Early-Stage Growth Mechanism and Synthesis Conditions-Dependent Morphology of Nanocrystalline Bi Films Electrodeposited from Perchlorate Electrolyte

Д.и. Тишкевич, С. С. Грабчиков, T.i. Zubar, D.s. Vasin, Sergei Trukhanov, A.i. Vorobjova, Dzmitry Yakimchuk, Аrtem L. Kozlovskiy, Maxim V. Zdorovets, Sh. Giniyatova, Dmitriy Shimanovich, Dmitry Lyakhov, Dominik L. Michels, Mengge Dong, S.a. Gudkova, А.в. ТрухановNanomaterials 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the early-stage growth of bismuth (Bi) films electrodeposited from a perchlorate electrolyte. Researchers discovered a novel co-deposition of lead (Pb) and Bi at very short deposition times (1 second), explaining this phenomenon and proposing a two-stage growth mechanism that transitions from a Pb-rich pillar-like structure to a pure Bi granular form. This work offers a new method for creating high-quality, dense nanocrystalline Bi films with controlled morphology for applications requiring high density.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bismuth (Bi) is a semimetal with unique electronic and thermoelectric properties, making it attractive for applications in spintronics, radiation detection, and as a lead-free alternative for radiation shielding. While various methods exist for synthesizing Bi films, understanding the precise growth mechanisms, especially at the initial stages of electrochemical deposition, is crucial for controlling film morphology and properties. Specifically, the authors highlight a lack of comprehensive understanding regarding the nucleation and growth of Bi films electrodeposited from perchlorate electrolytes, particularly concerning the influence of short deposition durations and the potential for unexpected co-deposition. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by systematically studying the early-stage growth of Bi films under varying electrochemical conditions.

Methods

The researchers employed electrochemical deposition in a galvanostatic regime to produce Bi films on copper (Cu) substrates. They systematically varied the deposition duration (from 1 to 30 seconds) and current density (10-20 mA/cm²). To characterize the resulting films, a suite of advanced techniques was utilized:

  • Polarization Measurements: Used to determine the optimal range of current densities for Bi electrodeposition.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): Employed to investigate the surface morphology and microstructure of the films.
  • Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): Used for detailed surface topography analysis and grain size distribution.
  • Energy-Dispersive X-ray Microanalysis (EDX): Utilized to determine the elemental composition of the films.
  • Nanoindentation: Used to estimate film thickness.

Custom software and the Gwyddion program were used for image processing and statistical analysis of porosity and grain size, respectively.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from the electrodeposition process and subsequent characterization of the synthesized films.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unexpected Pb-Bi Co-deposition: For the first time, the paper demonstrates and explains the co-deposition of lead (Pb) and bismuth (Bi) when deposition duration is as short as 1 second. This is attributed to the presence of Pb impurities in the Bi anodes and the thermodynamic favorability of Pb reduction at the initial stages.
  • Two-Stage Growth Mechanism: A novel two-stage growth mechanism for Bi films from perchlorate electrolyte is proposed. The first stage (approx. 1 second) involves Pb-Bi co-deposition, forming a Pb-rich phase with a pillar-like morphology. The second stage involves the growth of pure Bi, transitioning to a granular and eventually layered granular structure.
  • Morphology Evolution: The film morphology evolves significantly with deposition duration and current density. It transitions from pillar-like (Pb-rich) to granular and then to a layered granular structure characteristic of rhombohedral Bi. This evolution is linked to the development of a strong Bi growth texture and coalescence effects.
  • Closely-Packed Microstructure: Investigations into film porosity reveal that the electrodeposited Bi films exhibit a closely-packed microstructure, with porosity decreasing as deposition duration and current density increase. This suggests potential for applications requiring high density.
  • Perchlorate Electrolyte Advantages: The perchlorate electrolyte is highlighted for its ability to achieve homogeneous and dense coatings with high deposition rates and near 100% current efficiency, making it suitable for applications like radiation shielding.

Key Results

  • Optimal Current Density Range: Polarization measurements identified an optimal current density range of 10-20 mA/cm² for Bi electrodeposition in the perchlorate electrolyte.
  • Compositional Phases: Three distinct compositional phases were observed: a Pb-rich phase (up to 84.5% Pb), a Bi-rich phase (up to 1.9% Pb), and a pure Bi phase. The duration required to reach the pure Bi phase decreased with increasing current density.
  • Deposition Rate: The deposition rate increased with deposition duration, exhibiting a sublinear behavior. Higher current densities generally led to higher deposition rates.
  • Grain Size: Increasing deposition duration from 1 to 30 seconds led to a significant rise in average grain size, with higher current densities promoting a more abrupt increase.
  • Porosity Reduction: Porosity decreased with increasing deposition duration and current density, with average porosity dropping from 10.6% for Pb-rich films to 1.8% for pure Bi films.
  • Morphological Changes: SEM images clearly show the transition from pillar-like structures (1 s) to granular (5 s) and then layered granular morphologies (15 s and beyond) as deposition progresses.

Limitations and Future Work

  • EDX Limitations at Short Durations: The authors acknowledge that EDX analysis can introduce errors for very short deposition durations (1 s) due to the thinness of the deposited film, potentially affecting quantitative analysis of component ratios.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) would be a more accurate technique for studying the quantitative elemental ratios in electrodeposited films. They also indicate that future work will focus on further investigating the influence of electrodeposition synthesis conditions on the quantitative ratio of components and studying the crystal structure of the films. The potential for pulse deposition to further control morphology is also mentioned.

Summary updated

Abstract

Bi nanocrystalline films were formed from perchlorate electrolyte (PE) on Cu substrate via electrochemical deposition with different duration and current densities. The microstructural, morphological properties, and elemental composition were studied using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM), and energy-dispersive X-ray microanalysis (EDX). The optimal range of current densities for Bi electrodeposition in PE using polarization measurements was demonstrated. For the first time, it was shown and explained why, with a deposition duration of 1 s, co-deposition of Pb and Bi occurs. The correlation between synthesis conditions and chemical composition and microstructure for Bi films was discussed. The analysis of the microstructure evolution revealed the changing mechanism of the films' growth from pillar-like (for Pb-rich phase) to layered granular form (for Bi) with deposition duration rising. This abnormal behavior is explained by the appearance of a strong Bi growth texture and coalescence effects. The investigations of porosity showed that Bi films have a closely-packed microstructure. The main stages and the growth mechanism of Bi films in the galvanostatic regime in PE with a deposition duration of 1-30 s are proposed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{2020early,
  author = {Д.И. Тишкевич and С. С. Грабчиков and T.I. Zubar and D.S. Vasin and Sergei Trukhanov and A.I. Vorobjova and Dzmitry Yakimchuk and Аrtem L. Kozlovskiy and Maxim V. Zdorovets and Sh. Giniyatova and Dmitriy Shimanovich and Dmitry Lyakhov and Dominik L. Michels and Mengge Dong and S.A. Gudkova and А.В. Труханов},
  title = {{Early-Stage Growth Mechanism and Synthesis Conditions-Dependent Morphology of Nanocrystalline Bi Films Electrodeposited from Perchlorate Electrolyte}},
  booktitle = {Nanomaterials},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/nano10061245},
}
Figure