Early versus delayed cranioplasty after decompressive craniectomy in traumatic brain injury: a multicenter observational study within CENTER-TBI and Net-QuRe
Rick Vreeburg, Ranjit D. Singh, Inge A. M. van Erp, Tommi K. Korhonen, John K. Yue, Harry Mee, Ivan Timofeev, Angelos G. Kolias, Adel Helmy, Bart Depreitere, Wouter A. Moojen, Alexander Younsi, Peter J. Hutchinson, Geoffrey T. Manley, Ewout W. Steyerberg, Godard C. W. de Ruiter, Andrew I.r. Maas, Wilco C. Peul, Jeroen T.j.m. van Dijck, Hugo F. den Boogert, Jussi P. Posti, Thomas A. van Essen, Cecilia Åkerlund, Krisztina Amrein, Nada Anđelić, Lasse Andreassen, Audny Anke, Anna Antoni, Gérard Audibert, Philippe Azouvi, Maria Luisa Azzolini, Ronald Bartels, Pál Barzó, Romuald Beauvais, Ronny Beer, Bo‐Michael Bellander, Antonio Belli, Habib Benali, Maurizio Berardino, Luigi Beretta, Morten Blaabjerg, Peter Bragge, Alexandra Bražinová, Vibeke Brinck, Joanne Brooker, Camilla Brorsson, András Büki, Monika Bullinger, Manuel Cabeleira, Alessio Caccioppola, Emiliana Calappi, Maria Rosa Calvi, Peter Cameron, Guillermo Carbayo Lozano, Marco Carbonara, Simona Cavallo, Giorgio Chevallard, Arturo Chieregato, Giuseppe Citerio, Hans Clusmann, Mark Coburn, Jonathan Coles, D. James Cooper, Marta Correia, Amra Čović, Nicola Curry, Endre Czeiter, Marek Czosnyka, Claire Dahyot‐Fizelier, Paul Dark, Helen Dawes, Véronique De Keyser, Vincent Degos, Françesco Della Corte, Đula Đilvesi, Abhishek Dixit, Emma Donoghue, Jens P. Dreier, Guy‐Loup Dulière, Ari Ercole, Patrick Esser, Erzsébet Ezer, Martin Fabricius, Valery L. Feigin, Kelly Foks, Shirin Frisvold, Alex Furmanov, Pablo Gagliardo, Damien Galanaud, Dashiell Gantner, Guoyi Gao, Pradeep George, Alexandre Ghuysen, Lelde Giga, Ben Glocker, Jagoš Golubović, Pedro A. GómezJournal of Neurosurgery2024 · DOI
Functional outcome and quality of life were similar between early and delayed cranioplasty in patients who had undergone DC for TBI. Neurosurgeons may consider performing cranioplasty during the index admission (early) to simplify the patient's chain of care and prevent readmission for cranioplasty but should be vigilant for an increased possibility of hydrocephalus. Clinical trial registration nos.: CENTER-TBI, NCT02210221 (clinicaltrials.gov); Net-QuRe, NTR6003 (trialsearch.who.int) and NL5761 (onderzoekmetmensen.nl).
Introduction
In cases of severe Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) with life-threatening brain swelling, a Decompressive Craniectomy (DC)—the surgical removal of a portion of the skull—is often performed as a life-saving measure. Once the intracranial pressure stabilizes, the skull must be reconstructed through a procedure known as cranioplasty.
Currently, clinical guidelines lack a consensus on the optimal timing for this reconstruction. Early cranioplasty (within 90 days) is theorized to improve cognitive and motor recovery by restoring normal intracranial pressure dynamics and allowing for earlier, more aggressive rehabilitation. Conversely, delayed cranioplasty (after 90 days) is often preferred to ensure that all swelling has resolved and to potentially minimize the risk of post-operative infection. This study evaluates the long-term functional outcomes and complication rates associated with these two timing strategies.
Methods
This prospective, multicenter, observational cohort study utilized data from two major European TBI registries: CENTER-TBI (65 centers) and Net-QuRe (8 centers in the Netherlands). From an initial pool of over 5,000 patients, 173 individuals who underwent both DC and subsequent cranioplasty were included (73 early, 100 delayed).
To address the inherent selection bias of an observational study (where healthier patients might receive earlier surgery), the researchers employed multivariable ordinal regression adjusted for baseline injury severity using the IMPACT model, propensity score matching, and instrumental variable analysis to account for center-specific surgical preferences.
Results
Functional Outcomes and Quality of Life
The primary finding was that the timing of cranioplasty did not significantly impact macro-level functional recovery at 12 months. The distribution of Glasgow Outcome Scale–Extended (GOSE) scores was comparable between the two groups (adjusted Odds Ratio [aOR] 0.87, 95% CI 0.61–1.21).
Distribution of 12-month GOSE scores for early vs. delayed cranioplasty groups.
