Early life cognitive development trajectories and intelligence quotient in middle childhood and early adolescence in rural western China

Zhonghai Zhu, Suying Chang, Yue Cheng, Qi Qi, Shaoru Li, Mohamed Elhoumed, Hong Yan, Michael J. Dibley, Wafaie Fawzi, Lingxia Zeng, Christopher R. SudfeldScientific 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies four distinct trajectories of cognitive development in early childhood in rural China, revealing that these early patterns are strong predictors of cognitive abilities in middle childhood and adolescence. The findings highlight the critical importance of early interventions, particularly those addressing nutrition and maternal education, for long-term human capital development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how early childhood cognitive development unfolds and its long-term impact is crucial, especially in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) where millions of children fail to reach their full potential. While it's known that early adversities can have lasting consequences, most studies have only assessed cognitive development at a single time point. This approach fails to capture the dynamic nature of development and how different developmental paths might lead to varying long-term outcomes. This paper aims to address this gap by identifying distinct trajectories of cognitive development in the first few years of life and examining their association with later cognitive abilities.

Methods

The researchers employed Group-Based Trajectory Modeling (GBTM), a statistical technique used to identify distinct developmental pathways within a population based on repeated measurements. They used longitudinal data from a birth cohort in rural China, assessing cognitive development at multiple points from infancy (3 to 30 months) through early adolescence (10-12 years). The Bayley Scales of Infant Development (BSID-II) were used for infant assessments, and the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-IV) was used for older children. GBTM allowed them to group children into distinct trajectory subgroups based on their cognitive z-scores over time. They then used multivariate multinomial logistic regression and generalized estimating equations to identify predictors of these trajectories and their association with later cognitive outcomes.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a prospective birth cohort of 1388 children in rural western China. This cohort was originally part of a randomized trial of antenatal micronutrient supplementation. Cognitive development was assessed at six time points: 3, 6, 12, 18, 24, and 30 months of age, followed by assessments in middle childhood (7-9 years) and early adolescence (10-12 years).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Developmental Trajectories Matter: Simply looking at a single cognitive score in infancy isn't enough. The pattern of development over time is a powerful predictor of later cognitive abilities.
  • "Catch-Up" is Real, but Not Universal: One identified trajectory showed children starting below average but improving significantly. This highlights the potential for early interventions to alter developmental paths.
  • Early Disadvantages Persist: The trajectory of children who started below average and then declined showed the lowest cognitive scores in adolescence, suggesting that early disadvantages, if not addressed, can have lasting effects.
  • Maternal Education is a Strong Protective Factor: Each additional year of maternal education significantly reduced the risk of a child following a declining cognitive trajectory.
  • Prenatal Nutrition is Key: Supplementation with multiple micronutrients for at least 180 days during pregnancy was associated with a lower risk of suboptimal developmental trajectories.
  • Birth Weight is a Critical Indicator: Low birth weight (LBW) was a significant risk factor for being in the declining cognitive trajectory group.

Key Results

  • Four Trajectories Identified:
    1. Start below average-then decrease (3.2% of participants)
    2. Start below average-then increase (10.2%)
    3. Consistently average (40.3%)
    4. Consistently above average (46.3%)
  • Predictors of Declining Trajectory: Low birth weight infants were 10.60 times more likely to be in the "start below average-then decline" group. Each grade increase in maternal education decreased the risk of being in this group by 73%.
  • Long-Term Cognitive Impact: Infants in the "consistently above average" trajectory had 8.02 points higher IQ in adolescence compared to those in the "start below average-then decline" group.
  • Intervention Impact: Multiple micronutrient supplementation for ≥180 days was associated with a reduced risk of being in the "start below average-then improve" and "consistently average" groups compared to the "consistently above average" group.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Follow-up Rate: The follow-up rate for middle childhood and adolescence was around 50%, raising concerns about potential bias due to dependent censoring. However, they conducted sensitivity analyses (using Inverse Probability Weighting - IPW) which suggested their main findings were robust.
  • Subgroup Size: GBTM can sometimes result in small subgroup sizes, which may limit statistical power for further analyses.
  • Generalizability: The identified trajectories and their predictors might be specific to the rural Chinese population studied and may not be directly applicable to other settings.
  • Biological Mechanisms: The study did not examine the underlying biological mechanisms linking predictors to cognitive trajectories.

Future work could focus on replicating these findings in diverse populations, exploring the biological underpinnings of these trajectories, and developing targeted interventions based on these insights to improve long-term human capital.

Summary updated

Abstract

The relationship of cognitive developmental trajectories during the dynamic first years with later life development outcomes remains unclear in low- and middle-income countries. 1388 Children born to women who participated in a randomized trial of antenatal micronutrient supplementation in rural China were prospectively followed. Cognitive development was assessed six times between 3 and 30 months of age using Bayley Scales of Infant Development, and then in mid-childhood (7-9 years) and early adolescence (10-12 years) using Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children. We identified four distinct infant cognitive development trajectory subgroups using group-based trajectory modeling: (i) consistently above average, (ii) consistently average, (iii) started below average and then improved, and (iv) started below average and then declined. LBW infants (<2500 g) were 10.60 times (95% CI 3.57, 31.49) more likely to be in the trajectory group that started below average and then declined, while each grade increase in maternal education decreased the risk of being in this group by 73% (95% CI 54%, 84%). Infants who performed consistently above average had 8.02 (95% CI 1.46, 14.59) points higher IQ in adolescence versus the declining trajectory group. These findings suggest that interventions to improve early child development trajectories may produce long-term human capital benefits.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2019early,
  author = {Zhonghai Zhu and Suying Chang and Yue Cheng and Qi Qi and Shaoru Li and Mohamed Elhoumed and Hong Yan and Michael J. Dibley and Wafaie Fawzi and Lingxia Zeng and Christopher R. Sudfeld},
  title = {{Early life cognitive development trajectories and intelligence quotient in middle childhood and early adolescence in rural western China}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-54755-1},
}
Figure