Abstract
Online vision testing enables efficient data collection from diverse participants but often requires accurate fixation. When needed, fixation accuracy is traditionally ensured by using a camera to track gaze. That works well in the lab, but tracking during online testing with a built-in webcam is not yet sufficiently precise. Kurzawski, Pombo, et al. (2023) introduced a fixation task that improves fixation through hand-eye coordination, requiring participants to track a moving crosshair with a mouse-controlled cursor. This dynamic fixation task greatly reduces peeking at peripheral targets relative to a stationary fixation task, but does not eliminate it. Here, we introduce a crowded dynamic fixation task that further enhances fixation by adding clutter around the fixation mark to leverage crowding. We assessed fixation accuracy during peripheral threshold measurement. Relative to the RMS gaze error during the stationary fixation task, dynamic fixation error was 61%, while crowded dynamic fixation error was only 47%. With a 1.5° tolerance, peeking occurred on 9% of trials with stationary fixation, 4% with dynamic fixation, and 0% with crowded dynamic fixation. This improvement eliminated implausibly low peripheral thresholds, likely by preventing peeking. We conclude that crowded dynamic fixation provides accurate gaze control for online testing.
The Challenge of Online Gaze Control
In visual psychophysics, maintaining precise gaze fixation is critical. When measuring peripheral vision—for instance, determining a participant's ability to identify letters at 10 degrees eccentricity—any "peeking" toward the target invalidates the results. In laboratory settings, high-precision eye trackers like the EyeLink 1000 provide the necessary ground truth. However, as vision science increasingly moves online to reach broader populations, researchers face a hardware gap: standard webcams typically have an error margin of 4 degrees or more, which is insufficient for sensitive threshold measurements.
Crowded Dynamic Fixation: A Software-Based Solution
To address this, researchers developed Crowded Dynamic Fixation, a method that uses hand-eye coordination and visual crowding to "tether" the participant's gaze to a central target without specialized hardware. The study compared three fixation conditions:
- Stationary Fixation: A traditional static crosshair.
- Dynamic Fixation: A crosshair that moves slowly in a circle, which the participant must track with a mouse cursor.
- Crowded Dynamic Fixation: The moving crosshair is surrounded by three similar distractors moving in Brownian motion.
The "crowded" approach leverages a fundamental visual limitation: our inability to distinguish objects in the periphery when they are surrounded by clutter. If a participant attempts to look away from the central crosshair toward a peripheral stimulus, the central target becomes "crowded" by the distractors, making it nearly impossible to maintain accurate manual tracking. Thus, the mouse cursor acts as a physical "leash" for the eyes.
Experimental Validation and Trial Structure
The researchers validated this method using 21 participants in a lab setting, using an EyeLink 1000 to provide ground truth gaze data while participants used the EasyEyes web application. Each trial followed a specific sequence: a tracking phase (750–1250 ms), a brief stimulus view (150 ms), and a response phase.
Results: Achieving Lab-Grade Accuracy
The results demonstrate a significant improvement in gaze control:
- Error Reduction: Compared to stationary fixation, dynamic fixation reduced RMS gaze error to 61%, and crowded dynamic fixation reduced it to 47%.
- Eliminating Peeking: Using a standard 1.5° tolerance for fixation breaks, peeking occurred in 9% of stationary trials and 4% of dynamic trials. Remarkably, crowded dynamic fixation reduced peeking to 0%.
- Data Integrity: By preventing peeking, the method eliminated "implausibly low" peripheral thresholds that often plague online datasets, bringing results in line with established biological limits like Bouma’s Law.
Conclusion
Crowded dynamic fixation provides a robust, software-only solution for gaze control in online psychophysics. While slightly more demanding for participants—increasing experiment duration by approximately 18%—it ensures data quality comparable to laboratory standards. This method opens the door for high-precision vision research conducted remotely across diverse global populations.
Summary updated