Similarly, quality of life, measured by QOLIBRI scores, showed no significant difference, with median scores of 68 for the early group and 64 for the delayed group.
Complications and Subgroup Analysis
While functional outcomes were similar, the study identified a significant trade-off regarding complications. Patients in the early cranioplasty group faced a fourfold higher risk of hydrocephalus (12% vs. 4%; aOR 4.0, 95% CI 1.2–16). This is likely due to the restriction of brain expansion and altered cerebrospinal fluid dynamics when the bone flap is replaced early.
However, a notable exception was found in patients with major extracranial injuries (polytrauma). In this subgroup, early cranioplasty was associated with significantly better functional outcomes (aOR 1.9, 95% CI 1.3–2.7). The authors suggest that early skull stabilization allows these patients to engage more safely and vigorously in physical rehabilitation.
Subgroup analysis of adjusted odds ratios for functional outcome (GOSE) at 12 months.
The study suggests that for the majority of TBI patients, the timing of cranioplasty (before or after 90 days) does not dictate long-term neurological recovery. From a logistical perspective, performing the procedure early—potentially during the initial hospital admission—can streamline the chain of care and avoid the costs and risks associated with a second hospital stay.
Clinicians opting for early cranioplasty must remain vigilant for the increased risk of hydrocephalus. For patients with significant extracranial injuries, early reconstruction may offer a specific rehabilitative advantage. Future randomized controlled trials are needed to further refine these timing windows and incorporate health economic analyses to weigh the benefits of streamlined care against the costs of managing increased complications like hydrocephalus.
Summary updated
Abstract
Functional outcome and quality of life were similar between early and delayed cranioplasty in patients who had undergone DC for TBI. Neurosurgeons may consider performing cranioplasty during the index admission (early) to simplify the patient's chain of care and prevent readmission for cranioplasty but should be vigilant for an increased possibility of hydrocephalus. Clinical trial registration nos.: CENTER-TBI, NCT02210221 (clinicaltrials.gov); Net-QuRe, NTR6003 (trialsearch.who.int) and NL5761 (onderzoekmetmensen.nl).
BibTeX
@article{vreeburg2024early,
author = {Rick Vreeburg and Ranjit D. Singh and Inge A. M. van Erp and Tommi K. Korhonen and John K. Yue and Harry Mee and Ivan Timofeev and Angelos G. Kolias and Adel Helmy and Bart Depreitere and Wouter A. Moojen and Alexander Younsi and Peter J. Hutchinson and Geoffrey T. Manley and Ewout W. Steyerberg and Godard C. W. de Ruiter and Andrew I.R. Maas and Wilco C. Peul and Jeroen T.J.M. van Dijck and Hugo F. den Boogert and Jussi P. Posti and Thomas A. van Essen and Cecilia Åkerlund and Krisztina Amrein and Nada Anđelić and Lasse Andreassen and Audny Anke and Anna Antoni and Gérard Audibert and Philippe Azouvi and Maria Luisa Azzolini and Ronald Bartels and Pál Barzó and Romuald Beauvais and Ronny Beer and Bo‐Michael Bellander and Antonio Belli and Habib Benali and Maurizio Berardino and Luigi Beretta and Morten Blaabjerg and Peter Bragge and Alexandra Bražinová and Vibeke Brinck and Joanne Brooker and Camilla Brorsson and András Büki and Monika Bullinger and Manuel Cabeleira and Alessio Caccioppola and Emiliana Calappi and Maria Rosa Calvi and Peter Cameron and Guillermo Carbayo Lozano and Marco Carbonara and Simona Cavallo and Giorgio Chevallard and Arturo Chieregato and Giuseppe Citerio and Hans Clusmann and Mark Coburn and Jonathan Coles and D. James Cooper and Marta Correia and Amra Čović and Nicola Curry and Endre Czeiter and Marek Czosnyka and Claire Dahyot‐Fizelier and Paul Dark and Helen Dawes and Véronique De Keyser and Vincent Degos and Françesco Della Corte and Hugo den Boogert and Bart Depreitere and Đula Đilvesi and Abhishek Dixit and Emma Donoghue and Jens P. Dreier and Guy‐Loup Dulière and Ari Ercole and Patrick Esser and Erzsébet Ezer and Martin Fabricius and Valery L. Feigin and Kelly Foks and Shirin Frisvold and Alex Furmanov and Pablo Gagliardo and Damien Galanaud and Dashiell Gantner and Guoyi Gao and Pradeep George and Alexandre Ghuysen and Lelde Giga and Ben Glocker and Jagoš Golubović and Pedro A. Gómez},
title = {{Early versus delayed cranioplasty after decompressive craniectomy in traumatic brain injury: a multicenter observational study within CENTER-TBI and Net-QuRe}},
journal = {Journal of Neurosurgery},
year = {2024},
doi = {10.3171/2024.1.jns232172},
}