TL;DR
This paper introduces ECC, the first automatically generated dialogue dataset with joint emotion-cause labels, addressing the limitations of manual annotation in empathy response systems. By leveraging LLMs and a novel EC-DD framework, ECC enables more robust and scalable training of empathetic AI, leading to improved response quality and a deeper understanding of conversational nuances.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Current empathy dialogue systems struggle to truly understand and respond to users because they often focus solely on identifying emotions without grasping the underlying causes. Existing datasets either lack cause annotations entirely or add them retrospectively through manual processes. This manual approach is plagued by subjectivity, leading to inconsistent cause labels, weak rational connections between emotions and their triggers, and prohibitively high costs that limit dataset scalability. The authors aim to overcome these challenges by creating a dataset that automatically and synergistically generates both emotion and cause labels during the dialogue creation process.
Methods
The core of the paper is the EC-DD (Emotion-Cause Dialogues Distillation) Framework. This framework automates the generation of dialogues and the extraction of emotion-cause labels. It begins by extracting "emotion-cause seeds" from commonsense knowledge bases, specifically focusing on the xReact relation (e.g., "PersonX pays attention to the paint, xReact, Motivated"). These seeds are then processed: emotions are mapped to a predefined emotion dictionary, and the cause and emotion seeds are used to generate a "Situation" description. This situation then serves as the context for a Large Language Model (LLM) to generate a dialogue. Finally, the LLM is used again to annotate emotion and cause sentences within the generated dialogue, ensuring a direct link between the dialogue content and the initial seeds. This process is designed to be fully automated, avoiding manual labeling.
Datasets
- ECC (Emotion-Cause Conversation Dataset): The primary contribution is this newly introduced dataset. It contains 2.4K dialogues with automatically generated emotion-cause labels.
- Existing Datasets for Comparison/Evaluation:
- DailyDialog: A large dataset with emotion labels.
- CHASE: A dataset derived from plays.
- Empathetic Dialogues (ED): A large, manually annotated dataset for empathetic conversation generation.
- ESConv: A dataset focused on emotional support dialogues with negative emotions.
- RECCON: A dataset that includes emotion and cause annotations, but these were added post-hoc.
- SODA: A large dataset for social dialogue, lacking empathy or emotional cause labels.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Automated, Synergistic Generation is Key: The paper strongly advocates for generating emotion and cause labels during dialogue creation, rather than retrofitting them. This approach inherently links the cause to the emotion, leading to more coherent and rational datasets.
- LLMs as Powerful Tools for Data Creation: The EC-DD framework demonstrates that LLMs can be effectively used not only to generate dialogues but also to extract and annotate complex relational information like emotion-cause pairs, significantly reducing costs and subjectivity.
- Cause Labels are Crucial for Deeper Empathy: Experimental results and human evaluations suggest that models trained on ECC (which includes cause labels) outperform those trained on emotion-only datasets, especially in generating contextually relevant and targeted empathetic responses. The ablation study highlights that cause labels are more critical than emotion labels for maintaining coherent and specific empathetic interactions.
- Balancing Data Scale and Quality: While ECC is smaller than some existing datasets, its automatically generated, high-quality, and richly annotated nature makes it a valuable resource. The paper shows that ECC can achieve competitive or superior performance even with less data compared to larger, manually annotated datasets.
Key Results
- ECC Dataset: The EC-DD framework successfully generated 2,398 dialogues with emotion-cause labels.
- Model Performance: The CAER model, trained on ECC, demonstrated superior performance across various metrics (Loss, Perplexity, BLEU scores) compared to models trained on ED and RECCON, especially on the RECCON benchmark.
- Human Evaluation: Human evaluators rated ECC-trained responses highly (average score of 4.61), particularly in Naturalness (4.74) and Affective expression (4.84).
- Cost Efficiency: The ECC dataset cost less than $500 to generate, a stark contrast to the estimated $7,000+ for traditional methods.
- Ablation Study: Removing cause labels (w/o C) led to a more significant decline in performance than removing emotion labels (w/o E), underscoring the importance of causal reasoning.
Limitations and Future Work
- LLM Biases: The authors acknowledge that LLM-generated data may still contain illusions and biases, despite mitigation efforts.
- Evaluation Metrics: Current automatic metrics for empathetic dialogue systems lack robust ways to assess emotion-cause annotation quality. Developing standardized metrics is an active area of pursuit.
- Dataset Scale: While ECC is a significant step, its current scale is limited by resource constraints. The authors envision leveraging the EC-DD framework for generating larger datasets in the future.
- Future Work: The authors plan to continue developing standardized metrics for cause-aware dialogue evaluation and to scale up the ECC dataset. They also aim to explore inferring emotional reasons in empathy response tasks more broadly.
Summary updated