Echo-Level SAR Imaging Simulation of Wakes Excited by a Submerged Body

Yan Jia, Shuyi Liu, Yongqing Liu, Limin Zhai, Yifan Gong, Xiangkun ZhangSensors 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive simulation framework for Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) imaging of submerged body wakes. By integrating fluid dynamics, electromagnetic scattering, and SAR imaging principles, it enables the generation of realistic SAR images of these wakes, crucial for understanding their detectability under various environmental conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Detecting submerged objects, like submarines, is vital for both civilian and military applications. While acoustic methods (sonar) have been the traditional approach, advancements in noise reduction and sound-dampening technologies are making them less effective. This has spurred interest in non-acoustic detection methods, with Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) showing significant promise due to its high resolution and all-weather capabilities. However, SAR cannot directly image submerged bodies; instead, it relies on detecting the disturbance they create on the sea surface – the wake. Understanding and simulating these wakes is crucial for developing effective SAR-based detection strategies. The challenge lies in accurately modeling the complex interplay between the submerged body's hydrodynamics, the resulting surface waves, and how these waves interact with radar signals under varying sea states and operational parameters.

Methods

The authors propose a multi-stage simulation approach:

  1. Hydrodynamic Modeling: They use Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) with the Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations and the Volume of Fluid (VOF) method to simulate the wake generated by a submerged body (specifically, a scaled DARPA SUBOFF hull). This captures the complex wave patterns, including Bernoulli peaks and Kelvin-like wakes, at different velocities and depths.
  2. Sea Surface Modeling: A realistic, randomly rough sea surface is generated using the Elfouhaily wave spectrum and the Longuet-Higgins directional transfer function. This model accounts for wind speed and direction, creating a dynamic background against which the wake is observed.
  3. Electromagnetic Scattering: The Two-Scale Model (TSM) is employed to calculate the electromagnetic scattering from the combined sea surface and wake. This model considers Bragg scattering, which is dominant for SAR at moderate incidence angles, and accounts for different polarizations (HH and VV).
  4. SAR Imaging Simulation: The simulated electromagnetic scattering data is then processed using the Range-Doppler (RD) algorithm. This algorithm simulates the entire SAR imaging chain, from raw echo signal generation to azimuth and range compression, to produce a final SAR image of the wake.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data generated from the models described.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wake Dynamics are Velocity Dependent: The study clearly shows that the characteristics of the submerged body wake, particularly the prominence of divergent and transverse waves, change significantly with the body's velocity. At lower speeds (lower Froude numbers), both wave types are visible, but as speed increases, the transverse wave diminishes.
  • Wind Conditions Mask Wakes: Higher wind speeds lead to a rougher sea surface, which can effectively "mask" the wake features in SAR images, making them less discernible. This highlights the importance of considering environmental conditions for wake detection.
  • Polarization Matters for Amplitude: While the pattern features of the wake's backscattering are similar between HH and VV polarizations, VV polarization generally shows a higher normalized radar cross-section (NRCS), resulting in brighter images.
  • Orientation is Key: The orientation of the wake relative to the SAR platform's line of sight (β) significantly impacts its visibility. When the wake is perpendicular to the radar line of sight (β=0°), only the divergent wave is prominent, while when parallel (β=90°), the transverse waves contribute more to the backscatter.
  • Simulation is Crucial for Understanding: The paper demonstrates the power of a fully integrated simulation approach to understand the complex interactions that determine wake detectability in SAR imagery.

Key Results

  • The CFD simulations successfully reproduced wake patterns consistent with theoretical expectations (e.g., Kelvin wakes) and showed how these patterns evolve with velocity.
  • Simulated SAR images revealed that at lower wind speeds (2 m/s), wakes are more discernible. As wind speed increases (e.g., to 3 m/s), the wake features become obscured by the sea surface background.
  • The study showed that at lower speeds, transverse waves are visible, but they diminish and eventually disappear as speed increases.
  • VV polarization consistently yielded brighter SAR images of the wakes compared to HH polarization.
  • The simulation framework successfully generated SAR images of wakes, demonstrating the feasibility of the proposed end-to-end simulation pipeline.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Constraints: The authors acknowledge that computational limitations restrict the scope of simulated wake scenes and the resolution of the generated data.
  • Simplified Hull Model: The study used a scaled, bare hull model of the SUBOFF submarine, excluding appendages like rudders and stern appendages, which could influence wake generation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the simulation to a wider array of submerged body wakes, investigating the effect of orbital velocity on facet displacement (VB effect), and exploring the influence of swell on SAR imaging outcomes. They also aim to delve deeper into SAR imaging simulations for various submerged body wakes.

Summary updated

Abstract

The paper introduces a numerical simulation method for Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) imaging of submerged body wakes by integrating hydrodynamics, electromagnetic scattering, and SAR imaging simulation. This work is helpful for better understanding SAR images of submerged body wakes. Among these, the hydrodynamic model consists of two sets of ocean dynamics closely related to SAR imaging, namely the wake of the submerged body and wind waves. For the wake, we simulated it using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) numerical methods. Furthermore, we compared and computed the electromagnetic scattering characteristics of wakes under various navigation parameters and sea surface conditions. Following that, based on the operational principles and imaging theory of synthetic aperture radar (SAR), we established the SAR raw echo signal of the wake. Employing a Range-Doppler (RD) algorithm, we generated simulated SAR images of the wake. The results indicate that utilizing Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) numerical methods enables the simulation of wake characteristics generated by the motion of a submerged body with different velocities. The backscattering features of wakes are closely associated with the relative orientation between the wake and the radar line of sight. Under specific wind speeds, the wake gets masked within the sea surface background, resulting in less discernible characteristics of the wake in SAR images. This suggests that at lower speeds of submerged body or under specific wind conditions, the detectability of the wake in SAR images significantly diminishes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jia2024echo,
  author = {Yan Jia and Shuyi Liu and Yongqing Liu and Limin Zhai and Yifan Gong and Xiangkun Zhang},
  title = {{Echo-Level SAR Imaging Simulation of Wakes Excited by a Submerged Body}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/s24041094},
}
Figure