2017) were used to determine conversion coefficients, and long-series evaporation data (2008-2018) were used for calculating long-sequence ET₀.
- Lake Data: Historical observation data for Ulungur Lake (Burultokay and Jili lakes) from the Hydrological Bureau of Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region and the Hydrological Bureau of Yellow River Conservancy Commission in 2015. This included water level-capacity-area curves, salinity, and water volume measurements.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Significant Hydrological Alteration: The operation of water conservancy projects has drastically reduced the average annual river flow of the Irtysh River, with particularly pronounced impacts on the flow during the crucial June and July flood season. This highlights the substantial human influence on natural water regimes.
- Ecosystem Response to Flow Reduction: The study directly links reduced river flow and altered hydrological characteristics to decreased biomass in the basin's ecosystems, underscoring the sensitivity of these systems to water availability.
- Improved EWD Calculation for Terrestrial Ecosystems: The adaptation of the Penman-Monteith equation using water surface evaporation data is a practical solution for regions with limited meteorological data, making ecological water demand assessments more feasible and reliable.
- Integrated Approach for Lake Levels: Combining multiple methods (morphological, salinity, habitat, historical data) for determining ecological lake levels offers a more comprehensive and robust understanding compared to single-method approaches, especially for complex lake systems like Ulungur Lake.
- Ecological Regulation as a Mitigation Tool: The study demonstrates that "catchwork irrigation technology" (artificial flood peaks) can effectively mitigate the negative impacts of reduced flood flows from water conservancy projects, helping to restore hydrological processes and meet the water demands of valley forests and grasslands.
Key Results
- River Flow Reduction: The average annual river flow in the Irtysh River decreased significantly after the operation of water conservancy projects, with a high alteration index observed, particularly in July and August.
- Ecological Water Demand (Forests & Grasslands): The total ecological water demand for valley forests and grasslands during the critical growth period (April-September) was estimated at 521 million m³. The peak demand occurred in June and July, accounting for 52.4% of the total.
- Ecological Lake Levels (Ulungur Lake):
- Minimum ecological water levels for Burultokay and Jili lakes were determined as 478.66 m and 480.66 m, respectively.
- Maximum ecological water levels were determined as 482.80 m and 483.20 m, respectively. These levels were calculated considering the need to prevent saltwater intrusion between the lakes.
- Ecological Regulation Success: The implementation of ecological regulation (artificial flood peaks) led to a significant increase in vegetation coverage and grass yield, demonstrating its effectiveness in ecological remediation.
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Limitations: The study acknowledges that the calculation of ecological water demand for terrestrial ecosystems relied on evaporation dish data due to limitations in meteorological data. Future research could benefit from more comprehensive meteorological data.
- Exchange with Groundwater and Fish Food: The calculation of Ulungur Lake's ecological water demand did not fully consider the exchange between lakes and groundwater, nor the specific food source requirements for fish habitats.
- Future Research Directions:
- Further investigation into the relationship between ecological water demand and ecological regulation, water level, and lake water quality is recommended for developing more detailed guiding strategies.
- Future studies could explore the use of hydrodynamic models and optical/altimetry data for improved lake water quality and connectivity assessments.
- Investigating the response of lake water level to water conditions and the requirements of fish habitats is crucial for improving lake management.
Summary updated